TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Trump withdraws from Iran nuclear agreement

21 pointsby m1about 7 years ago

6 comments

satokemaabout 7 years ago
Can anyone actually give me an elevator summary of what this actually means without relying on tribal language or dog-whistles? Clicking link related doesn't actually explain why any of this matters to me outside of signaling and posturing; it just sends me to a timeline of various pundits and celebrities telling me how I should feel bad and angry about this.
评论 #17024398 未加载
评论 #17025014 未加载
评论 #17024397 未加载
评论 #17024432 未加载
rando444about 7 years ago
Now that North Korea is becoming more friendly, one only hopes he's not grasping at straws to create a military conflict to create a distraction from his personal issues.
评论 #17024996 未加载
runesoerensenabout 7 years ago
Title should be <i>&quot;Trump withdraws U.S. from nuclear agreement&quot;</i> or just <i>&quot;U.S. withdraws from nuclear agreement&quot;</i>.<p>The distinction matters as this is something the U.S. (not just Trump) is doing. The rest of the world care less about who or what causes the U.S. to act this way.
patrickg_zillabout 7 years ago
One chart that I saw, indicates that the amount of business with Iran that the US does, is about $200 million dollars per year. The EU combined however, did about $25 Billion in trade with Iran last year. So it is much more significant to the EU than the US.
评论 #17025139 未加载
评论 #17024699 未加载
LifeLiverTranspabout 7 years ago
The irony beeing that iran, culturally is much closer to the west then all those &quot;natural&quot; allies in the region except israel. The few iranians i met where quite open minded, scientific endavouring and driven people. Very creative. They even have that messianic martyr streak that makes for such nice founder stories.<p>&quot;For one year we suffered, wearing the cross of 16 h days- and then my company died, but on the third day, i pivoted and it ressurrected.&quot; the pull through narrative of the champions.<p>Iran is one huge memorial for top-down modernization gone wrong along with turkey and i presume very soon - saudi arabia. Turns out- that when some cruel elite percived as a outsider force inserts a ideology, the people will reject it quite violently and ralley behind whatever oppossition available.<p>The iran nuclear deal was a attempt to contain and prevent a local nuclear arms race. Which now will go into full gear i presume- israel has nukes, saudi arabia and iran will want them too - or at least join some retaliation strike pact like NATO. Which can be provided by any major nuclear force in the region. So lots of diplomats currently travelling and offering nuclear umbrellas.<p>The colonial era drawn states dissolve and entitys alligned by culture&#x2F;religion re-appear. What remains are some mixed out of the way clusters for minoritys, a small kurdistan, syria and a very large iran(including most of the former iraq) with some proxy states, and a wahabi- power block. Turkey will be cut off from the wahabi-block and get stuck in something similar to vietnam.<p>Lots of the players will go for nukes to cement there conquered territories and enjoy the status of North Korea - in particular since the US seem to be on its way out into isolationism.<p>Russia supports iran currently by accident. Israel has chosen the lesser competent evil as ally and supports saudi arabia against iran- although the very same saudi arabia still propels most the religious narrative of the islamic oppossition to israels existance.<p>Its a great game, and the west is actually percived by now as a unreliable buisness-partner and dangerous - often absent replacable ally.<p>A good coherent strategy would be for the west to force its actual allies - not by propaganda or current ruler, but by cultural development direction( israel, kurds, iran) into a coherent block and leave the rest of the region to do what it always does, repeat past mistakes.<p>PS: North africa is turning into a bunch of warlords playing europe for ressources and bribes in return for holding refugees back.
pasbesoinabout 7 years ago
Macron had it about right: Domestic reasons.<p>Also, Trump is more comfortable with as well as playing strong man. He doesn&#x27;t want the U.S. to win; <i>he</i> wants to &quot;win&quot;. If he could, I&#x27;m sure he&#x27;d scrap term limits, fair elections, and line up his kids for dynasty.<p>Finally, I&#x27;ll mention that China&#x27;s in the process of de facto purchasing Afghanistan. Not the political quagmire, but rather dominant if not sole proprietorship over the commercial interests. This will place them at Iran&#x27;s border. And what&#x27;s the name of that global trade &quot;road&quot; Xi is building?<p>The counterbalance there will be Russia, to the extent they can back up their military with the commensurate expenditures. Not a counter-balance that works in the U.S.&#x27;s -- nor Europe&#x27;s -- favor.