TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

ESR: Slaves to speech suppression are masters of nothing

18 pointsby artoover 6 years ago

4 comments

tommahoover 6 years ago
Was in a debugging scenario related to hierarchical nodes of data we identified as &#x27;parents&#x27; and &#x27;children&#x27;. Something was happening in a business process that left behind &#x27;children&#x27; without &#x27;parents&#x27;. I called them &#x27;orphans&#x27;.<p>Out of left field: a teammate who was adopted raised such a stink about inclusiveness in our naming conventions that the whole project suffered. I&#x27;m shaking my head even recalling this.<p>I no longer use anthropomorphism in unfamiliar company.
kirkulesover 6 years ago
On the contrary, claiming that using words like &quot;diversity&quot; or &quot;inclusiveness&quot; is tantamount to &quot;meaning to do &#x27;you&#x27; harm&quot; is itself harmful.
评论 #17979996 未加载
squozzerover 6 years ago
I dig the sentiment. But why not use &quot;leader&quot; and &quot;follower&quot; instead? Multi-tiered hierarchies might use military ranks (private, sergeant, etc.) or titles of nobility (king, earl, duke, etc. which would probably confuse a lot of people)
评论 #17978927 未加载
评论 #17979548 未加载
NPMaxwellover 6 years ago
OP: &quot;the demand for suppression of &#x27;politically&#x27; offensive terms is ... a desire to make speech and thought malleable to political control.&quot; But OP feels that using speech to make thought comfortable with owning slaves and thereby supporting the political support for slave-holding is OK. Noobs routinely ask, &quot;The term is WHAT? But slavery is bad.&quot; The answer is, &quot;Not in this case. This is a case where slavery is OK.&quot; After years of living with this language, this (admittedly small) support for slavery no longer disturbs the experienced programmer. The programmer will even say that, on this side, there is no thought control in the language, but on that side, there is.
评论 #17979498 未加载