TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Does HN store IP addresses to identify users?

13 pointsby forgottenacc57almost 8 years ago
does HN store IP addresses for the purposes of identifying user accounts?<p>I wonder if HN was hacked if &quot;anonymous&quot; posts would be linked back to actual people even though no email address is on the account.<p>EDIT after comments: OK so maybe HN should be clear that anonymity is not likely if HN is hacked. HN sort of presents as being a &quot;safe&quot; place to post anonymously but it&#x27;s an illusion.

8 comments

positr0nalmost 8 years ago
I believe they have mod tools to help with voter ring detection and similar problems. I would guess those rely on ip addresses for some of the functionality.
评论 #14773727 未加载
savethefuturealmost 8 years ago
They should not have to tell you that there are risks to using online services, that should be a given...
pavementalmost 8 years ago
IP address is most definitely part of the voting ring algo. I&#x27;m almost positive about that much.
评论 #14773382 未加载
type0almost 8 years ago
&gt; does HN store IP addresses for the purposes of identifying user accounts?<p>They use cookies assuming you are logged in. I wish they do store IPs in order to prevent password brute-forcing attacks.<p>&gt; I wonder if HN was hacked if &quot;anonymous&quot; posts would be linked back to actual people even though no email address is on the account.<p>You should be more concerned about your email account being linked to your HN username, fortunately you don&#x27;t have to provide your email here.<p>&gt; OK so maybe HN should be clear that anonymity is not likely if HN is hacked. HN sort of presents as being a &quot;safe&quot; place to post anonymously but it&#x27;s an illusion.<p>It&#x27;s pseudonymous forum, if you wish to be anon - head over to 4chan instead.
meowfacealmost 8 years ago
Even if the DB were dumped and all users&#x27; IP addresses were revealed, the leaked IPs wouldn&#x27;t be much of a security risk.<p>For one, an attacker would not necessarily get your current IP address.<p>But even if they did have your current IP address... so what? The most someone could find from that is your general region; maybe your city or a city next to yours if they&#x27;re lucky. There&#x27;s no way they&#x27;re doxing you from that unless they think they can successfully SE the ISP and don&#x27;t mind risking jail for it.<p>The real security risk would be the leaked password hashes. That would be much, much more likely to result in people being doxed (and worse).
评论 #14773682 未加载
ogdanalmost 8 years ago
You can use Tor to post to HN anonymously.
ketralnisalmost 8 years ago
&gt; HN sort of presents as being a &quot;safe&quot; place to post anonymously but it&#x27;s an illusion.<p>I don&#x27;t think I&#x27;ve seen that represented anywhere, and I don&#x27;t think a news site really should be
nvr219almost 8 years ago
It does.
评论 #14773373 未加载