TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

How to run a meeting (1976)

147 pointsby trendoidover 8 years ago

13 comments

cgioover 8 years ago
My take: 0) invite the right people 1) send all relevant reading material 2 days before meeting 2) have an agenda for the meeting - in the invitation 3) agree who runs the meeting 4) follow the agenda, keep a log of issues that hijack the discussion but leave it at that and keep on with the subject 5) document decisions 6) send email with decisions&#x2F;actions<p>Not that complex. I run meetings quite often, and they always work fine. Now workshops are a different think...
评论 #13183340 未加载
评论 #13189501 未加载
dammitcoetzeeover 8 years ago
There are sections of this that overlap with how I treat meetings, but overall it seems like a bunch of verbal fluff that&#x27;s the opposite of what a meeting should be. Exceedingly clear, short, and purposeful.<p>I learned a more pragmatic, even meeting-hostile approach to meetings: <a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;hackaday.com&#x2F;2016&#x2F;10&#x2F;06&#x2F;life-on-contract-how-to-have-a-meeting&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;hackaday.com&#x2F;2016&#x2F;10&#x2F;06&#x2F;life-on-contract-how-to-have-...</a>
评论 #13179156 未加载
评论 #13179530 未加载
评论 #13180576 未加载
hkonover 8 years ago
How meetings are run:<p>1) Wait 5 to 10 minutes for everyone to join<p>2) Spend additional 5 minutes getting your computer hooked into the projector and shared with remote participants<p>3) Read through your powerpoint<p>4) Ask for feedback. Receive comments about your choice of font for the powerpoint.<p>5) Thank everyone for the meeting and head to the next one.
评论 #13180921 未加载
scrabbleover 8 years ago
This is helpful for me. I serve on a local board and this very much describes the type of discourse that occurs there. For reference, we run the meetings according to Bourinot&#x27;s rules of order: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.amazon.com&#x2F;Bourinots-Rules-Order-Assemblies-Shareholders-ebook&#x2F;dp&#x2F;B004JN1CGK&#x2F;ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&amp;qid=1481744194&amp;sr=8-1&amp;keywords=bourinot%27s+rules+of+order" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.amazon.com&#x2F;Bourinots-Rules-Order-Assemblies-Shar...</a><p>By the same token, this is not terrible useful for me in terms of work meetings which are extremely informal in comparison. They are also intended to achieve a different goal.<p>I&#x27;d say that both types of meetings are appropriate for their goals, but I&#x27;ve also been surprised at just how effective the more formal meetings have been in achieving progress and consensus.
ThomPeteover 8 years ago
I avoid meetings like the plague. Even when I was running a company with 80 people I would ask if I was necessary or my input was necessary. If not I wouldn&#x27;t accept.<p>Meetings are like teamwork trips. They are the illusion of progress.<p>There are situations where they are necessary but nothing beat ongoing discussions around actual work.
评论 #13186012 未加载
评论 #13183225 未加载
评论 #13190995 未加载
john_gauchoover 8 years ago
Just a couple of days ago I was thinking about this topic exactly.<p>Considering that I spend upwards of 2 hours per day in meetings it is amazing how little time I have dedicated into thinking about how to make meetings more efficient. I don&#x27;t think I&#x27;m the only one to make this mistake. Just because you have 5 people sitting in a room talking does not mean we are going anywhere or we are making any decisions.<p>Does anybody have a book recommendation where I can read more about how to maximize productivity of meetings?
phailhausover 8 years ago
Wow, what an obnoxious page header. It takes up a quarter of the screen on my laptop!
评论 #13179994 未加载
edoceoover 8 years ago
There was an old book on the topic. Roberts Rules of Order
评论 #13182225 未加载
评论 #13180852 未加载
majc2over 8 years ago
A related classic take on how to run meetings: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=46BFYo4drLc" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=46BFYo4drLc</a>
disposablezeroover 8 years ago
-9) Keep everyone productive and focused... scarcity = prioritization<p>-8) Eliminate boat anchors wasting time of previous with non-value-add bullshit.
ap22213over 8 years ago
Off topic, but I&#x27;m so glad that writing has gotten more concise over the last 40 years.
epynonymousover 8 years ago
