TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Show HN: Onomics – Make D3 Tables

28 pointsby rohinover 7 years ago

5 comments

abraaeover 7 years ago
Looks really interesting, and we&#x27;re currently scouting for good table solutions, but this is a killer:<p>&gt; Onomics is currently free for beta users, though we’ll eventually start charging for some premium use cases (hosting high volume charts, heavy usage, advanced charts, branded charts for example).<p>You&#x27;ve got to make money, that&#x27;s for sure. But this open ended future tax (what is heavy usage&#x2F;high volume anyway?) means that I can&#x27;t invest the time in checking out your offer.<p>Much better would be some bold statement like &quot;features x,y and z will always be free&quot;.
评论 #16348147 未加载
评论 #16344891 未加载
Bishonen88over 7 years ago
I was intrigued by the title of this post as I was looking for some nice django+d3 combinations for data viz but ... A hosted table with a bar chart? That&#x27;s new.<p>I don&#x27;t really see the audience for this. In the business world, no one will be willing to host their precious, sensitive data on some unknown server. For private use, I&#x27;d argue that one either creates a table programmatically in html or simply does it in excel if it&#x27;s just something small. While we&#x27;re on the topic of excel, I reckon one could recreate this app with VBA to look identical or near identical within less than 24h (possibly 3h-8h?).<p>Then comes the description itself - Stephen Few might get a small headache reading it:<p>&gt; tables present all the actual data so readers feel more confident they’re seeing the source information.<p>As opposed to what, charts? What else do charts show if not &quot;actual&quot; data?<p>&gt; Tables also allow you to rank items and show the relative magnitude of any item versus the rest.<p>Do charts not have exactly the same property? The relative magnitude of one item is easier seen in a well made chart than a table.<p>&gt; Lastly, tables have a high information density: they allow you display a large amount of data in a limited space. Imagine the above table as a bar chart and how unwieldy that would be<p>The above table does in fact contain a bar chart. Doesn&#x27;t seem so unwieldy to me. Charts, in my opinion, can have a much higher information density which is still comprehensible than tables - a scatter plot with 2 series each made of 1.000 items might be eye-opening if done right (and data has some trends etc.) - the same data displayed as a table, however, would take minutes&#x2F;hours to digest.
评论 #16344914 未加载
eb0laover 7 years ago
Journalists will love it!<p>It&#x27;s not easy for journalist to do a simple table like yours. The problem is very time consuming for them to do this kind of work.<p>If you want to get traction in newsrooms, you&#x27;ll need to add the option to tweak the size of the chart to be able to fit their CMS screen state, and twitter&#x2F;facebook&#x2F;etc post sizes.
catacombsover 7 years ago
They talk a big game about using D3 to make tables, but they aren&#x27;t responsive on different screen sizes.
airstrikeover 7 years ago
Why would I ever want to split up that table into two columns? Maybe this works in a blog where everyone is an amateur, but any professional worth their salt would stay away from that in the business world.