TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

When Silence Is a Plea Bargain: On Life as a Stutterer

48 pointsby fern12over 7 years ago

8 comments

lsadam0over 7 years ago
I&#x27;m curious if any others with a stutter have had a similar experience as myself. I&#x27;ve always had a severe stutter, and spent many years in speech therapy learning to deal. I&#x27;m fairly good at managing it, using many of the same techniques others in this thread have mentioned. Of course, the stutter never got better, I just became better at managing it.<p>However, as an adult I was diagnosed with ADD and started to take a low dose of Adderall. Of all the ways this was a positive influence in my life the largest change was that as long as I am medicated the stutter completely disappears. I don&#x27;t know if I can put into words what a sense of relief this was :). I will always remember the first time I spoke without analyzing and organizing every word before hand, one day a sentence just came out without a single thought. I&#x27;ve actually had to relearn having a filter on what I say. If I go off the medication for more than a day, the stutter comes back in full force.
le-markover 7 years ago
As an introvert prone to social anxiety, a lot of this resonated with me. I however, am not subject to betrayal by my own voice, as a stutterer must be. This passage really stood out;<p><i>Absent the context afforded by weekly papers and emails, silence acts as a blank slate onto which people tend to project their own insecurities, expectations, even paranoia. It can masquerade as apathy, or rudeness</i><p>I&#x27;ve always found that keeping quiet was just easier in so many ways. Consequently I&#x27;ve always been seen as quiet, reserved, stoic at best or cold and judgemental at worst. I&#x27;ve only recently come to realize what a disservice I&#x27;ve done myself by keeping quiet all these years. No one knows what I&#x27;m about if I don&#x27;t tell them. If I&#x27;m kind and generous, I have to tell people what I&#x27;m about, who I am, through <i>words</i> and actions.
评论 #15698491 未加载
评论 #15699747 未加载
Overtonwindowover 7 years ago
Forgive me for commenting so much, this is a topic very near and dear to my heart. I encourage all of the engineers out there to look at a stuttering fluency device called the SpeechEasy. It&#x27;s a very deceptive device that is ripe for innovation.<p>1) the device works on the chorus effect, echoing a person&#x27;s voice to help smooth out fluency.<p>2) its not gurranteed to work, won&#x27;t work for most people, and likely beneficial effects will wear off within 1-2 years.<p>3) Minimum price: $3,000<p>4) Not covered by most insurance companies.<p>SpeechEasy like devices and other fluency technology is ripe for disruption. I encourage all engineers and software developers to consider how low cost technology can be made to assist people with disabilities.<p>&#x2F;soapbox plea
评论 #15697846 未加载
rdtscover 7 years ago
&gt; Guidance counselors, speech therapists, and teachers alike flocked to my suddenly choked speech, forming what<p>Well my childhood speech therapist was ironically located in a mental hospital. So in order to attend the session my mom had to drag me through &quot;a hallway of horrors&quot; where having to pass by patients there either staring catatonically into space, mumbling nonsense, or doing other weird stuff. Needless to say I didn&#x27;t attend those for too long. But I do remember them trying the latest research techniques on me, which was a delayed audio feedback loop, not sure how effective it was, because we didn&#x27;t come back after a while.<p>Another thing I noticed is that my cousin also stutters, wonder if it is genetic in any way. His stuttering was triggered by being scared by dog once. Don&#x27;t remember why mine started.<p>&gt; I substituted in place of “trouble words,”<p>Heh, you&#x27;d be surprised how many synonyms I know because of that. Some words don&#x27;t have good synonyms, those words are to be feared and they cause extreme anxiety ... which causes even more stutter.<p>&gt; and my classmates were quick to assure me that it sounded just as ridiculous as I thought.<p>Yeah on the plus side I guess I developed a pretty thick skin against being made fun of, as I&#x27;ve been made fun of constantly, well since as long as I remember.
Alohaover 7 years ago
It never occurred to me that my stutter could spill across into the way I write - but it does - the word choices I use when writing are directly related to the word choices I&#x27;d use when speaking. I use similar word substitution tactics to get around a minor stutter, its lead me to have a much wider working vocabulary than I would otherwise.
评论 #15696785 未加载
genzomanover 7 years ago
I worked with a really great DevOps guy who had a bad stutter, and was not a native English speaker. I myself had a surgery that paralyzed one of my vocal chords and I couldn&#x27;t speak above a whisper for years and still can&#x27;t be heard in loud places. I can commiserate with just wanting to let other people know what you&#x27;re thinking, but just not physically being able to do it. It&#x27;s not easy, but the isolation it caused gave me my tech chops today. Not sure I&#x27;d always trade that tit for tat, but c&#x27;est la vie.
评论 #15697962 未加载
Overtonwindowover 7 years ago
Wow this is very powerful. I use to volunteer with kids who stutter, and the frustration, sadness, and silence due to an inability to communicate clearly was so painful to see.
southphillymanover 7 years ago
Why isn&#x27;t this considered a disability in the U.S.?
评论 #15697668 未加载
评论 #15697654 未加载