TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

The Personal Toll of Whistle-Blowing

277 pointsby gringoDanover 6 years ago

17 comments

dhh2106over 6 years ago
&gt;One interviewee, in response to a question about what advice he would give a potential whistle-blower, wrote, “[Can they] afford 5 years of their life in turmoil?” Another said, “Part of your ability to do anything about this is keeping yourself together,” and suggested that whistle-blowers find someone “like a minister or a shrink who’s confidentiality-protected,” because “this could go on for a while.” A high proportion of whistle-blowers reported divorces or other marital strain, family conflicts, and stress-related health issues including shingles, autoimmune disorders, panic attacks, insomnia, and migraines. Several of them said that the financial consequences were devastating.<p>More than anything, I didn&#x27;t realize how long these cases seem to take. But I wonder: if there was a way to reduce the duration of the cases, would that reduce the impact on whistleblowers? Is that possible somehow? Retaliation is also a big concern, of course, as the article makes clear.<p>Also, I found this interesting: &gt;the first documented whistle-blowing case in the United States took place in 1777, not long after the signing of the Declaration of Independence, when a group of naval officers, including Samuel Shaw and Richard Marven, witnessed their commanding officer torturing British prisoners of war. When they reported the misconduct to Congress, the commanding officer charged Shaw and Marven with libel, and both men were jailed. The following year, Congress passed a law protecting whistle-blowers, and Shaw and Marven were acquitted by a jury.
评论 #19017303 未加载
edooover 6 years ago
This reads like an advertisement for the FBI. A bigger story is how Obama removed protections and actively attacked whistle blowers after promising the most transparent government ever. That had true toll.
评论 #19018767 未加载
评论 #19020814 未加载
refurbover 6 years ago
An interesting story of turning whistleblowing into a business is Ven-a-care pharmacy in the Florida Keys.[1]<p>They started out as a small pharmacy, but now have a team of lawyers. They’ve gotten over $600M in whistleblower rewards as of the early 2010’s. Not sure what the total is now.<p>[1]<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.cnbc.com&#x2F;id&#x2F;41491563" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.cnbc.com&#x2F;id&#x2F;41491563</a>
评论 #19017673 未加载
ilakshover 6 years ago
For me there is a related issue that is just as problematic or worse. There are certain things that are critical of the US government that are simply not allowed to be spoken in most US centric places. The public effectively censors itself. I could mention some specific things but that would trigger it and then no one would see my comment. In general you can get away with mentioning things from the distant past but nothing particularly heinous or recent. I think that this is because people want to believe that their side has a moral high ground.
评论 #19019655 未加载
评论 #19022186 未加载
评论 #19022937 未加载
Aeolunover 6 years ago
This wasn’t so much about the personal toll of whistleblowing as the fucked up system and the apparent impossibility to do wrong as a US corporation.<p>This was a really depressing story on multiple levels.
评论 #19024286 未加载
mywacadayover 6 years ago
Ireland is still recovering from the Maurice McCabe case <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Garda_whistleblower_scandal#Maurice_McCabe" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Garda_whistleblower_scandal#Ma...</a> He was ostracized by his colleagues and even painted as a pedophile by Senior Gardai(Police) trying to discredit him. An absolute horror of a story when you get into the details, spent nearly a decade proving his life fighting the case and clearing his name. Can&#x27;t imagine any Gardai whistleblowers in Ireland for a long time.
PaulHouleover 6 years ago
I hate the last few months of the year, when ads for car dealerships get pushed away by ads for &quot;Medicare Advantage&quot; plans which sound like something you need to get Grandma away from.<p>It&#x27;s kind of thing that seems like a scam to normal people, but politicians seem to think is a way to save money. Go figure. I don&#x27;t see how you can save money when you start out by adding 13% extra at the beginning to give the private sector some profit to work with.
gwernover 6 years ago
&gt; A few days later, in early September, 2014, Sewell was rushed to the hospital with a serious head injury after an accidental fall inside his house. Medical personnel found a clot in his brain. After three days in the hospital, Sewell died, at the age of thirty-nine.<p>Head injuries are no joke, people. Even if you recover from them, the epidemiology suggests there are life-long consequences for mental health, intelligence, income, impulse control...
lifeisstillgoodover 6 years ago
For me, Mark Felt sets the right template - get other people to do the publicising, leak anonymously and keep heavily in the shadows. Sometimes literally.<p>Just do not put your head above the parapet.
评论 #19018886 未加载
snarf21over 6 years ago
I keep thinking that in cases of any real size that these people should be put into witness relocation programs. Additionally, continue to pay them their current salary but not require them to work. We need people who know to speak out and therefore need to protect them.
评论 #19018130 未加载
评论 #19018518 未加载
platzover 6 years ago
So Freedom only got a slap on the wrist, basically
评论 #19017565 未加载
评论 #19017578 未加载
gaddersover 6 years ago
This guy did OK out of being a whistleblower (barring the prison sentence): <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.reuters.com&#x2F;article&#x2F;us-usa-tax-birkenfeld&#x2F;whistleblower-in-ubs-tax-case-gets-record-104-million-idUSBRE88A0TE20120911" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.reuters.com&#x2F;article&#x2F;us-usa-tax-birkenfeld&#x2F;whistl...</a>
评论 #19017620 未加载
samstaveover 6 years ago
There is an insidious aspect with respect to Tech Workers.<p>You don&#x27;t need to be a whistle-blower to have a toll on your life&#x2F;career.<p>Talk too much shit about a company in Silicon Valley and you&#x27;re fucked, regardless of the merits of your claims against them.<p>#TeflonUnicorn
评论 #19019807 未加载
sleepybrettover 6 years ago
Should whistleblowers be entitled to some portion of the fine levied against the offender to offset their losses (and encourage whistleblowing)?
评论 #19020204 未加载
crb002over 6 years ago
He should have moved to Iowa. Under Iowa Code 730, blacklisting has Civil and criminal penalties.
评论 #19021269 未加载
agumonkeyover 6 years ago
Maybe we need more patient and stealth activism.
deogeoover 6 years ago
I&#x27;d be very grateful for a summary - I&#x27;m no fan of these long-form articles.
评论 #19017308 未加载