TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

The Size and Shape of “Idea Space” (2011) [pdf]

30 pointsby bridgelandover 8 years ago

3 comments

jmmcdover 8 years ago
Fascinating!<p>The <i>methods</i> are very interesting -- a threshold (similar to &quot;just noticeable difference&quot; (JND) used in cognitive&#x2F;perceptual science); an attempt at estimating the size of the space; an attempt using Hausdorff dimension to approximate the number of dimensions (one could consider a multi-dimensional scaling approach to this too).<p>But the choice of data and features means the <i>results</i> shouldn&#x27;t be taken too seriously:<p>&gt; We have implemented such a capability using feature counting, where a feature can be a word or phrase with statistically significant frequency, or the author’s name, or specific text from popup-menu selections, or if available, background database demographics about the author (his or her department, location, title, etc.).<p>If you use e.g. author&#x27;s name and demographics as features, then this will contaminate the features that describe the ideas themselves. The rest of the results just aren&#x27;t worth reading about until that problem is fixed.
fallingfrogover 8 years ago
I wonder if the dimensionality 14 is something intrinsic to idea spaces in general, or if they&#x27;re actually measuring the dimensionality of the human brain&#x27;s storage of ideas? Or something about the English language even?
评论 #13080852 未加载
diyseguyover 8 years ago
Seems like if you stood in the middle of the 14 dimensional space - every idea is 7 dimensions away - our typical mental stack depth. Perhaps if you could go to one more extra step away you could come up with really new ideas that haven&#x27;t been thought of before.