TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

How “Dirty” MP3 Files Are A Back Door Into Cloud DRM

22 pointsby thomasreggiabout 15 years ago

4 comments

seanmcqabout 15 years ago
Wait, I thought the point of anti-DRM was to do whatever we want with the music. We can now do that. As far as I can tell this article calls anything that inconveniences rampant theft DRM.
评论 #1246393 未加载
评论 #1246783 未加载
dotBenabout 15 years ago
"Apple, Google and Amazon are all reportedly in discussions with big labels to provide a cloud music service. ... The labels, say our source, are demanding that a user can only stream music that is watermarked to their username. Change the username, or try to stream music that you’ve ripped from a CD, and those songs won’t play."<p>It's a stupid idea to propose that you wouldn't be able to access music you put into the cloud that didn't have your personal watermark in it.<p>Let's assume Johnny has an all-legal music collection dating back 10 years - consisting of iTunes (watermarked) MP3s, Amazon (non watermarked) MP3s and a ton of self-ripped MP3s from his old CD collection (non watermarked).<p>There is no way Apple, Amazon or anyone else would find success and adoption in a system that would only let him play the watermarked files purchased from iTunes but deny him playing the rest of his legal collection.<p>Anyone building such a system, regardless of the music industries demands, needs to find a new product manager.
thomasreggiabout 15 years ago
This is really the only way to crack down on copyright issues, watermark each file with some information pining it to the buyer. When you combined this with the cloud, only or someone with your username can access the media (I'd bet they'd rather some biometrics). Interesting stuff.
steve19about 15 years ago
Seems like a good compromise to me.
评论 #1246816 未加载