TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

60% of male managers now say they're uncomfortable mentoring women

97 pointsby bubmiwabout 6 years ago

17 comments

anon77887almost 6 years ago
I&#x27;m still getting over a situation which occurred a month ago, and as it stands I will probably have to leave my job.<p>I hired a female contractor engineer (in the UK contractors are paid daily, supposed to be easy to hire&#x2F;fire), my manager is also female. 2 weeks after the engineer started, I knew she wouldn&#x27;t be able to stay in the team because her work was not good (she was spending a lot of time chatting around, and not producing good quality code). Everybody complains to me that my engineer is not performing well, but my manager makes me keep her. A month later my manager asks for a meeting with me, and says that my contractor has been complaining about micro-management, and that it can be seen as bullying or harassment. Because of that I leave for 2 weeks, and it takes another month to get rid of the contractor.<p>Learnings: I actually handled the situation very well, but I suffered a lot from the way my manager handled the situation. I have myself managed, hired and fired dozens of people in my career. Yet as soon as it was a girl, the rules of the game completely changed, and it didn&#x27;t matter who was right or wrong. No matter how much I want to be inclusive and how much I want to give equal rights to everybody, other people (and even females) don&#x27;t see it that way, and still want to make a distinction between sexes.
评论 #19949471 未加载
shaknaalmost 6 years ago
I can understand the reluctance, up to a point.<p>I&#x27;m male, I&#x27;ve been accused of sexual abuse, and it was thrown out because it became exceedingly clear that it never happened. That was extremely unpleasant to go through, and I&#x27;d rather never go through it again.<p>However, it hasn&#x27;t had an ongoing effect on my relationships with women, just the one woman. I&#x27;m still more than happy to work with my coworkers regardless of their sex, and I&#x27;m more than happy to guide anyone who happens to fall under my leadership.<p>Anybody accused is first judged by the audience. A certain amount of guilt is assumed. That you let yourself into a potentially compromising situation, or you sought out the situation.<p>And I imagine the higher you are up a managerial chain, the higher the stakes are when you get accused.<p>There is a human cost, even if &quot;nothing comes of it&quot;.<p>I imagine many of these managers are terrified of the ordeal, of lawyers, they don&#x27;t know if the company will support them until a judgement is made or kick them to the curb. Of the effect it may have on their family, where they might already have strained relationships with their spouses.<p>They don&#x27;t want to potentially risk it, because the power dynamics at play are not in their favour from the outset. The system is biased to find fault, rather than first determine if there was fault.<p>At the same time, we can&#x27;t cut the authority of the system in any way - the people it protects, who genuinely need protection, often are already in a power imbalance of their own.<p>The fears are justified to an extent, but the simple truth it comes down to is... You&#x27;re a manager. It is your responsibility to be responsible for those under you. If you can&#x27;t be, then perhaps a management position is not appropriate for you. Perhaps you need to learn to thrive in a different role. Harsh, certainly, but as the environment stands, ignoring those under your care will only help to promote an environment where women are once again second-class citizens.
评论 #19946546 未加载
6Wc1p3KHalmost 6 years ago
Throwaway for obvious reasons.<p>I&#x27;m not a manager, but I eat lunch&#x2F;dinner one on one with men far more than I eat lunch&#x2F;dinner with women, and it&#x27;s because I try not to be a creep. I try to manage bias and I try to be aware of when I might be doing something for a coworker just because she&#x27;s female and pretty, and unfortunately that means that when it is actually genuinely appropriate to grab dinner together and talk about our work I second-guess myself. When it does happen, it&#x27;s usually a more senior coworker taking the initiative first.<p>No idea how to stop doing it other than time and experience. If you&#x27;ve got tips, throw them out there.
评论 #19945988 未加载
jonnybgoodalmost 6 years ago
A female coworker of mine just recently shared with me that she was treated like this in her previous workplace. She felt alienated and as if she was some kind of harlot ready to ruin the lives of her male coworkers. She’s happy to not be in that workplace anymore.
评论 #19948106 未加载
random123987almost 6 years ago
That&#x27;s funny how a comment thread in topics like this explodes into its own version of Me Too. The only &quot;slight&quot; difference is that MeToo talks about actual rape which happened, while this version is about &quot;feeling uncomfortable while imagining things&quot;.<p>Nevertheless, I do have a certain empathy for the people who talk about their fears here. I have mine too. Again there is this small difference: while you fear that a certain accusation(which happens how often?) can ruin your carrier, I have a fear that your fear can ruin my carrier with &gt;60% chance. Without possibility for me to get accused explicitly, leaving me no chance to defend myself.<p>While I&#x27;m taking a moment to feel your fears, can I ask you to do the same for mine?
simonblackalmost 6 years ago
It&#x27;s the same sort of problem with males not wishing to be classified as &#x27;paedophiles&#x27; and children.<p>Once upon a time, I would have tried to help distressed children. These days I walk straight past them. Let the next female do the consoling.
lostmymind66almost 6 years ago
