TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Can we all stop using Medium now?

925 pointsby squiggy22about 6 years ago

70 comments

55555about 6 years ago
I was writing on Medium because it ranks well in Google. I wrote nearly a dozen really great articles on primarily health and dietary supplement topics. After 2 months they started to rank well and were getting daily readers, as the content was really great. Then I wrote an article on a &#x27;research chemical&#x27; and they banned my account overnight. I lost the final edited versions of all content. They did not send me a zip with the content. They could have simply deleted the offending article(s) but instead they deleted all of them.<p>The thing is, the thing I wrote about isn&#x27;t illegal. When you write articles on Medium keep in mind you&#x27;re writing on someone else&#x27;s website and they don&#x27;t give a damn about you. You are subject to their opinions about what is appropriate and what isn&#x27;t. I have no doubt if an alt-right voice wrote on Medium and were controversial enough in their views they&#x27;d be deplatformed.<p>But also the way they handle it is just rude. Fuck them.
评论 #19937007 未加载
评论 #19937870 未加载
评论 #19937906 未加载
评论 #19938158 未加载
评论 #19937678 未加载
评论 #19936235 未加载
评论 #19937671 未加载
评论 #19935734 未加载
评论 #19935767 未加载
评论 #19935932 未加载
评论 #19936010 未加载
评论 #19936283 未加载
评论 #19936527 未加载
评论 #19937223 未加载
coldteaabout 6 years ago
&gt;<i>When did reading stuff on the web become pay to play?</i><p>At the moment authors wanted to get paid. When did somebody else&#x27;s writing became a free for all?<p>If, as you say, that [Medium] is where &quot;all your favourite content lives&quot; (which means you appreciate the content), then it&#x27;s troubling that you don&#x27;t want to pay for it.<p>&gt;<i>Just so we are clear. Medium takes your content, rolls it up into a pretty SEO friendly package for themselves and sells it. Oh, and turns us all into seals waiting for someone to throw us a fish in the process. If you are lucky, you might even get a cut. You know. Like the sort of cut artists get on Spotify. Profit share I think the cool kids call it. So why is everyone still publishing on it? For what? More eyeballs? More attention? More reach?</i><p>All of the above. More eyeballs. More reach. More attention. A primed audience looking to read something. And also some authors make decent-ish money (far more than Spotify) on Medium. So there&#x27;s that.<p>&gt;<i>Please. It’s 2019. Learn to market yourself and your content. Quit being lazy waiting for Medium to do it for you. OWN YOUR PLATFORM.</i><p>Yeah, and how does that work for you? We&#x27;ve only read your blog because it was picked by an aggregator (HN).
评论 #19938646 未加载
评论 #19938200 未加载
评论 #19939305 未加载
jscholesabout 6 years ago
&gt; If you enjoy reading on the web chances are you’ve been forced to login to Medium at some point in the last week.<p>I&#x27;ve never once logged into Medium. I see a &quot;Pardon the Interruption&quot; notice every time I want to read something, but I just hit Escape and move on with my day. If I had to pick a side, I&#x27;d probably say avoid Medium. But I don&#x27;t know under what circumstances it forces you to log in just to read something.
评论 #19936123 未加载
评论 #19935655 未加载
评论 #19935590 未加载
评论 #19938101 未加载
throw007about 6 years ago
I&#x27;m writing on Medium because its rank well on Google. I have several articles about the product I&#x27;m selling that rank 1-5 on Google and it gives me a lot of customers.<p>It&#x27;ll take me a lot of time to build my own website and content that gives me the same result. So, there&#x27;s that.<p>Sorry, not a native speaker.
评论 #19935398 未加载
评论 #19935287 未加载
评论 #19935272 未加载
评论 #19935687 未加载
评论 #19935412 未加载
_seemethereabout 6 years ago
Not everyone has the time to create their own platform and curation network. That&#x27;s the reason why people will keep using Medium.<p>We need to stop acting like it&#x27;s easy to build these types of platforms.
