TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Show HN: Jet – Codeship’s CI Platform for Docker

15 pointsby moritzplassnigover 9 years ago

5 comments

efficacyover 9 years ago
I love the idea of this, and I have been spending a lot of time recently with docker compose and jet. The problem I keep coming up against is the lack of documentation for jet. It uses a similar-but-different approach to docker compose. Docker compose has tons of stuff available, but is focussed strongly on describing a complete live system rather than setting up for CI. Unfortunately, so far I have been completely unable to find any detailed documentation for jet other than a few examples which don&#x27;t do quite what I need, so fussing with jet&#x27;s yml files takes much longer and is very frustrating.<p>I know the product is quite new, and I&#x27;m willing to cut it a bit of slack. I&#x27;m also willing to contribute to a beta program or write documentation, blog posts etc. to help others if there&#x27;s any way I could get access to more detailed information (source code with an NDA if that&#x27;s all you have)<p>Can anyone help?
评论 #11216037 未加载
evancordellover 9 years ago
I&#x27;ve been evaluating the new Docker platform for a few months, and I definitely prefer it to anything else I&#x27;ve used. It fills a void that I was frustrated existed - there aren&#x27;t, or at least weren&#x27;t, any CI hosts that would take a repository with a docker-compose.yml file and let you run tests against the services defined therein. To be clear, Jet doesn&#x27;t do this exactly, but it does let you define services with the same format as docker-compose.yml which I&#x27;ve found to be even more useful.<p>Currently we use a custom AMI (with docker and compose installed) running bamboo on bamboo&#x27;s on-demand service, but we&#x27;ve been bitten a couple of times as Bamboo updates their protocols without notice and causes our agents to start failing. It&#x27;s not an issue if you use their official AMIs, but maintaining your own is not as easy as you&#x27;d hope.<p>That said, I have had some problems with the support channels at CodeShip. I know I&#x27;ve just been a free user evaluating the service and am probably not a high priority, but my experience hasn&#x27;t been positive.<p>After activating Docker builds for my account, I was unable to get a test build working. It turns out that this was because of an unusual bug with service names (if I named my service `web`, it would attempt to load up what looked like an internal codeship container instead of the one specified in my config), but I didn&#x27;t know that at the time.<p>My first support request was simply ignored. After a couple more months I decided to try a build again, but the bug was still affecting me. My second support request was dismissed as a temporary problem with the docker build services (&quot;running out of resources&quot;) which seemed unlikely given the circumstances.<p>Through trial and error I discovered the service naming issue and followed up on my support ticket to report it. No response to that, either.<p>All in all I came away thinking it was a pretty nice service with pretty lousy support.
MalcolmDiggsover 9 years ago
Really excited about this. Getting docker to play nice with CI&#x2F;CD tools has been a major pain for me. Ended up writing way-to-many custom scripts to handle the meat of the processes, but I was hoping there would be a better way. Now it sounds like there is!
moritzplassnigover 9 years ago
@Evan: Thanks for the feedback, great to hear that. I&#x27;m sorry for the bad support experience you got. We&#x27;re currently building out our tooling for providing a better support experience and are prioritizing paid customer over anybody else. I hope we can share some of those learnings in a blog post soon.
moritzplassnigover 9 years ago
Codeship founder&#x2F;ceo here: We would love to get your feedback! Contact details @ profile :)