TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Are there better countries to start my SaaS company for tax reasons?

58 pointsby kiddzover 8 years ago
We are about to launch a sass product and I'm wondering if it's too imaginative to incorporate in another country for tax reasons. We're using stripe, based in the US and most of our clients will be in the US. Also it's a .com.

22 comments

philiphodgenover 8 years ago
Hah.<p>I am an international tax lawyer and I advise startups that do business all over the world.<p>I do not have a good answer to your question. There is insufficient data upon which to make a suggestion.<p>However, here are my guidelines:<p>- if there is a US person involved in this business as an officer or owner, you will experience exquisite agony in opening a bank account abroad.<p>- until your net profits from non-US sources amount to $2M - $3M per year, the tax benefits are likely to be trivial.<p>- an hour of founder time spent thinking about tax is an hour wasted. Think about building your product. Think about getting a customer. That&#x27;s much more valuable.<p>- as soon as you add a foreign corporation to your business structure you have probably added $10K - $20k to your overhead. Minimum.<p>There are exceptions to every rule. Your situation may be different. Good luck.
评论 #13351350 未加载
pieterhgover 8 years ago
If you work in the US, and most of your clients will be in the US, most tax agencies (and probably IRS, but I&#x27;m not sure) will effectively presume you&#x27;re a US-based company. It doesn&#x27;t matter if your company is registered somewhere else, they&#x27;ll presume it as a US company. The same laws apply in most European countries.<p>Why? Because otherwise all freelancers would simply register in the country with the lowest tax to dodge their national taxes. Obviously governments don&#x27;t want that.<p>If you have the opportunity to physically relocate to another country though, then it becomes interesting to find places with lower tax rates. Countries like Singapore won&#x27;t care if you&#x27;re a foreigner opening a company and are never there. It&#x27;s mostly about your personal tax residency what matters.<p>An increasingly common construction with people working remotely is a Hong Kong or Singapore company, and either no personal residency anywhere (e.g. traveling around perpetually), or a personal residency in a place with lower personal tax. Think Bulgaria or Panama.<p>If you&#x27;re a US citizen, there&#x27;s extra difficulties here. You&#x27;ll be taxed for any income above $100K&#x2F;y, even if you&#x27;re not a US resident anymore. If you don&#x27;t want to be taxed in the US, you&#x27;ll have to forego your citizenship (!).<p>P.S. IANAL.
评论 #13349565 未加载
_d8fdover 8 years ago
If you&#x27;re business never takes off, it won&#x27;t matter where you are incorporated. Get some decent advice for a professional you trust. When you start making mad stacks of cash, let the profits from your business pay for the super duper advice on a tax strategy that makes the most sense for your business.<p>About 10 years ago I decided to become a one person tax expert, read a NOLO press book on incorporating, and found what I thought was a clever solution to optimizing taxes in the most favorable manner. About a year later, my accountant told me two things... 1. &quot;I&#x27;ve never actually seen a client choose this tax structure&quot; 2. &quot;You picked the worst possible taxation vehicle for your business, which is hard to do on purpose!&quot;
评论 #13355445 未加载
jwilliamsover 8 years ago
Wanted to lob more to the comments here on keeping it simple (and in the US):<p>You&#x27;ll find that most US companies want to deal with US companies. This isn&#x27;t just preference, but is part practicality. Contracts &quot;Governed by the laws of Panama&quot; isn&#x27;t going to fly. I&#x27;ve even seen companies argue over the US state specified. This can be true elsewhere, but most places are more used to dealing with US-based companies and contracts than another random country.<p>Related: As a foreign company you might find you&#x27;re subject to provisions and laws you weren&#x27;t aware. Could be privacy or even simple reporting. Knowing your own country&#x27;s business requirements is hard enough, knowing another could compound that.<p>It&#x27;s going to be a similar story if you intend taking investment. To some investors it won&#x27;t matter. To many it will matter a lot. Either way, a US (esp. Delaware) company is simple for both -- and you&#x27;ll probably find the investment legals are significantly cheaper.<p>Eventually you&#x27;ll want to employ people too. Granted there are ways of doing this without a US entity, but it&#x27;s not going to be pretty.
