TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Facebook’s Modern Messaging System: Seamless, History, And A Social Inbox

81 pointsby hiteshiitkover 14 years ago

20 comments

ajg1977over 14 years ago
"It seems wrong that an email message from your best friend gets sandwiched between a bill and a bank statement. &#60;snip&#62; With new Messages, your Inbox will only contain messages from your friends and their friends. All other messages will go into an Other folder."<p>This sounds utterly retarded.<p>Which is more important to me - an email from ISP or phone company telling me I have a bill to pay, or an IM from a friend asking how my vacation was? Some of the most important emails I've ever received have been from people I wasn't previously acquainted with.<p>It's as if Facebook are trying to train people to spend all there time interacting with other Facebook members, doing Facebook-type activities. Everything else be damned.
评论 #1907455 未加载
评论 #1907779 未加载
评论 #1907590 未加载
评论 #1907456 未加载
评论 #1907853 未加载
评论 #1907469 未加载
评论 #1907466 未加载
评论 #1907510 未加载
评论 #1907450 未加载
gfunk911over 14 years ago
I would really like a service that did the following<p>1. People can message me in a way that no more difficult than now.<p>2. That message will be sent to me via whatever communication method is best for me at that moment.<p>3. This choice of communication method is transparent to the sender of the message.<p>4. All messages, no matter the communication methods, are accessible online in one place.<p>5. It should not require me (or anyone I communicate with) to sign up for any services they don't already use.<p>Use cases:<p>1. I get an IM, but I'm not at my computer. I want to be notified of the IM (likely on my phone) and be able to reply to it from there. This is transparent to the original sender.<p>2. I get a text message, and I want to reply, but my reply will be long and I don't feel like typing it out on my phone, so I reply via some service online. The original sender gets a text in reply.<p>3. I have IM at work, but a friend only has access to email. We communicate back and forth, him via email and me via IM. It is transparent from both sides.<p>Maybe I am projecting, but it sounds like this is in the ballpark of what Project Titan is going to do. I am sure there are other services that do this (hell, I could write an alpha of it in not that much time), but such is life.<p>PS I believe that an important distinction between this and Wave is that Wave was trying to replace other communication methods, while this is trying to unify them.
评论 #1907478 未加载
评论 #1907746 未加载
bensummersover 14 years ago
I'm not entirely convinced that Facebook is the sort of trustworthy company you would want as an intermediary for all your communications.
mattwdelongover 14 years ago
What I find most interesting in all of this is how they're positioning the product. From what I understand they're not targeting die hard email users, they are targeting a much younger demographic, probably ideally around age 17 and heading off to University.<p>A system that will keep someone who has never been away from home in touch with their family, their old friends and their new friends - something to make them feel more in touch and connected. Basically target the demographic that Facebook was originally built for.<p>Google tried a similar messaging system, as many suggest (Wave), but they positioned it for the enterprise/business customer. Perhaps the wrong demographic, maybe Facebook gets it right?
评论 #1907607 未加载
评论 #1907426 未加载
评论 #1908016 未加载
yarapavanover 14 years ago
Request your invite at this page: <a href="http://www.facebook.com/about/messages/" rel="nofollow">http://www.facebook.com/about/messages/</a><p>Your email address will match your public username, for example:<p>Profile: facebook.com/username<p>Email: username@facebook.com
评论 #1907519 未加载
zitterbewegungover 14 years ago
Sort of interesting that google and facebook are trying (or have tried) to rethink our messaging concepts. Are they trying to fix something that isn't broken? Sometimes I think it needs work but it seems like they are trying whole new ideas that may or may not work.
评论 #1907386 未加载
评论 #1907387 未加载
评论 #1907491 未加载
评论 #1907367 未加载
riffraffover 14 years ago
from the article Many are aware of Facebook’s Cassandra system, but now they’ve built something new called hBase (working alongside the open source community again)<p>Someone knows what this means? Did they switch to hbase the _existing for many years_ database solution, or did they build something else on top of it (is there a trace of this in the hbase community?) or did they build something else from scratch and incredibly hit on the same name?<p>I wish techcrunch was a bit less.. techcrunch...
评论 #1907577 未加载
ajg1977over 14 years ago
So when everyone was expecting them to compete with Gmail, they've gone and imitated... Goggle Wave?
评论 #1907417 未加载
评论 #1907375 未加载
评论 #1907445 未加载
AndrewOover 14 years ago
<i>People are aware of Facebook’s Cassandra system, but now they’ve built something new called hBase...</i><p>As in Apache HBase? Not to be too pedantic, but that's not really something that Facebook "built". I'm assuming that was an error on TC's part.
评论 #1907547 未加载
kylecover 14 years ago
Google has all the pieces to do this even better than Facebook. I look forward to seeing what they can do with GMail, Google Chat, and Google Voice.
评论 #1907480 未加载
评论 #1907837 未加载
necolasover 14 years ago
It seems that Facebook are trying to extend their information base by capturing information on people that are not using Facebook and their relationship with Facebook users.<p>Some similar conceptual underpinnings to Google Wave but I wonder how practical it will be to have your entire history of communication with a person stored in a single thread.<p>Underwhelmed and the majority of the questions were related to the privacy concerns (dismissed by Zuckerberg) that this product throws up.
评论 #1907517 未加载
yarapavanover 14 years ago
And FB's blog post on this: <a href="https://blog.facebook.com/blog.php?post=452288242130" rel="nofollow">https://blog.facebook.com/blog.php?post=452288242130</a>
评论 #1907416 未加载
评论 #1907415 未加载
synnikover 14 years ago
I have not heard anything regarding how they expect to open Facebook to external communications without bringing in spam.
评论 #1907609 未加载
mikedankoover 14 years ago
Google does it now but integration is poor, and I suppose Facebook sort of took the user stories and simplified them but...<p>I don't see how this is different than anything Yahoo did 4-5 years ago. From the standpoint of using their IM app, things are forwarded to email or SMS depending on what the user wants. If you're in the webmail app similar options are provided. They also had a sort of seamless SMS from their webmail client a long time ago. I'm not sure what I'd call it, Intermodal Communication? How is what Facebook is doing here any different than the Yahoo model?
equarkover 14 years ago
Interesting that they bailed on Cassandra and went back to HBase.
评论 #1907781 未加载
评论 #1907432 未加载
kuahyeowover 14 years ago
This is interesting. On one hand Facebook doesn't try to attempt to satisfy the email crowd (imagine Blackberry and corporate firewalls), on the other hand, they are looking squarely at the SMS crowd (imagine teens who send 500+ sms a month, and complain $10 a month for the privilege is too much).<p>The scale is much larger and the requirements less stringent, yet the market is ripe to be pried apart, as most sms providers and telcos are basically milking it.
mikedankoover 14 years ago
This sounds super for Facebook users, but does this entice any Non-Facebook users? Are they doing anything to capture the people who don't see value in it?
rickharrisonover 14 years ago
Interesting question to people in our space: When will facebook become "the internet" for non-technical people?
评论 #1907349 未加载
paraschopraover 14 years ago
Oh boy, never heard so many buzz words in one single article. Did anyone make out what it really is?
评论 #1907662 未加载
gcbover 14 years ago
Give facebook even more credentials.<p>also, this is very similar to yahoo mail year-old inbox (you can read social feeds from pretty much anywhere... flickr, twitter, etc, etc)