TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: How to Evolve a Legacy .NET Application with Python

4 pointsby ninjamayoover 6 years ago
We have a legacy application that is built in Windows Forms and C# but in recent years we&#x27;ve been doing a lot of work in Python. We want to evolve this tool and gradually move all of the backend code to Python but still have a Windows desktop front-end either in Windows Forms (as is currently) or WPF.<p>I have already looked at different options building parts of the core libraries in IronPython or even using a REST web server to call the Python core but quite sure yet. Has anyone does this and are there any example applications that you know off using this idea?

5 comments

eksemplarover 6 years ago
Why do you want WPF or windows forms for your application? Especially if you’re doing a web based backend any way.<p>I know it’s a tad silly to use web uis for everything, but the truth is, that it’s where almost all of the ui innovations lie right now.<p>It’s not just for design either, it’s also automation. Like if you use Django, a lot of the basic forms for inputs will actually write themselves based on you’d datamodel.
shooover 6 years ago
I&#x27;ve seen:<p>* .net product with embedded ironpython for scripting ;<p>* desktop client talking to a backend server that happened to be implemented in python ;<p>* desktop application implemented as a collection of command line tools for batch processing, with a windows desktop frontend. Some of the command line tools were implemented in python and bundled using py2exe, other command line tools were written in other languages<p>these were all proprietary things with varying numbers of enterprisey customers, apologies, no sample code.
评论 #18489375 未加载
backslash_16over 6 years ago
Using Python via IronPython and trying to get C# to talk to Python sounds like it could have lots of issues. I would go with a Python HTTP(S) API that gets called by the Winforms or WPF UI.<p>This has the added benefit of forcing you into a more decoupled architecture and allows you to easily add a different type of UI (web, phone app, etc..)
评论 #18489368 未加载
LiamPaover 6 years ago
Nearing completion of something similar:<p>Phase I C# -&gt; python &#x2F; Django &#x2F; some simple html forms<p>Phase II (in progress) Django rest backend &#x2F; react front end<p>We host the application internally, all our team members know at least basic python so updates are easy and deployment is much quicker.
penetrarthurover 6 years ago
What is the reason to rewrite a legacy c# code to python?
评论 #18527112 未加载