TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Evaluate my idea

8 pointsby famfamalmost 15 years ago
Simple idea; website checkins. You visit a website every 24 hours and get points/badges etc. I'm not sure if checkin would be automatic (via 3rd party cookies) or if you would have to hit a button etc. Think of it as Foursquare for websites. I recognize that it would be easy to game/script.<p>Goals:<p>New traffic driving for websites. (Our website will give you a list of sites supporting checkin)<p>Make traffic stickier (visitors can return every 24 hours to checkin)<p>Fun for users through usual psychological mechanisms (points/badges/mayorships etc).<p>Websites can acknowledge (reward?) users' loyalty through jsonp/api mechanisms.<p>Questions:<p>Is it too close to MyBlogLog/EntreCard/Facebook Like?<p>Would this be an open system (anyone can check into any domain) or a system where you can only checkin to sites that support it?<p>Are there privacy concerns?<p>Do you think anyone would be into this? (I'm assuming no one on HN would be into it as a user, although hopefully some HN people would want to use it on their fledgling sites to drive traffic)<p>Thanks for the feedback!

7 comments

mikeleeorgalmost 15 years ago
Back in the day, before the dot-bomb, there was a site that did something similar. A few sites, actually. I think one of them was iWon (<a href="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IWon" rel="nofollow">http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IWon</a>), which offered points for performing certain actions on various websites. Others followed a treasure hunting model. You had to find certain pieces of content, or perform certain actions, to get points. They monetized by signing up partners (since this generated visits) and advertising.<p>That being said, I think this is an interesting idea. With Foursquare, Gowalla, and others having popularized the "check-in" idea, the market could be ready for this kind of a service again. If you can build a system to prevent gaming, you'd have a good, defensible product on your hands.<p>I think it's definitely worth a try. You can even scoop up some of the previous ideas (treasure hunt, rewards for actions, etc) and incorporate them too.<p>Good luck!<p>[Edited &#38; added some more info below]<p>Ah, I just recalled a few other attributes of the iWon system. They started with a portal page and rewarded you for clicking on certain links. This obviously is different than visiting a website whenever you wanted and checking in - and I think the latter model is better.<p>They also had a time restriction. You could only perform a certain number of clicks a day, and perhaps even a certain number for hour. Those may not stop people who write scripts to game your system, but it's an element you can consider.<p>I'm guessing you've already considered the social aspects of this too, yea? For example, check-ins could appear on Facebook, Twitter, etc. If your system included a friends concept, I could see which websites my friends like to visit, and perhaps go there too.<p>BTW, if you can pull this off, you'll also end up with a great database of user behavior. You'll know who the users are (Since they signed up on your site), you'll know which offers &#38; sites they like to visit, and you'll know how frequently they do so. Not that I'm highly recommending this, but such a list of users could be very valuable to marketers.<p>As the website owner, I'd love to be able to contact my visitors. Some sites may want to offer visitors free content, free stuff, easter eggs, etc. As a marketer, I'd love to know who visits my competitors, or related sites, so I could offer them incentives to use my service instead.<p>P.S. I wonder who'd become the mayor of Hacker News ;-)
myoung8almost 15 years ago
The issue with this is that it rewards users for generating pageviews instead of taking an action.<p>In the real world, when someone checks in at a business, odds are they are buying something, creating that virtuous feedback loop.<p>The only way to make this really pay off for website owners is to tie it in deeply with a more robust rewards system, but that requires fairly custom integration...which gives me an idea!<p>If you could build something like MixPanel meets Foursquare (i.e. develop a JS API that makes it incredibly easy for developers to build a rewards system) that would be a big win for everyone.
评论 #1422281 未加载
faramarzalmost 15 years ago
I really like the thought. Very fresh!<p>First things that come to mind are based on the User Experience. How will it function without being obtrusive? Can you build a relationship with the Check-in user and the publisher/content provider? This is something Facebook cannot currently do with it's like button.<p>I.E. I click the Like button on your site makes it visible to My friends, but it won't create a "personal connection" between Me and you. Can your check-in mechanism solve this?<p>I'm bookmarking this, cause I'd like to see where this goes. It's certainly an intriguing proposition.
评论 #1422290 未加载
impalmost 15 years ago
It seems like a cool idea. I remember when I was in high school applying for scholarships, there was a scholarship website that had something similar. I had to browse around their website looking for coins or something like that. When I found enough coins I got entered into a drawing for a scholarship. It was kind of fun, and probably could be generalized to other types of websites.
aymericalmost 15 years ago
From a first impression it sounds like a great idea.<p>The "karma" score you get on some websites could be extended to more websites rather than contained in each website separately.<p>I actually think that providing a Karma/Gaming API could be a great idea. I'd surely use it on my websites if it can integrates with my user authentication system.
评论 #1422385 未加载
jeffeppalmost 15 years ago
I really like this idea and have discussed it in detail with a few buddies.<p>I even have the URL cheqd.in if you would like it please let me know.<p>My thoughts were to make it the anti-location based check-ins.<p>So TV (watching) Books (reading) Internet (surfing) etc..
评论 #1424192 未加载
mikeleeorgalmost 15 years ago
Hey, this isn't yours, is it? <a href="http://onetruefan.com/" rel="nofollow">http://onetruefan.com/</a><p>If so, that was quick!