评论 #19935192 未加载
评论 #19935526 未加载
评论 #19935080 未加载
评论 #19936009 未加载
评论 #19938895 未加载
评论 #19935269 未加载
评论 #19936216 未加载
dmjeabout 6 years ago
There&#x27;s quite a lot of mileage in what this guy says, and the &quot;content behind walled garden&quot; thing pisses us all off (I&#x27;m a non-Facebooker for All The Usual Reasons and have the same response whenever I see stuff &quot;published&quot; there).<p>But: noone seems to have mentioned the fact that you can publish on WordPress and use the Medium plugin to copublish to Medium. It deals with the whole canonical content &#x2F; SEO thing, you get to keep your original content, and you get the potential benefits of a Medium audience &#x2F; stats &#x2F; etc.<p>Best of all worlds.
评论 #19936121 未加载
评论 #19944243 未加载
评论 #19936449 未加载
silverorioleabout 6 years ago
Seems like not many commenters are giving a perspective on why people might like Medium more than going to a personal blog. Here’s mine.<p>As a reader, I usually don’t care who wrote the post I’m reading. I also don’t care about seeing more content from the same person, which is all I would get on a personal blog; in fact, I would prefer to see related content but different viewpoints from other people, which is what Medium shows me. I want to read them all in the same format, not hop between different blog layouts. I want them all to have consistent like&#x2F;comment mechanics. As a reader, sorry, I just don’t care about your personal brand or platform. I want to easily read a lot of stuff by different people on a topic.<p>Never used it as a writer, but why should individuals have to set up their own SEO, comment system, blog system, etc just to post an article? Because they think that they’re so important or controversial that they need a personal space&#x2F;brand? For most writers I think you get a lot for free with Medium.
评论 #19939589 未加载
评论 #19937912 未加载
sgarmanabout 6 years ago
I know this doesn&#x27;t justify all the issues but I&#x27;m at least a little excited that someone is trying to create a media&#x2F;news service that isn&#x27;t ad based. Seems like we have a way to go but at least this is a start.<p>I&#x27;m a little surprised that there are so many complaints here - I bet a lot of the same people complaining also complain about ad based services and now they create news &#x2F; journalism &#x2F; articles designed for clicks and not quality content.
评论 #19937263 未加载
评论 #19937150 未加载
Hackbratenabout 6 years ago
Please re-enable the `-webkit-overflow-scrolling: touch;` CSS style for your content. The article is a pain to read on Mobile Safari because bouncy&#x2F;rubber-band scrolling is disabled.
评论 #19935376 未加载
评论 #19936987 未加载
评论 #19935444 未加载
评论 #19935690 未加载
tyingqabout 6 years ago
Large.com is available for $850k if there&#x27;s a VC thinking they can disrupt.
评论 #19935576 未加载
评论 #19937557 未加载
DanielBMarkhamabout 6 years ago
There&#x27;s a deeper thing going on here that should be mentioned because it applies in so many places: the platform is the enemy.<p>That is, once you create a platform to do X, the purpose of the platform becomes &quot;get people to use the platform to do X&quot;, <i>not</i> X. They sound like the same thing but they are not.<p>An example: Facebook, I guess, is all about sharing things with your friends. But over time it quickly morphed into an engine that was only concerned about how many people would spend their time on their site sharing and consuming things, not about sharing. So people &quot;shared&quot; by posting memes from other places. They shared by copying crap and fake articles. They &quot;shared&quot; by playing dumb and addictive games for hours at a time, asking anybody they could find to help them milk a fake cow or something.<p>If you cared about sharing, you might think about a wise investment in time, both for the sharer and the folks consuming what was being shared. But if you think about whatever you could pass off as sharing, then you might think about virality, demographics, psychology, and so forth. Worse yet, you&#x27;d probably do whatever you could to prevent people from talking about real sharing. After all, that would be a huge hit to your site&#x27;s metrics. It might even involve an existential crisis.<p>Likewise Medium cared about blogging and publishing, but only in terms they had predefined and could control. As they started looking at their numbers, they started refining their definitions.<p>The same thing is happening everywhere, for instance YouTube. YT couldn&#x27;t care less about average folks making creative content to share, even though that&#x27;s the schtick. What they really care about is reliable non-offensive video content being regularly produced and consumed by the most numbers of people that they can sell ads to.<p>I&#x27;m not saying that any of these platforms are evil or ran by bad people. My point is that by defining a platform and business model that&#x27;s widely-adopted, you end up preventing any sort of change, quality improvement, or re-imagining what the important drivers are for that platform. I can change what I consider to be high-quality video to create, share and consume ten times a day. YouTube cannot. Same goes for Medium and text content. The platform, the idea of fixing quality attributes for complex things into code, is the natural enemy of serious consideration and evaluation of the thing the platform supposedly supports.
