TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Legendary Apple Engineer Gets Rejected for Genius Bar Job

113 pointsby pavornyohover 8 years ago

17 comments

hoodoofover 8 years ago
It goes the other way too. The older I get, the less inclined I am to work for any company. I just no longer believe in really any corporate mission. I&#x27;m not inclined to work hard for anyone except me. Most companies seem to be doing things that are either uninteresting or trivial or silly.<p>I was super ambitious and worked super hard for other people when I was younger and now why the heck should I do that for some other company?
评论 #12433250 未加载
评论 #12433374 未加载
aluminussomaover 8 years ago
I have wanted to run an experiment of famous programmers or computer scientists applying to jobs at Google&#x2F;Facebook&#x2F;Etc (under an assumed identity) and seeing if they get rejected. My hypothesis is that there would be several notable rejections.<p>Unfortunately, I do not not anyone well enough to conduct this experiment.
评论 #12432779 未加载
评论 #12432686 未加载
评论 #12432979 未加载
WhitneyLandover 8 years ago
As some one in their 40&#x27;s I&#x27;m really hoping this situation will improve.<p>One bad thing is there does not seem to be much social stigma against this kind of discrimination. You could engage in it, talk about it with friends, and probably not raise a eyebrow.
评论 #12432908 未加载
评论 #12433089 未加载
vegetablepotpieover 8 years ago
On face value this story seems ironic, but there’s a lot of questions in my mind. What is the skill set overlap between an Apple engineer and an Apple genius? Although Mr. Scheinberg’s experience may be useful in addressing technical issues, would a retired engineer be able to comfortably transition to a customer service role at Apple?
评论 #12432678 未加载
X-Istenceover 8 years ago
My local Apple store has a bunch of older people working in the store. They are often just as knowledgeable as the younger kids running around, and have all kinds of cool stories to tell about how things &quot;used to be done&quot;.<p>I actually prefer to work with one of the older people when making my purchase because I don&#x27;t feel nearly as rushed and it seems to me to be a lot more personal...
评论 #12433090 未加载
pipio21over 8 years ago
You could be a great engineer but horrible in sales, or dealing with troubled customers like in this case.<p>Just because companies have the ability to discriminate you, does not mean you can accuse them of age discrimination that is based on your prejudices, not on reality.
Angosturaover 8 years ago
So, how is he chatting with people who may know irritating little about their iPhones etc? What are his people skills like?
Mikeb85over 8 years ago
So? It&#x27;s a sales job, not an engineering job.
评论 #12432911 未加载
peter303over 8 years ago
Ive seen a older sales people in some Apple stores. A good sales manager knows customers relate to people their own age.
评论 #12432693 未加载
Mithalduover 8 years ago
Do american interviewers actually say, entirely unqualified, &quot;we&#x27;ll be in touch&quot;, and then never actually send ANY follow-up?
wtbobover 8 years ago
Weird, the text is an inch wide. Given that the three inches of whitespace on either side of the text haven&#x27;t changed width, I guess we know which part of their site Business Insider think is most important.
koolbaover 8 years ago
Besides the sanctity of old people as a reliable voting block, why is age discrimination a problem? If companies are stupid enough to not hire good candidates, or under pay the ones they do hire, then they&#x27;ll lose out against the better companies that don&#x27;t do those things.<p>Plus, it&#x27;s my understanding[1] that it&#x27;s not discrimination to refuse to hire someone for being &quot;too young&quot; or &quot;too inexperienced&quot;. How is that not discrimination if the bright eyed youngster is equally qualified?<p>[1]: <i>If there&#x27;s someone with the appropriate legal background, please correct me if I&#x27;m wrong.</i>
评论 #12432665 未加载
评论 #12432596 未加载
评论 #12432616 未加载
评论 #12432617 未加载
评论 #12432560 未加载
评论 #12432618 未加载
评论 #12432660 未加载
评论 #12432884 未加载
dogma1138over 8 years ago
Could also be easily a case of being overly qualified of them not even taking the application seriously because if some one sent a CV that looks like his to any entry level tech support &#x2F; sales support position they would most likely assume it&#x27;s a gag.<p>Overall hiring overqualified people is a problem, they might never be happy and they can easily undermine the structure of a company even unintentionally.<p>This is like hiring some one like Wozniak to do entry level programming at a company hell undermine everyone from the team leader upto the CTO just for being who he is.
评论 #12432424 未加载
评论 #12432457 未加载
评论 #12432468 未加载
Hydraulix989over 8 years ago
This reminds me of the outrage when Uber kicked Sebastian Thrun off its platform when he worked as an Uber driver offering people rides in his Model S (founder of Google X, inventor of the modern &quot;self-driving&quot; car).<p>I think all you have to do is say the legendary engineer is &quot;over-qualified&quot; for this position -- I mean, you can&#x27;t jump to age-ist conclusions right away when Michael Jordan applies to play high school basketball.
hoodoofover 8 years ago
Call this an unfair generalization if you must, but old people are no good at everything.<p>- Moe from &quot;The Simpsons&quot;
评论 #12434301 未加载
Pica_soOover 8 years ago
Does age discrimination even uphold for remote work?
steaminghackerover 8 years ago
so, they didn&#x27;t bother checking his cv?