interesting that this is from 1976 and still applies to 2016, but does it apply to startup companies?<p>here are my takes on meetings in general, some correlated to the article&#x27;s sentiments:<p>1. avoid meetings when possible, avoid them like the plague. as a meeting organizer, you need to be very clear about your objective&#x2F;goal for the meeting, so don&#x27;t be too liberal with other people&#x27;s time, but this also means when being asked to attend a meeting, cancelling or rejecting the ones you deem to be useless. learn to just say &quot;no&quot;. as an engineer i feel this sometimes lowers your favorability in the eyes of managers or peers, but this sets the right culture and tone, if you&#x27;re in a company where you attend a lot of useless meetings, i feel for you.<p>2. avoid meetings when possible<p>3. avoid meetings when possible<p>4. for decision making meetings, limit the number, preferably &lt;= 3, the more people you add, the more opinions you have to filter which sets things back. lots of my key decisions are done in private with one person. ever go into that meeting with 11 people in the room, all ready to say something for the sake of saying something? run, run as fast as you can!<p>5. always list actions triggered from the meeting and follow up on them adamantly with owners assigned before leaving the room. the meetings where there&#x27;s a lot of talk, but then everyone leaves without clear ownership are a waste of time.<p>6. for developers, it&#x27;s important to recognize that they maybe in &quot;the zone&quot;, so if i must have a meeting with developers, i try to organize this during the beginning or end of the day, meetings during the middle of day tend to break them out of the zone, then they have to context switch back to that deep problem that they were thinking about which would be a huge productivity fail on everyone&#x27;s part.<p>7. keep things concise, we&#x27;re not here to small talk about families or the warriors, do that at the water cooler. some people use this as an ice breaker to relax the mood, but that is just potentially a cover up for some big shit storm about to happen.<p>8. for the meetings where you&#x27;re trying to pass down information, keep it concise again, ok to reiterate key messaging, believe the shit that you&#x27;re saying, have conviction.<p>9. keep track of time, i hate all the assholes that overrun meeting times, i tend to attend these meetings less and less, if they can&#x27;t prove that they can hold effective meetings then you lose my time.<p>10. know thy audience, what messaging do you want to give, what messaging do you hope they digest, and tailor it, don&#x27;t talk about stuff that 80% of the people don&#x27;t care about, you&#x27;re wasting people&#x27;s time.<p>11. the good ol&#x27; status meeting, everyone and their mother attends to get a feel for what others are working on, but has absolutely no pertinence to what i need to get done or have done. really keep things high level, this is not your chance to voice your opinion, or give people the illusion that you&#x27;re busy. just talk about the high level points, if you have stuff to resolve, don&#x27;t do it in the meeting, do it offline, ahead of the meeting.<p>12. prepare well for meetings, i used to think that i could just waltz in and improvise, no, you need to prepare well, if you have a 1h meeting with 5 people, that&#x27;s 6h of company time being spent, almost a full person day spent. you better be ready and you better get to the point.<p>13. be on time, every minute wasted is amplified by the number of people waiting. i usually issue punishment for the ones that come in late, sometimes just the latest, sometimes everyone who&#x27;s late, buy coffee, do pushups, whatever it is.<p>14. i have a no phone and laptop policy in my meetings, sure you could be one of those new fangled flower power children that like to take notes on ipad&#x2F;surface, or evernote on your laptop, but don&#x27;t do that. you should, however, bring in a paper notebook. i know you have photographic memory, but bring that notebook, means you&#x27;re well prepared and expecting something out of the meeting. i had a friend that brought his laptop to play nba live to his harvard law school class. i also had this senior director during a 3 on 1 interview doodle penises on his laptop while the candidate was talking. there&#x27;s potential for a lot of mistrust in these circumstances. i think for the meeting owner to project onto a screen is obviously fine, but there&#x27;s nothing concealed. assholes that answer phone calls or email during my meetings, unless you&#x27;re sre&#x2F;devops, should be banned from meetings. the goal should be to get out of the meeting as quickly as possible, everyone focused, if you cannot focus then things will drag on.<p>15. avoid meetings if possible...
jcooke89over 8 years ago
&#x27;an all-electronic, multichannel, microwave, fiber-optic video display dream console in his living room&#x27; ..phroar!