mellingabout 6 years ago
It’s halfway through the month and I’m blocked by Medium. It is a bit frustrating.<p>I’m not sure about this comment though:<p>“Learn to market yourself and your content. Quit being lazy waiting for Medium to do it for you.”<p>Maybe I am lazy but there really isn’t an easy and inexpensive way to market your blogs or apps.
评论 #19934927 未加载
评论 #19935860 未加载
评论 #19935300 未加载
bwastiabout 6 years ago
I wrote one article on Medium. I ended up writing my own little version using open source markdown rendering to see how hard it would be to roll my own, <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;jott.live" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;jott.live</a><p>From what I found, there is a lot of stuff Medium does well that is hard to recreate by one&#x27;s self. Super simple features, like<p>- rich text editing that isn&#x27;t ugly<p>- caching what you&#x27;re currently working on<p>- tracking views and who has viewed your article<p>aren&#x27;t easy to build and generally aren&#x27;t worth it unless you write many many articles.<p>Although I don&#x27;t like the aggressive account on-boarding and payment models for reading articles, Medium certainly makes life easy for writing articles.
评论 #19938980 未加载
评论 #19937136 未加载
评论 #19937445 未加载
dtornabeneabout 6 years ago
g-d forbid writers find a way to be compensated, eh? I despise medium, it sucks as a platform, it sucks to read, and 99 times out of a hundred if I&#x27;m on an aggregator or twitter and I see a medium link to a piece that sounds interesting I skip it, because medium <i>sucks</i>. But christ does that post reek of entitlement. On top of that, maybe learn to put words together a bit better if you want people to read your blog over another platform
dickeytkabout 6 years ago
The main argument in this article doesn&#x27;t apply unless the Medium writer enabled the partner program on the post. That&#x27;s what enables the pay wall.
评论 #19935039 未加载
评论 #19935659 未加载
regnerbaabout 6 years ago
I don&#x27;t publish anything ever really so I don&#x27;t understand the appeal of using Medium. Can anyone explain it to me? Is it just the ease of use? Write some text, click button, it&#x27;s available online?
评论 #19935345 未加载
评论 #19935094 未加载
评论 #19935064 未加载
keyleabout 6 years ago
I wish I could upvote this 10 times.<p>Medium is the pinterest of thoughts.
IloveHN84about 6 years ago
Funny how from &quot;All to Medium, ditch WordPress and personal blogs&quot; now people want to go the way around because of metered views and other limitations imposed by Medium popularity.<p>I say it since ever: own your own content.
评论 #19936720 未加载
wtmtabout 6 years ago
Side note. I didn’t read this post for two reasons. On mobile, the lack of inertial scrolling makes it like pushing hard against some massive slush, and the lack of a scroll bar prevents me from knowing how long the article is and whether I should read it quickly now or check it later.<p>A criticism on Medium, including its usability (I presume), should do a lot better if it wants to be read.
