TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Blind: an anonymous, corporate social network

141 pointsby Sonnol53almost 7 years ago

25 comments

rc-1140almost 7 years ago
Blind is actually a cool, if at times strange, place. I&#x27;ve posted legitimate requests for advice on here, Reddit, and Blind, and the quality of responses were overwhelmingly in Blind&#x27;s favor. Blind actually gave me real, if not blunt&#x2F;brief, feedback about what I could&#x2F;should do for various situations I&#x27;ve been in. Here and Reddit? The same tired old platitudes from well-meaning people that make them feel like they&#x27;re helping and making a difference, but are in reality providing highly generic advice that could apply to just about anyone at most skill levels and just showed that those who did respond skimmed the title and nothing else.<p>Of course, there are in-jokes, people who take those in-jokes deathly serious, people with mental instability (though that poster is actually taking a break after receiving feedback, fortunately for them), people who lean waaay too hard in one political direction or another, and other unsavory people and topics. However, this atmosphere allows for some brutally honest questions that would normally get shadowbanned&#x2F;shoved somewhere else&#x2F;otherwise manipulated by others or people in discussion board positions of power. There have been a few interesting relationship threads, a really good AMA about someone who works in Japan (I wonder if it&#x27;s Patrick McKenzie, the posts in the thread were REALLY informative to the detail he&#x27;s gone into before. I&#x27;ve forwarded stuff he&#x27;s written before to people I know who want to dream about working over there), salary numbers, advice for H1Bs, people going through rough times at work without having to reveal who they are without jackassing around with a throwaway yet still having an identifiable company attached to their username, and so on.<p>Dunno how long Blind will last for, but if you download the app and find you really don&#x27;t like the cons, just don&#x27;t use it every waking moment.
评论 #17772425 未加载
评论 #17770863 未加载
bertilalmost 7 years ago
I’ve seen several anonymous corporate networks before (three other full implementation actually, all reach exploding point). The same four things always pop-up, unless you ban one explicitly:<p>- mental health; single-handedly justifying the existence of every instance. The posts are boring overall: introversion, depression, burn-out, what to do (and the well-meaning responses to go see a doctor and hopefully links to internal references claiming the company will support you); it’s as exciting as a waiting room, but it’s helpful. On that note, if you feel like something is wrong and you are not sure: GO TALK TO A DOCTOR.<p>- salary; kind of hard not to have it here, but anonymity takes off the ability to tell people “Nah, you are incompetent, that’s what you deserve” so it’s a little locked; I really like the idea that Blind turns it to a conversation recommending LeetCode &amp; co. because that’s an interesting, objective exit from that conversation.<p>- bitching about bad manager: I think that’s the best aspect of those, but the tone can be very nasty and trollish. Unless you have great leadership who can take it, own it and improve, not the best idea. With good leadership, it can be staggering what feedback can accomplish.<p>- internal in-fighting, notably around incompetence and team rivalry, Social Justice, etc. Same as previous: good to take the temperature overall, but the tone is structurally problematic, unless you have really good content moderators. I&#x27;d recommend to limit some of that explicitly.
strykalmost 7 years ago
&gt;&gt; &quot;With Blind, users are completely anonymous, but are required to submit a verified work email to join a company channel.&quot;<p>That sentence doesn&#x27;t make sense. How can it be &quot;completely anonymous&quot; but you have to submit an e-mail address?
评论 #17770325 未加载
评论 #17772386 未加载
评论 #17771878 未加载
jarjouraalmost 7 years ago
I like Blind, but I also hate Blind. It&#x27;s full of excessively cynical replies and people who like to troll each other. I have found lots of great advice, yet still come away feeling really annoyed or frustrated.<p>To contrast the character, Reddit comments are usually full of jokesters who make me laugh, and Blind takes itself way too seriously. Sometimes humor and lightheartedness go a long way to building a powerful social network platform.
评论 #17772027 未加载
yellow_postitalmost 7 years ago
Blind is the quintessential “I feel worse after opening it” app for me. The self and company loathing is pretty incredible and I would hope many of the extremely negative posters find greener grass elsewhere.
评论 #17772209 未加载
venantiusalmost 7 years ago
I signed up for this a few years ago when I was working for a larger company. It was full of people using the anonymity to be very petty. I deleted my account without posting anything.
评论 #17770845 未加载
评论 #17770520 未加载