matt4077over 8 years ago
You&#x27;ve had all the benefits of the country you&#x27;re in: roads, schools, research universities that created the software industry, a foreign service that advocated for your right to sell globally. It&#x27;s time to return part of the favour.<p>(Also what everyone else said: it&#x27;s premature optimisation)
评论 #13348799 未加载
评论 #13348958 未加载
jwrover 8 years ago
Consider yourself lucky and incorporate in the US.<p>Do not, under any circumstances, even think about running a SaaS business from Europe. EU has made invoicing hell for small businesses, especially those selling SaaS. You will spend time on things like VAT number checking, verifying customer&#x27;s country using their IP (yes, I know), several kinds of invoices, prices inclusive or exclusive of VAT, calculating VAT for each EU country differently (and in different currencies), reporting VAT, and lots of other silly annoyances.<p>And if you think this is a &quot;solved problem using a third-party service&quot;, you haven&#x27;t tried it yet.<p>The only disadvantage of being US-based is that the first serious lawsuit will basicaly crater your business. Otherwise, you are <i>way</i> ahead of your buddies in Europe (like me).
评论 #13349860 未加载
评论 #13349946 未加载
评论 #13348867 未加载
评论 #13349955 未加载
mdekkersover 8 years ago
Having run companies in various countries, some of them more tax friendly then others, my advice is to keep it simple. Unless your turnover will be in excess of about a million USD annually, the compliance hassles are not worth it. with your money coming from somewhere else, your tax department is going to flag you up, and turn you inside out. you might not be doing anything wrong, but it will be something you will have to deal with, and pay lawyers and accountants to sort out.<p>I currently have an LTD in Cyprus, and am shortly moving to France. On paper, it is going to be hugely advantageous to keep my LTD in Cyprus, and move income via Cyprus to France. In reality, the likelihood of hassles with the French Tax and social insurance departments is very high, so I&#x27;ll be setting up shop in France. When the millions start rolling in, I&#x27;ll figure out some kind of construction, if it will be worth it.
blazespinover 8 years ago
Doesn&#x27;t Ireland have a 6.5 % tax rate? Isn&#x27;t that why all the companies like to incorporate there?<p><a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.forbes.com&#x2F;sites&#x2F;timworstall&#x2F;2015&#x2F;10&#x2F;15&#x2F;ireland-reduces-corporate-income-tax-rate-to-6-5-good-but-correct-rate-is-0&#x2F;#6769a77536d8" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.forbes.com&#x2F;sites&#x2F;timworstall&#x2F;2015&#x2F;10&#x2F;15&#x2F;ireland-r...</a>
评论 #13349355 未加载
评论 #13348814 未加载
tomahaover 8 years ago
The country you&#x27;re looking for is Delaware.
评论 #13348531 未加载
评论 #13348764 未加载
评论 #13348780 未加载
gamblor956over 8 years ago
No. You&#x27;re going to be taxed in the US anyways. Incorporating your company in another country just adds significantly more tax compliance, and potentially foreign income taxes, to the mix. Even worse, incorporating as a foreign corporation may make you ineligible for a variety of local, state, or federal tax benefits only available to domestic (meaning US-based) companies.
评论 #13348650 未加载
disordinaryover 8 years ago
New Zealand: <a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.doingbusiness.org&#x2F;rankings" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.doingbusiness.org&#x2F;rankings</a>, well actually Singapore because the corporate tax rate is lower (both countries have a corporate tax rate lower than the US).<p>But seriously if you&#x27;re based in the US and all of your employees are based in the US then pay tax in the US. The US government doesn&#x27;t look kindly on tax shells and unless you&#x27;ve got a lot of money to spend on accountants and lawyers you&#x27;re going to struggle. The US is the only country in the world that forces their citizens to pay tax on income earned (and taxed) while living overseas, so if you were thinking of relocating to a tax haven you&#x27;d end up paying more tax once your income reached a certain threshold.<p>And it&#x27;s only going to get tougher with the new administration.<p>Just pay your taxes, and take joy in the fact that you&#x27;re contributing to the society that you live in.
geff82over 8 years ago
As a European, I would choose the US any time. More friendly biz environment, many consultants there knowledgeable and no one, even the Europeans, ask why you are there and bill from there In case you have some really simple mass-market product, you could also consider the Dubai Internet Free-Zone where you have ZERO percent taxes, only about 3000 Dollar fees in the beginning (and some cost for license renewal every year). In case Europe is a must, Cyprus might be a low-cost option.