评论 #19936269 未加载
superconformistabout 6 years ago
But how will I &quot;clap&quot; for top-shelf webshit content if it&#x27;s not on Medium?
评论 #19937767 未加载
评论 #19937456 未加载
miklabout 6 years ago
I really hope people do. Medium is awful and getting awfuller as time passes.
davidzabout 6 years ago
It&#x27;s fine to dislike Medium and run your own blog, but I find the article intellectually dishonest in comparing Medium to Facebook. One harvests your data and lets advertisers target you with ads, the other charges a subscription to provide access to content.<p>It&#x27;s disingenuous to claim they &quot;sell whatever advertising they please&quot;, and link to a ToS screen cap that&#x27;s completely unrelated.<p>Companies have to make money in order to pay their developers and pay for servers. Personally, I&#x27;d rather pay them instead of seeing ads plastered everywhere.
spyckie2about 6 years ago
Please KEEP USING medium to keep all those uninspired rants, thought leader posturing, and no substance fluff pieces on subjects that are actually interesting behind a paywall.<p>Please put more effort into creating better content by exhibiting interest and passion into a subject through deep exploration, insights, discussion of core issues and resolution, and great descriptive writing.<p>It used to be that everyone who wrote a diary had no expectations of their content being anything valuable, and the value of writing was in the exploration of ideas and organization of your thoughts. Now the value of writing is how many people you reach? Philosophically, I&#x27;m against that change, so please keep that stuff behind a paywall.
fbn79about 6 years ago
To make a parallelism with traditional paper it&#x27;s like to say that everyone want to publish an article must become an editor and found a newspaper. That&#x27;s not realistic. Medium and other platform put a lot on work on promotion, positioning and creating an engagement place for writers and readers. I don&#x27;t think that every writer must became an editor in digital era. It&#x27;s like to say that if you are a musician you have to host your clone of spotify and bypass all distribution platforms.
评论 #19938339 未加载
musicaleabout 6 years ago
This should be medium link.
评论 #19935658 未加载
gurlicabout 6 years ago
I&#x27;m currently working on an alternative to Medium. So far it has all the elementary things like a working editor, notes and highlights, a decent commenting system. There are publications too, with teams, submissions etc. User profiles and publications have custom domains, custom CSS for branding. There&#x27;s also a somewhat half-working Github integration for advanced writers but I&#x27;ll need to work on it a fair bit to polish the edges. At some point, I&#x27;d ideally want to open-source the editor&#x2F;bloggy bit and have people self-host it and perhaps push their content back to the platform for centralized distribution if they want.<p>It&#x27;s still a work in progress and I&#x27;m trying to figure out some sort of strategy, especially a content policy around not allowing clickbait and spammy &quot;how to use learn redis in 3 minutes&quot; type articles. I&#x27;d probably have to cap the max number of users and publication to a few thousand since I don&#x27;t have the resources for this to be anything more than a hobby project.<p>I&#x27;m aware of a couple of others working in the same space. Write.as comes to mind, thought I don&#x27;t think they&#x27;re doing publications etc.
评论 #19935436 未加载
评论 #19935255 未加载
评论 #19935338 未加载
ausbahabout 6 years ago
Doesn&#x27;t medium also fill the gap of a sort of easy to use, personalized aggregate site for blogs and such? I&#x27;m not aware of any other site that does this.<p>And isn&#x27;t that kinda of the point of sites like Medium, Reddit, YouTube, Facebook, etc. - that provide enough of a valuable service to people by providing a single place for people to view a certain type of content that in spite of ads, centralized control, some pay walls, crappy technology, etc. that consumers and producers still find it worth while to use for viewing and publishing.<p>I would even go a step further and say such aggregate sites like Medium represent what the &quot;new&quot; internet represents, convenience and monetization. The average user doesn&#x27;t care about privacy or ads as much as they want easy access to information. The average producer doesn&#x27;t care about control compared to what runs their operation, revenue and readers. I think many &quot;technologists&quot; and other people who populate sites like Hacker News have values the align more closely to that of the &quot;old&quot; internet, so view many of the new trends negatively.<p>I&#x27;m not trying to say if it&#x27;s right or wrong, just my two cents.
