TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Girls' Life vs. Boys' Life? Magazine Cover Sparks Uproar

26 pointsby marcusgarveyover 8 years ago

6 comments

Spooky23over 8 years ago
The problem is that with all of the bullshit aside, they need to sell the magazine to some dwindling population still buying them.<p>The &quot;heartwarming&quot;, positive cover is indeed heartwarming and a good message, but is also pretty lame, and unlikely to sell magazines.<p>I also question whether this is typical shallow&#x2F;ignorant internet outrage. When I was a kid, Boy&#x27;a Life was a Boy Scouts magazine, and had annual themes that appeared every year at the same time. If you looked at the May&#x2F;June cover, the annual Boy Scout Jamboree issue wouldn&#x27;t be as &quot;internet offensive&quot;.
home_boiover 8 years ago
IIRC, Boy&#x27;s Life magazine is run by a boy scout organization while Girl&#x27;s Life is run by a corporation chasing for the most eyeballs possible.
评论 #12575525 未加载
relics443over 8 years ago
Maybe it&#x27;s just my lack of need for external influence, but why is this a big deal? I think women can and should be whatever they want to be. A trashy magazine shouldn&#x27;t change that.<p>Should A Girl&#x27;s Life change the tone of their stories? That&#x27;s up to the market. As long as their demographic enjoys what they print (which translates to $$$), they&#x27;ll continue to run it. Should people be outraged by it? If they choose to be, yes. But at the end of the day a consumer is a consumer, and if they want trash they&#x27;ll get it.
评论 #12576156 未加载
hammockover 8 years ago
There are plenty of men&#x27;s magazines that will offer you a &quot;denim checklist.&quot;
trav4225over 8 years ago
This is indeed a humorous juxtaposition, but they wouldn&#x27;t make crap like that if our society didn&#x27;t gobble it up.
marcusgarveyover 8 years ago
Why was this flagged?
评论 #12576136 未加载