TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Show HN: Use Meetup.com Data to Find Your Ideal City

104 pointsby ponderingHplusover 8 years ago

15 comments

erex78over 8 years ago
This is cool and a nice idea &#x2F; UI, but it seems to bubble up populations centers. Needs to normalize for population somehow. (<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;xkcd.com&#x2F;1138&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;xkcd.com&#x2F;1138&#x2F;</a>)
评论 #12400595 未加载
评论 #12400178 未加载
timothycrosleyover 8 years ago
I think meetup.com is a fairly poor data source for these kind of questions - even if the data was normalized. Interested in Coffee? Seattle is better then NY, but is way less likely to have meetups dedicated to it since they are just baked into the culture - so theres a higher probability that the unrelated meetup you will be hosted at a local coffee shop.
评论 #12402191 未加载
评论 #12402771 未加载
dansoover 8 years ago
Very cool. I haven&#x27;t looked at what Meetup has available for an API but I&#x27;ve rarely ever seen its data used as a way to find out about a city, even though it&#x27;s a great way to (manually) look up interests. You&#x27;d miss out on things that are on Eventbrite (but no reason why you couldn&#x27;t combine their data...), but otherwise, it seems like a solid way to at least find hotspots for interests, particularly regional cities (i.e. not New York&#x2F;SF&#x2F;Chicago) that have, for whatever reason, an especially strong group.
ponderingHplusover 8 years ago
I published a quick writeup to accompany the visualization here: <a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;cole-maclean.github.io&#x2F;blog&#x2F;Meetup.com%20City%20Finder&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;cole-maclean.github.io&#x2F;blog&#x2F;Meetup.com%20City%20Finde...</a>
评论 #12400880 未加载
Splendorover 8 years ago
I put in &quot;fishing, hiking, &amp; skiing&quot; and the #1 recommendation is NYC.
lumberjackover 8 years ago
Doesn&#x27;t work very well for people who don&#x27;t want to live in the US. For every topic there are exponentially more American meetup groups so even if I insert tons of topics related to my country and only my country the top picks are still in the US.
erikbover 8 years ago
Actually that&#x27;s part of what I do manually. However, in Berlin (my favorite city so far) meetup seems to go down. Fewer events in general, fewer interesting ones, and more events where nobody shows up. 2012 it was awesome, but in 2016 fun is hard to come by. I don&#x27;t know, maybe they increased the payment in the meantime or something or maybe I&#x27;m just getting too old.
评论 #12402351 未加载
initramover 8 years ago
If I double-click on the globe, it zooms in, and then I can&#x27;t rotate the globe anymore. I also don&#x27;t see how to zoom back out!
cheriotover 8 years ago
Cool! I&#x27;ve used meetup to meet people while traveling and it&#x27;s gone really well. I&#x27;ve thought about making a tool for that. Did you scrape meetup, use their api, or is there a data dump available?
评论 #12403952 未加载
DogPawHatover 8 years ago
Looked up my home city of Dublin, Ireland. Apparently we&#x27;re number one for &quot;sober activities&quot;. Which both surprises and doesn&#x27;t surprise me at the same time (Plenty of people tired of Irish pub culture using it as an alternative place to find social events)
arcticfoxover 8 years ago
I can&#x27;t tell if this is getting hammered right now or I&#x27;m not using it correctly. I put a topic in and nothing happens...<p>It did work for one topic after a while, but I&#x27;m not sure if I was just lucky or did something different.<p>Great idea though, I hope I can get it working later!
评论 #12400720 未加载
angryostrichover 8 years ago
If I put in anything mah jong related it removes all the previous topics and resets the page. I&#x27;ve tried with &#x27;mahjongg&#x27; and &#x27;mah jong&#x27;. Though &#x27;mahjong&#x27; seems ok, it just doesn&#x27;t pull anything.
chewxyover 8 years ago
I put in all my interests (and current meetup groups) and Brisbane was in the top 10 list. The funny thing is I moved FROM Brisbane to Sydney (for better jobs)
baccheionover 8 years ago
Usually (taken from erf&#x2F;error based on sample size), something grows proportional to the square root of the sample size. If using raw sample sizes, you can apply a square root to that sample size before using it (meters its impact).<p>Also, perhaps you could do something like establish an overall average and standard deviation &quot;percentage interested&quot; in each topic, then compare the percentage in a given location with the expected. The farther the percentage from the expected (in either direction), the more that location gets pulled up or down. For example, maybe every location is equally good if you&#x27;re interested in &quot;breathing air&quot;, but then maybe one has a slightly higher concentration, making it more relevant.<p>Also, as you are combining several interests, you are trying to maximize coverage and uniqueness (maximum number of interests present in the maximum amount, with stronger interests given more weight (though you don&#x27;t ask anyone to rank interests), such that locations having them getting a boost). That is, one location shouldn&#x27;t dominate the rankings due to a much higher likelihood of having one interest, while having the other interests being &quot;averagely represented&quot; or worse.<p>That is, maybe the proper way to combine the standard deviations for each place is through multiplication (take the absolute value, then &quot;multiply in&quot; if standard deviation is positive or &quot;divide in&quot; if standard deviation is negative). This will ensure that below average &quot;satisfaction of interests&quot; divide&#x2F;lower the ranking score and that positive &quot;SOIs&quot; multiply&#x2F;increase it.<p>Also, it&#x27;s good to pull the ranking score from a mean&#x2F;center&#x2F;expectation with each &quot;interest score&quot;, rather than just blindly averaging&#x2F;kludging them in. The standard deviation approach achieves this, but I&#x27;m mentioning it explicitly such that you can consider it in the event something other than standard deviations are used.<p>There could also be something done to boost a city with meetups for a rare interest (the smaller the overall percentage, the more weight a location gets). For example, if 2% overall are interested in Cricket and 20% in design, then a city with an overall percentage of 3% cricket should be boosted more than a city with an overall percentage of 30% design, even though the proportion &quot;above the norm&quot; is the same, as Cricket is &quot;hard to find&quot; or a rarity.<p>Also, if you could factor in the area of a city, then that could enhance the scores further (5k out of 5 million people in New York means something entirely different than 5k out of 5 million in a sprawling suburbia, as population density makes it more likely the 5K in New York will be accessible).<p>See what I&#x27;m getting at?
评论 #12403977 未加载
cloudjackerover 8 years ago
amazing representations of the midwest, from that data