phantom_oracleabout 6 years ago
The authors complaints are valid, but fails to acknowledge that besides Medium, so many great(and not so great) conversations happen on platforms that are now locked behind login gardens. It was fine back in the day to just create a throwaway FaceTwit account but now they demand mobile numbers too.<p>Pre social media, how did people discover great content? You can go as far back to the 90s or very early 00s as a time reference
评论 #19935888 未加载
duxupabout 6 years ago
I&#x27;ve been amazed seeing some folks I think of as good web citizens who are thoughtful about the web, web development, and etc.... keep using Medium, or at least have recently.<p>Some of these people would get plenty of attention posting on a personal site and just tweeting it out, but they choose medium, and I wonder why.<p>Folks less well known, I get it it assuming they somehow get more attention on medium.
vcavalloabout 6 years ago
jeez, could you jack my mobile scrolling any further? not reading that for any longer than 2 seconds
samwilliamsabout 6 years ago
A community member built a blogging platform on our permanent, decentralised web (Arweave) today. You might want to check it out:<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;arweave.net&#x2F;egqLRAbESk4BvrPZGwNM-koJZZU3_xYRb_G9-CYCvFs" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;arweave.net&#x2F;egqLRAbESk4BvrPZGwNM-koJZZU3_xYRb_G9-CYC...</a><p>Full disclosure: I started the Arweave project.<p>Sam
Vordimousabout 6 years ago
So I have been putting together a way for people to more easily make their own blogging platform. It would kind of mimic a social media platform, but since everything is committed to a repository using the JAMstack it could easily be converted to a full website. Any feedback would be wonderful. <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;your-media.netlify.com&#x2F;post&#x2F;make-your-own-media&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;your-media.netlify.com&#x2F;post&#x2F;make-your-own-media&#x2F;</a> Everything is owned by the end user. This is only providing a recipe for people to use.<p>I will also mention that <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.stackbit.com&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.stackbit.com&#x2F;</a> is doing basically the same thing but more from a “Make life easier for Website designers” perspective.
vfc1about 6 years ago
One of the big advantages of self-hosting is that you own not only own the platform, but also the traffic.<p>When I started my business I had a previous blog with several topics covered.<p>Because I self-hosted, I managed to redirect the traffic only for a specific set of posts on the topic to my new business blog where I moved several posts over, getting thousands of visits in my business blog (and converting customers) since day one.<p>The Ghost blogging platform is open source, and you can self-host if you want (I do).<p>With Ghost, you can also get their hosted service for a monthly fee and you own your own platform, you have a markdown-based editor with markdown on the left and content on the right.<p>You can run your own ads, have a fixed top menu that does not go away with scrolling with links to your products and services, etc.<p>If you are serious about running a business blog, you should definitively self-host. I know Medium has the sharing aspect, but it&#x27;s not worth it because most of the traffic in blogs in general comes from Google searches and not sharing.<p>The social sharing traffic is a drop in the ocean for most blogs, it&#x27;s not worth getting potential paying customers blocked due to a medium paywall popup.
ameliusabout 6 years ago
What happens if you are a popular blogger, and one day you decide to take your business elsewhere, and make the announcement on Medium in your last blogpost there? Will they take that post or even your entire blog down?<p>Similar question for YouTube.
miguelmotaabout 6 years ago
Medium should be used as a means to distribution (like a mirror) but not be the canonical source. Make your personal blog be the primary source of storing your articles but copy post on medium for discoverability
pwncakeabout 6 years ago
Is there a suggested alternative people should be turning to as opposed to building their own, especially if their expertise is in writing or some other field than computer science or web design?
