TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

I will now charge my clients a fee to support open source projects

126 pointsby giladalmost 6 years ago

13 comments

derekp7almost 6 years ago
The problem is that enterprises have one mechanism to purchase software, and a totally separate mechanism for charitable donations. The two budgets are run by separate groups, and never interact.<p>The solution? Offer your code under an open source license, but also have a purchase option to buy a commercial license. In many cases, the commercial version is a compiled and validated official executable, available with a support contract. But there is no reason that the came code can&#x27;t be made available under both licenses, or that the commercial license can&#x27;t actually be the same GPL (or whatever) license the open source one is offered under.<p>This way, the technical team that chooses the software has an invoice that they can send to purchasing, to get corporate support dollars to the open source project.
评论 #20282137 未加载
评论 #20282934 未加载
评论 #20285105 未加载
acconradalmost 6 years ago
This seems like a bad PR move. Having been in consulting everything is about perception of value. Why not just plan to spend some of your money (say 5%) on supporting open source projects and just raise your rates by 5%?<p>Ticketmaster is the perfect example of this. You buy a concert ticket for $35, but after all of their exorbitant bullshit fees, it&#x27;s more like $50-55. But if they just told you &quot;$50 is what you pay&quot; then you&#x27;d probably not care at all.<p>So go ahead and charge whatever you want for a fee. Just don&#x27;t penalize your customers for the things you want to personally support.
评论 #20282144 未加载
peterwwillisalmost 6 years ago
The most amusing thing about companies&#x27; technology budgets is their fear of price tags.<p>Pay for Enterprise support for that open source product? Way too expensive, no way.<p>Pay for 5 engineers in completely separate teams to badly implement, partially support, and later replace part of the Enterprise features as proprietary extensions over 2-3 years, while company&#x27;s actual product languishes without the functionality it could have used? Take my money.<p>Meanwhile, keep paying for SaaS and proprietary software, because there&#x27;s no alternative, supposedly.
评论 #20282053 未加载
rahimialialmost 6 years ago
specifically: &quot;I will ask my clients for an hourly rate that is 1 Euro higher than I originally negotiated or I would usually charge. I will take that money (up to ~160 Euros per month) and support those projects on Open Collective that I&#x27;m basing my work upon in my client&#x27;s project.&quot;
swalshalmost 6 years ago
I&#x27;ve never been to church, except for the occasional funeral. So i&#x27;m not really familiar with how collection plates or tithes work. But maybe the church of open source could find a priest to get some advice. Or at the very least, lecture people about how much better a person you can be for supporting open source.
评论 #20281793 未加载
评论 #20282780 未加载
jnpawalmost 6 years ago
<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;twitter.com&#x2F;adamrackis&#x2F;status&#x2F;931195056479965185" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;twitter.com&#x2F;adamrackis&#x2F;status&#x2F;931195056479965185</a><p>If you think your software is valuable enough to cost money (instead of offering it for free) then do so.
hokusalmost 6 years ago
Its not my area of expertise but....<p>There are so many corrupt non-profits to which one can make tax deductible donations. Would it be possible to reform&#x2F;tweak&#x2F;hack the [existing] donations to help their bottom line?<p>I bet someone out there is already doing this.
vbstevenalmost 6 years ago
I wonder if some sort of structure can be used where you split the invoice in two separate invoices. One for the work and a smaller one for the open source donation that can be deducted from taxes as an actual donation. It might not be legal because of tax evasion.
评论 #20283491 未加载
NetOpWibbyalmost 6 years ago
The comments on that article are better than the article itself.
mjl-almost 6 years ago
to which projects do you donate? the ones you used in your paid work? the ones you wish would improve? the ones which need it most?
评论 #20282940 未加载
kiranknalmost 6 years ago
Like the idea !
masonicalmost 6 years ago
I hope the writer puts some of those proceeds toward a proofreader.
revskillalmost 6 years ago
Imagine from the beginning of github, you do that, then OSS will die from day 1.<p>I&#x27;m sure it&#x27;s not the right way to make OSS sustainable.<p>The only way (which i believe) to make OSS sustainable, is that, you open source the core or toolings, let others fork it, and you make contract to support enterprise clients, to support the open core.
评论 #20281715 未加载
评论 #20281594 未加载