TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Why do we have asymmetric views about work life balance in professions?

2 pointsby quintinabout 7 years ago
Correct me here and this is a genuine question.<p>We (software professionals) expect to go home at a reasonable time, still be paid the best salary among all verticals and we often complain about work life balance. But we have a different set of expectations when it comes to doctors, day care professionals, military etc. We don’t expect a doctor to discontinue his operation if he worked for 9 hours a day or infantryman to stop shooting. Heck, I will be furious if the daycare professional chose not to keep a watch on my child even beyond the designated time if I fail to show up.<p>Is this because we lack empathy or are we living in our own bubbles?

2 comments

jaclazabout 7 years ago
&gt;Is this because we lack empathy or are we living in our own bubbles?<p>Coming from someone that is not a software professional, you are actually living in your own bubble BUT you have a number of mitigating circumstances.<p>The work of (I presume) a programmer is not entirely new and can be likened to a number of &quot;intellectual professions&quot;, what has changed (again as seen from the outside) is the toxicity of the environment around you.<p>I mean, a programmer at IBM or Bell Laboratories or NASA in the &#x27;60&#x27;s has probably written possibly &quot;more important&quot; code, very likely being paid comparatively much less, but he&#x2F;she did it in a proper office, with some &quot;proper&quot; management and much less &quot;company pressure&quot;.<p>And - since I believe you are from the US - remember that the &quot;best salary among verticals&quot; is not &quot;worldwide&quot;, generally speaking in the EU programmers and &quot;software professionals&quot; are not usually paid better or much better than other technical professionals (like engineers, architects or similar).
codingdaveabout 7 years ago
I think it is because our minute-to-minute work doesn&#x27;t impact the well-being of either ourselves or other people. Your other examples all have a direct impact on people&#x27;s lives, potentially up to life&#x2F;death consequences. Whereas whether or not I finish updating this react component... not so much.<p>Now, contrast that with the work I did at a hospital. I was fully expected to keep working if whatever I was fixing had a negative impact on patient care, even if it was something trivial. We had a standard criteria for when we went home which was that if patient care was not impacted, we could put it off for later, but nobody walked out that door if a patient could be harmed by our inaction.