评论 #19935049 未加载
评论 #19937848 未加载
评论 #19935724 未加载
skilledabout 6 years ago
I have yet to figure out the &#x27;persona&#x27; for Medium users.<p>From time to time you can come across some decent content, but the loops and hoops you have to go through to read it are simply not worth my time.
评论 #19935208 未加载
cfitzabout 6 years ago
I am happy to pay for well articulated content that can sometimes reach 45min&#x2F;piece in reading duration.<p>Medium will slowly learn what you’re interested in and send you opt-out’able weekly newsletters with recommendations.<p>I’m surprised the OP has this much distaste for a platform which not only has good content, but rewards such, yet without ads. I’d happily pay to see less ads in my life.
paulie_aabout 6 years ago
A lot of content creators have posted their experiences here. It matters for SEO, while being shitty to content creators.<p>From this readers perspective if it&#x27;s on medium it&#x27;s not worth reading. I&#x27;ve literally thought this &quot;awesome that sounds like it will solve my exact issue...oh fuck it&#x27;s on medium...next&quot;
rchaudabout 6 years ago
A big chunk of the comments are about the problems of self-hosting video. The reality is that if you&#x27;re not hosting on Youtube, or aggressively promoting the video via FB Ads or something, you will never get anywhere close to the number of views that would necessitate thinking about &quot;video at scale&quot;.
throwaway13000about 6 years ago
I have decided not to post on internet platforms that take my content and put it behind a login wall. I guess if I post a blog or video, I expect that everyone must be able to view it without having to login. Only then I will give my content to your platform. This will stop the web from being a bunch of islands.
sisciaabout 6 years ago
There is definitely something I miss in the discussion self-hosted blog vs medium.<p>But the simplest solution isn&#x27;t to just write on your own self hosted blog and cross post on medium setting the canonical URL?<p>Doesn&#x27;t this give the best of both worlds?<p>You still have control over your property and you still get the SEO benefits from the medium domain...
pawurbabout 6 years ago
Medium is also bad for SEO <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;abot.app&#x2F;blog&#x2F;medium-blogging-platform-seo" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;abot.app&#x2F;blog&#x2F;medium-blogging-platform-seo</a> . Selling your personal brand for a fancy WYSIWYG editor does not seem to be the best trade-off.
robsunabout 6 years ago
I can remember praising Medium as the ultimate solution for professional bloging. I stopped using Medium when a pay wall was introduced. I didn&#x27;t follow what happen since then with the platform. Can someone shortly introduce me to the topic why Medium is considered now as evil corp?
suzilabout 6 years ago
Medium will often pop up when I search for something programming-related, but I&#x27;m less likely to find someone&#x27;s blog post. What if we had a search engine that would only show programmer&#x2F;technical blog posts? Then we could bring more traffic to the self-published.
salutonmundoabout 6 years ago
<i>Prediction</i>: next week on HN: an article titled &quot;Why Medium is super great&quot;
neop1xabout 6 years ago
Your page still won&#x27;t display in built-in webview of Materialistic Android HN client. And it has trouble parsing HTML. Just like Medium and many other modern (=broken) websites full of javascripts and ads.
jarymabout 6 years ago
Just came here to say I hate Medium. I frequently get a strobing green bar at the top of the page that is permanently there and as far as I can tell doing nothing. WTF?
aerovistaeabout 6 years ago
Ironically this page doesn’t work on mobile. It doesn’t have inertial scrolling, and I just have no patience for that. I stopped reading after the first paragraph.
评论 #19941044 未加载
ddalexabout 6 years ago
&gt; When did reading stuff on the web become pay to play?<p>Stallman was right.
manigandhamabout 6 years ago
&gt; <i>When did reading stuff on the web become pay to play?</i><p>That&#x27;s what happens when there are no ads. This is what the HN majority keeps saying they want.
ga-vuabout 6 years ago
Had a friend lose hundreds of posts after he complained on Twitter about the company&#x27;s annoying popup. They deleted his account within hours.
stanislavbabout 6 years ago
What is your best alternative? I&#x27;d say dev.to is a good one for the context of software&#x2F;programming related content
评论 #19936712 未加载
StanislavPetrovabout 6 years ago
Thankfully medium required a Google account to register, saving me the trouble of learning the hard way how bad they were.
xkcd-sucksabout 6 years ago
Somewhat relatedly, does anyone else need to adblock&#x2F;disable medium.com JS in order to scroll through articles?