评论 #13350069 未加载
yummyfajitasover 8 years ago
Possibly Singapore. They have very rational and simple tax laws, legal stability and are generally a good place to do business.<p>I&#x27;d be worried about the EU, even the more corporate friendly places (Ireland, Estonia) - the recent retroactive ruling on Apple&#x27;s Irish taxes make the EU seem potentially third world-like unstable.<p>Of course, if you eventually plan to bring the money back to the US, probably incorporating in the US is your best bet.
评论 #13348723 未加载
atmosxover 8 years ago
I can make a case for Bulgaria. The corporate tax is 10% and the insurance tax is about ~ 50 to 80 EUR&#x2F;month (can&#x27;t recall exactly). If you pay dividends it&#x27;s an additional 5%.<p>Banking service is rather poor, although they tend to reply via email in 24h. Finding an accountant that does speaks&#x2F;writes English properly and reply on a timely manner can be a challenge but it&#x27;s not impossible, especially in Sofia. On the other hand, in other cities you could get an accountant for 1&#x2F;10th of the cost.<p>The major benefit is that the legislation is <i></i>stable<i></i> which is a big plus. Requirements for opening bank accounts are pretty loose compare to most other European states, although account expenses are considerably higher to neighbour states - but still we&#x27;re talking ~ 120 USD&#x2F;year. Starting a business is easy and rather straight forward. Most official documents (like company statute) come in PDF with official (reckoned by the BG state) digital signature on them. As long as you pay your taxes, mail your invoices to your accountant, etc. You&#x27;re good to go even if you live in Alaska.
codehotterover 8 years ago
Many countries, and I think most countries in Europe, have language related to &quot;place of effective management&quot; in their tax code. Even a corporation incorporated in Cyprus (say), it could be considered resident in Germany (say), if the tax authorities feel the place of effective management is in Germany.<p>Interestingly, this link says that in the US: &quot;Generally a corporation is treated as a domestic corporation if it is created or organized under the laws of the United States, any State, or the District of Columbia. No other criteria related to place of management will cause a corporation to be domestic.&quot;<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.oecd.org&#x2F;tax&#x2F;automatic-exchange&#x2F;crs-implementation-and-assistance&#x2F;tax-residency&#x2F;United-States-Tax-Residency.pdf" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.oecd.org&#x2F;tax&#x2F;automatic-exchange&#x2F;crs-implementati...</a><p>If you do decide to incorporate somewhere else, and you manage the company from the US, make sure it&#x27;s a place where the tax code also doesn&#x27;t care about the place of effective management.<p>However, if the income is US-source, aren&#x27;t you always taxed on that income in the US anyway? &quot;A foreign corporation engaged in a US trade or business is taxed at regular US corporate tax rates, but only on income from US sources that is effectively connected with that business, and at 30% on US-source income not effectively connected with that business. By contrast, US-resident corporations are taxed based on their worldwide income.&quot;<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.pwc.com&#x2F;us&#x2F;en&#x2F;tax-services&#x2F;publications&#x2F;assets&#x2F;doing-business-in-the-us-2014.pdf" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.pwc.com&#x2F;us&#x2F;en&#x2F;tax-services&#x2F;publications&#x2F;assets&#x2F;d...</a>
评论 #13348720 未加载
Bashmaistoraover 8 years ago
Start making money before worrying about taxes.<p>If you are planning to bootstrap the company then incorporate wherever you want. On the other hand, investors would be a lot more comfortable investing in a US company and clients prefer to deal with other US companies.
jswnyover 8 years ago
Did you mean SaaS?