评论 #17770657 未加载
40acresalmost 7 years ago
I found Blind a pretty good social network for the niche. I got a useful info on industry salaries and interview prep from the general section. The company I work for had a section that was pretty negative and I think doesn&#x27;t reflect the overall thought of employees but still had great info regarding salary data and promotions. Along w&#x2F; entertaining (albeit hard to verify) rumors.
zitterbewegungalmost 7 years ago
How do they guarantee the anonymity? Is it only because the promise it? If we look at criticism against Proton Mail &#x2F; Lava Bit you have the same problem that they will only be private if they can be kept honest? See <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=8755492" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=8755492</a><p>Also, how do they expect to monetize this? Selling users data that is anonymized?
yashevdealmost 7 years ago
It&#x27;s the yik-yak for the corporate world; an absolute cesspool. Whatever valuable information exists on that platform isn&#x27;t worth sifting through all the toxicity, as some others here have alluded to. I installed it and deleted it forever within 45 mins. Don&#x27;t do it to yourself, folks.
RestlessMindalmost 7 years ago
I checked Blind and total compensation info is pretty much in the right ballpark (for my company and my partner&#x27;s company). This must be a nightmare for HR, who wants to hide that data as much as possible.
评论 #17771242 未加载
评论 #17771205 未加载
评论 #17771239 未加载
评论 #17771277 未加载
starpilotalmost 7 years ago
The lack of a strong karma system on Blind(the &quot;likes&quot; are a pretty casual form) makes the advice so good there. With karma, you write for the entire audience to gather points. Without karma, you write to a person. Also the lack of political correctness makes for outstanding real world applicability. I&#x27;ve done a similar comparison with asking about cycling on bikeforums.net vs Reddit. bikeforums responses were far more informative and open minded and diverse, most of all specific to me.
评论 #17770947 未加载
jacknewsalmost 7 years ago
&quot;and the US Navy coming online recently.&quot;<p>What could go wrong?<p>Certainly an app that helps rebalance the information-asymmetry between employers and workers is welcome, but I think it could be quite open to abuse when it comes to national security. Are the CIA and FBI going to join? Will we see the development of cyber &#x27;sentiment&#x2F;morale bombs&#x27;?
dqpbalmost 7 years ago
Who owns Blind? Where are they based? Sounds like a great way to mine insider info from tech companies naive employees.
评论 #17771467 未加载
Aeolunalmost 7 years ago
I still don’t really get why these companies that have absolutely no specific regional relevance are limited to sign up from two countries. Is there a problem with someone from say Germany, working for a German company signing up?
评论 #17774164 未加载
评论 #17770911 未加载
wyldfirealmost 7 years ago
I&#x27;ve heard of Blind but I&#x27;m too chicken to give them my work email address. Can anyone on HN testify to having done this? If so, aren&#x27;t you concerned that your employers can see you&#x27;re using Blind?
评论 #17771238 未加载
评论 #17770501 未加载
评论 #17770497 未加载
评论 #17771478 未加载
sidcoolalmost 7 years ago
I like the idea of the service. But I am having a hard time trusting it. It does require a verified work email address, which seems logical, else how would they know who works where. My worry is the chink in the armor that allows for abuse or exploit. You would be anonymous today, and not so much tomorrow.<p>Seems to be active only in US and South Korea. Any reason for this?
fallingfrogalmost 7 years ago
I love it! This same idea has occurred to me but I didn&#x27;t realize somebody already did it.
compsciphdalmost 7 years ago
i.e. yik yak, but centered around employer and not location?
评论 #17770764 未加载
wdr1almost 7 years ago
&quot;With Blind, users are completely anonymous, but are required to submit a verified work email to join a company channel.&quot;<p>That sentence seems to contradict itself.
Khainealmost 7 years ago
I just download Blind for iOS, denied it the ability to send me notifications and it just crashes on launch. Does that happen to anyone else?
shostackalmost 7 years ago
Are Blind conversations still indexed by Google?
naveen99almost 7 years ago
wow, i thought about making exactly this a while ago, so glad someone did it ! haven&#x27;t been this excited in weeks.
ickler9almost 7 years ago
Microsoft has 124,000 employees. You&#x27;re telling me one in three are on Blind? Yea right.
评论 #17770442 未加载
评论 #17772176 未加载
评论 #17770503 未加载
sadamzninternalmost 7 years ago
&gt;It has over 2 million users, including 43K at Microsoft, 28K at Amazon, and 10K at Google. In<p>It&#x27;s remarkable how unhappy the people at Amazon on Blind are.<p>Literally everyone is just leetcoding to get out or bragging about getting in early enough to make a killing on the stock surge.
评论 #17770837 未加载
评论 #17770900 未加载
casualtechalmost 7 years ago
Super interesting.
评论 #17770760 未加载