Grustafabout 6 years ago
Seems like you can have the cake and eat it too by posting to Medium AND your own domain, or wherever you want.
评论 #19938840 未加载
girlsrule1234about 6 years ago
For someone with such strong opinions on personal platforms, he’d do well to fix the scrolling in his site.
DmitryOlkhovoiabout 6 years ago
I don&#x27;t read medium. It&#x27;s just another stupid website that takes your time and gives nothing.
azhenleyabout 6 years ago
Fine. I’m going to make a Medium alternative this weekend and this person better try it out.
sytelusabout 6 years ago
TLDR; The article says that Medium locks up content behind its walled garden, requires login and then payment in some cases.<p>I think the article is not well researched and doesn’t understand the basic premise of Medium: <i>Enable professional writers to make living off of writing.</i> Medium is not your usual free blogging platform. There is an expectation that people <i>will</i> pay for good content and the hope that good writers should be able make living off of their writing. Medium wants to take on doing SEO, infrastructure, payments and let authors focus on just creating content.<p>Here’s some stats on how much writers can earn on Medium: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;medium.com&#x2F;s&#x2F;partner-program-updates&#x2F;april-update-from-the-partner-program-1bf39020f3f4" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;medium.com&#x2F;s&#x2F;partner-program-updates&#x2F;april-update-fr...</a><p>If I have to be devil’s advocate, I would ask why can’t Medium use ads as revenue source. Their $5&#x2F;mo subscription may look like cup of coffee but honestly I am tired of having dozen such subscriptions in my life. Also, people outside developed world, kids, teenagers, college students will still find this unaffordable.
kgwxdabout 6 years ago
I forget Medium exists until some complains about it. Several years ago, the popularity of Medium and several paywall&#x2F;signup-wall sites posted on HN and Reddit inspired me to write a Firefox add-on that is able to apply CSS to any element that contains any text or attribute value matching a given regular expression on any site. So far, I&#x27;ve only used it to apply &quot;visibilty: hidden&quot; to sites I don&#x27;t like, but it theoretically has other uses. I use a variation of the filter in Newsbeuter to keep them out of my RSS feeds. The result is that I do not see any links or any embedded content for sites I know I never want to interact with, ever. Search results, Reddit, HN, blogs, etc. The sites I add are basically erased from my personal internet experience. It is glorious, and I think if a lot of people used it, misbehaving sites would be more scared of it than ad blockers because they don&#x27;t even get the chance to grab your attention. It&#x27;s called ssure if anyone is interested. It&#x27;s a bitch to configure but it works on desktop and Android FF.
