TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

US kids’ doodles of scientists reveal changing gender stereotypes

28 pointsby onuralpabout 7 years ago

4 comments

adventuredabout 7 years ago
That study actually shows that almost nothing has changed in a quarter of a century.<p>They&#x27;re referencing 1986-2016 at 72%, versus ~67% from 2010-2017, as a meaningful improvement. That supposedly meaningful improvement is almost entirely wiped out if you adjust just one of the recent outlier data points down to the average. Or alternatively, to show how little actual improvement there has been in a quarter century, drop the data off pre 1992, that 72% vs 67% improvement might even regress (someone want to test that?). That&#x27;s pretty shaky ground for such a big claim.<p>Pretty ridiculous article premise given the data in question. There&#x27;s obviously a lot more work to do on improving the gender stereotype problem the article is claiming has improved, particularly since it has somewhere between barely changed and not changed at all in decades.
评论 #16635281 未加载
arsabout 7 years ago
This could just as easily mean that children simply don&#x27;t see scientists anymore and have no idea what they look like.<p>For me scientists are certainly far far less visible than they used to be. It&#x27;s all programmers now.<p>What would help would be correlating &quot;draw a person&quot;, from the same child and seeing if a scientist varies from that.
评论 #16635103 未加载
spodekabout 7 years ago
What about kids&#x27; doodles of mine workers, garbage collectors, soldiers killed in war, prisoners, and other undesirable fields?<p>I would guess they still draw mostly men. Or rather, I would guess they don&#x27;t even draw them or think about them. I don&#x27;t hear many calls for equality there.
评论 #16636420 未加载
评论 #16636249 未加载
jdaaphabout 7 years ago
what a fit tho