This is not surprising. We are in a hyper-sensitive society now where many people are accused and lose their entire career and possibly marriage through the court of public opinion.<p>As a result, it would be smart of most men in these positions to either not mentor at all or always have someone else in the room. I wouldn&#x27;t be surprised if companies started having everything recorded at some point.<p>The real problem is that false accusers won&#x27;t face many repercussions compared to the accused. Some men accused are even found to have done nothing and it doesn&#x27;t matter. People still believe they did something.
评论 #19945796 未加载
16e6471bd4b781almost 6 years ago
Based on the tenor this has already taken, I’m replying with a throwaway.<p>I have changed my behavior around women subordinates. It sucks, but that’s the reality. At this point I’m as concerned with the appearance of impropriety as I am false accusations. I know who I am and I trust myself. Everyone else? Not so much anymore.
评论 #19945651 未加载
dvfjsdhgfvalmost 6 years ago
It&#x27;s because if you get burnt once, you&#x27;ll always be on guard. It takes one abuser to change the lives of several people at once.
sfinkalmost 6 years ago
The study is fine. It&#x27;s reporting some statistics that I find believable. Statistics on men&#x27;s <i>worries</i>, mind, not on occurrences of actual harm.<p>The reactions I&#x27;m seeing are... not helpful for the most part.<p>One reaction is that this is a horrible thing because it is unfair. I agree that it is an unfortunate part of our current reality. So is the possibility of being forced into uncomfortable situations, or more generally, being sexually harassed when you&#x27;re a blameless woman in the workplace. I don&#x27;t see a way of resolving that unfairness without <i>any</i> negative impact on blameless men.<p>We can certainly try to work together in good faith to minimize negative impact while creating positive change. But wailing and moaning about the balance of power tipping slightly away from us (I&#x27;m a white male) is not acting in good faith. It&#x27;s just plain entitlement.<p>The #metoo movement&#x27;s direct impact puts me at more risk than before. And I&#x27;ve taken advantage of my cultural immunity more than once in my life. I&#x27;m not proud of some things in my past, and I&#x27;m not free from the possibility of doing more things in the future. I have problematic biases and attitudes. But I&#x27;d rather live in, and have my kids grow up in, the sort of world that #metoo is leading us towards than the world that (I hope) we&#x27;re leaving behind.<p>Besides, some of this abject fear over being accused of <i>the things that we&#x27;ve actually done</i> would be lessened if the patriarchal walls of silence and secrecy were torn down so we could all see what is actually happening in the world, rather than the whitewashed appearance of perfect honor and respect that we all pretend is real. I don&#x27;t think my personal lapses would be judged too harshly if compared against reality. But they look pretty bad if compared to all the guys professing purity and innocence -- because we as a society have somehow fooled ourselves into believing them.<p>60% of male managers are nervous about mentoring women. What percentage of working women are nervous about what their male coworkers might do one at any point in the future?<p>And fuck that, what percentage have already experienced worse than what a male manager might realistically experience from a complaint about his behavior in a 1-1? And don&#x27;t bother pulling out the &quot;but what if absolutely nothing happened but the woman accused him unfairly and he lost his job and wife and kids and had to live under a bridge until he killed himself??!&quot; unless you have some solid evidence that this happens more often than women get raped by acquaintances.<p>Or if you don&#x27;t like that comparison, maybe look at the number of women who lose jobs or careers or get blacklisted as a result of someone else harassing <i>them</i>.
评论 #19947621 未加载
atdtalmost 6 years ago
Sexual harassment and gender-based discrimination are real and urgent issues, but the path forward will not be lit by Facebook COO Cheryl Sandberg and SurveyMonkey marketing material. She has no moral credibility.
threatofrainalmost 6 years ago
It&#x27;s Vice President Michael Pence&#x27;s personal policy to never meet 1 on 1 with a woman unless it&#x27;s with his wife.
评论 #19947122 未加载
itsaidpensabout 6 years ago
This is bullshit. Don’t be a creep. Period, end of story. Hire and promote fairly. You won’t have a problem.
评论 #19945622 未加载
评论 #19945603 未加载
评论 #19945681 未加载
评论 #19945597 未加载
评论 #19945682 未加载
评论 #19945574 未加载
评论 #19945562 未加载
Lendalalmost 6 years ago
So 60% of male managers admit they aren&#x27;t good managers. Good. Step aside then, and let others more capable than you have a chance to prove themselves.
评论 #19945654 未加载
benatkinalmost 6 years ago
It seems like the path forward is clear. Sandberg:<p>&gt; &quot;The thing is, it&#x27;s not enough,&quot; she says. &quot;It&#x27;s really important to not harass anyone, but that&#x27;s pretty basic. We also need to not be ignored.&quot;<p>There&#x27;s no need to walk back any part of MeToo to solve this problem, just to keep pushing forward.
评论 #19945693 未加载
评论 #19945627 未加载
tehjokeralmost 6 years ago
Alternative headline: 60% of males rethinking how they interact with women after decades because protests broke through and raised consciousness. Change isn&#x27;t comfortable, it&#x27;s not supposed to be. It&#x27;s only supposed to be just.<p>This goes for technical skills and moral ones too. You feel bad until you&#x27;re better.
walrualmost 6 years ago
Regardless of skill or experience, they seem to be getting promoted over other more qualified individuals, anyway. At least that&#x27;s what I&#x27;ve noticed in my places of work over the last four years. I&#x27;d hate to tell you how many of those places went under as it&#x27;s all anecdotal. I am however getting a little put out by people around me not getting promoted on merit, but on optics.
评论 #19945632 未加载
评论 #19945650 未加载