ajflores1604about 6 years ago
So just my personal take, I definitely benefit a lot from Mediums recommendation system, however it might work. Probably because I&#x27;m brand new to programming, and even fields like machine learning are very fresh to me even though it seems like everyone and their mom already knows the basics. So having a system that can see that I looked up a specific topic and recommend similar articles from that domain. A lot of the time I don&#x27;t know what I don&#x27;t know, so having this recommendation system helps illuminate the domain a bit more for me. And the general style of medium where the posts can be a more casual overview of a topic compared to the deep dive of a whitepaper, helps me grasp concepts faster. The recommendation aspect also helps me explore domains in a more focused way compared to the random nature of social networks that just bubbles up whatever&#x27;s popular. I&#x27;d be lying to myself if I said I haven&#x27;t benefited from Medium.<p>Not trying to excuse them for what they&#x27;re doing, just trying to point out from my personal experience the value they&#x27;ve added to me and why following personal blogs or places like reddit, which I see mentioned as alternatives, isn&#x27;t a one to one replacement for me. I don&#x27;t know what or who I&#x27;d need to follow if the domain is new to me.<p>I guess continuing on this train of thought, and not wanting to complain without putting out an idea for a solution...if something were to come in and be a viable alternative to Medium it would have to<p>&gt;Allow for easy publishing (editor)<p>&gt;Have reliable distribution&#x2F;hosting (network)<p>&gt;And have some way to explore related topics or publications (discovery)<p>For publication I think the community would have to come around to a standard format. Like a simplified latex, or something similar to it, with an approachable interface that even my Mom or Dad could write something up without needing to read documentation.<p>As for distribution, the only thing I can really think of is an ipfs style network. Similar to how torrents can provide some security in the survival of a file even if the originator decides to stop seeding (hosting). And also similar to torrenting, I can see ppl willingly giving up resources for &#x27;the cause&#x27; if they themselves benefit enough from the network existing.<p>The only thing left, that also contains all the things I liked about Medium, is the discovery aspect. Also seems like it&#x27;d be the most difficult to implement on a distributed network. Maybe a few designated community servers, similar to tracker servers from the torrenting analogy, carry the information of what files are in the network. Im not sure exactly what the ipfs spec implements for this aspect of file discovery. But it seems some sort of designated &#x27;discovery nodes&#x27; would be necessary. Maybe graph network nodes that ppl can query using their own discovery algorithms or ones shared within the community? Idk how well those would scale, I&#x27;ve heard from the Neo4j pitch that Behance rolled over their infrastructure to neo4j from cassandra and reduced their server requirements by a factor of 10. Maybe that kind of efficiency would be enough to support the network in general with a minimal number of critical nodes?<p>I haven&#x27;t worked on an infrastructure level with anything I&#x27;ve mentioned, mostly just know of the technologies, so I might be completely off base with the individual things I proposed, but I feel like the general concept is worth dissecting.
评论 #19937245 未加载
getcrunkabout 6 years ago
So what alternatives are there? Either as a service or code?
bitLabout 6 years ago
We need a Zeitgeist service returning Overton window for each company and automate hiding articles&#x2F;content that are no longer fitting inside it.
评论 #19937159 未加载
AngeloAnolinabout 6 years ago
I&#x27;ve seen a lot of complaints about how Medium is becoming worse in terms of writing &#x2F; publishing &#x2F; blogging your thoughts on the internet [1]. I just don&#x27;t see why no one (or group) has taken to building a similar service less the cruft and could still be a viable business.<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;m.signalvnoise.com&#x2F;signal-v-noise-exits-medium&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;m.signalvnoise.com&#x2F;signal-v-noise-exits-medium&#x2F;</a>
myspyabout 6 years ago
He is right. Medium was cool around 2016. Before the content was behind a paywall and the free content was accessible in a visible way. They send you a mail with interesting stuff everyday and now it&#x27;s dead to me. The mobile site is horrendous, a banner where it says to download the app which can&#x27;t be canceled after five or so tabs. The asshole that designed it should never get a job in the business again.
taylodlabout 6 years ago
Can we all stop posting articles from Medium on HN? While we&#x27;re at it let&#x27;s stop posting articles residing behind paywalls. That&#x27;d be great.
whydoineedthisabout 6 years ago
No
emptyparadiseabout 6 years ago
This site appears to break scrolling inertia on touch screen devices.
jasonvorheabout 6 years ago
&gt; You know. That old internet that used to be open and free.<p>This is bullshit. Medium is free, you&#x27;re free to use it, it&#x27;s open (unless an author explicitly asks for a paywall for compensation) and you&#x27;re free to register an account to have your own content published there.<p>Medium isn&#x27;t using a proprietary protocol nor does it require a licensed client to access it and everyone has a browser, so I really don&#x27;t get the issue with publishing there.