评论 #13348590 未加载
评论 #13348537 未加载
ivankover 8 years ago
<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Controlled_foreign_corporation#United_States_Subpart_F_Rules" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Controlled_foreign_corporation...</a>
kxyvrover 8 years ago
Note, I am not an accountant, but these are my experiences running a business in the U.S.<p>If you are a passthrough entity like a sole-propietorship, partnership, or S-corp, probably not. Note, this doesn&#x27;t matter if you&#x27;re an LLC or not because the IRS doesn&#x27;t care. Basically, passthrough entities calculate all business income minus deductible expenses as personal income. Therefore, the amount is subject to federal and state income tax as well as payroll tax (FICA). Certainly, income tax is tiered and FICA caps out at $118,500, but let&#x27;s assume that you&#x27;re pulling in $100,000. This mostly puts you in the 25% tax bracket. We&#x27;ll assume that there&#x27;s also 5% of state income tax. For FICA, since you&#x27;re both the employee and the employer, you pay 15.3%. All together, that means you&#x27;re losing about 45% to tax off the bat. Note, this taxes apply regardless of where you register your company unless you live out of the country for 330 days a year or can claim foreign residency. Then, it gets complicated because a certain amount of income is tax free, but not over a certain amount. Anyway, if you decide to live in the U.S., that 45% or so of tax from above applies regardless of where the company is registered. The reason people register their company outside the state where they do their business, other than liability and tort concerns, is because they&#x27;re trying to avoid sales or gross receipts tax. However, everyone just bills that amount to their customers anyway, so it&#x27;s really a wash.<p>If you really want to know the implications where you live, just hire an honest accountant for an hour and ask. That&#x27;s what I did. It&#x27;s worth the money.<p>--- Edit 1 ---<p>Look, if you really want to save money on taxes, just make more money. That sounds silly, but it&#x27;s true. Register as an S-corp. Your first $118,500 are brutal because you&#x27;re paying an extra 15.3%, but after that FICA goes to 0%. Now, the top tax rate in the U.S. is 39.6%, but dividends are how people cheat that rate. Basically, an S-corp is required to pay the people who work in the company the prevailing wage for that position. However, money above that amount can be distributed to the shareholders as dividends. These are taxed at 15%. Note, you can&#x27;t just underpay yourself and then claim everything as a dividend. That&#x27;s illegal and you will get caught eventually. That said, the overall tax rate for someone who&#x27;s running an S-corp and making $300k is almost certainly lower than someone making $100k. For example, if you can convince the IRS that the prevailing wage for your position is $120k, and you made $300k, then the first $120k gets taxed at 45% or so (see above) and the last $180k gets paid out in dividends and taxed at 15%. That&#x27;s how you get your tax rate down. Note, at this point, really, just hire an honest accountant who can do the correct calculations and paperwork.<p>--- Edit 2 ---<p>Note, I talked about being an S-corp above. However, even if you register your company out of the country, it doesn&#x27;t matter. Americans must file their taxes every year regardless of where they live. If you are a bonified foreign resident, then the first $100,800 is tax exempt, but we still have to file this number. We also have to file what bank accounts have foreign assets over $10k at any time during the year. So, basically, when you file your taxes, the IRS doesn&#x27;t care where your company is registered at all. You&#x27;re going to pay your income tax and FICA, which is going to be in the 40% range if not more. Quite simply, if you&#x27;re self employed, you&#x27;re paying 15.3% in FICA. If you try to cheat this and your employer didn&#x27;t pay the other half, the IRS will still want its money and you&#x27;ll get caught. Even if you setup a foreign bank account with a foreign business, if a company pays you more that $600, they&#x27;re probably going to file a 1099 in order to deduct that expense from their taxes, which means that the IRS knows about your income. Further, if you try to wire the money into the U.S. from your foreign bank, that goes through a check as well. Really, the IRS wants to get paid and they will one way or another.<p>It&#x27;s not that illegal action can&#x27;t hide money. Certainly, it can. However, it&#x27;s difficult to hide money or reduce tax liability unless you have a lot of money to pay someone with a lot of know how to do it for you. At that point, just be happy that you&#x27;re rich.
评论 #13348762 未加载
评论 #13348635 未加载
评论 #13348648 未加载
FlopVover 8 years ago
Have you looked at US territories like the USVI? Might make things simple and keep a low corporate tax rate from what I hear.
wineisfineover 8 years ago
It just depends where you are located most of the time yourself.
mankash666over 8 years ago
In general, your lawyer and accountant should review anything you bring to their notice, especially suggestions via the internet, before finalizing things. Incorporating in Hong Kong is said to have many benefits, though please remember to be compliant with FATCA. Detailed blog [1]<p>[1]: <a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.locationindependent.co.uk&#x2F;nomad-guide-to-incorporating-in-hong-kong&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.locationindependent.co.uk&#x2F;nomad-guide-to-incorpor...</a>