TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: What is broken with job hiring processes?

16 pointsby calderarrowover 5 years ago
It seems like the job recruitment is convoluted and difficult for both job-posters and job-seekers, but nothing has been done about it. Why?

10 comments

winternettover 5 years ago
(US East Coast)<p>1. Recruiters are scraping the same job boards applicants use.<p>2. Salary Surveys are always wrong, and many go underpaid because they don&#x27;t know how to negotiate.<p>3. Companies write contracts poorly, with little consideration for things that keep employees engaged and on a contract.<p>4. There are way too many technology stacks, too many people focus on saying theirs is the best rather than accurately evaluating solutions based on available skills and right fit to the business need.<p>5. Way too many inexperienced and untrained people in management positions. I can&#x27;t tell you how often I&#x27;ve heard IT managers say that they&#x27;re &quot;Not really a technical person&quot;. Stop hiring your unqualified friends.<p>6. Government has no idea about tech either. They need to be educated in order to protect consumers, employees, and the economy from bad tech.<p>7. Not enough consumer protection enforcement. When companies do bad things the consequences should set an example for everyone else, not just be 10% of the profit as a penalty.<p>8. Employees need better vacation, and more options for flexible work days. 40 hour weeks are a lot, the standard for industry leave is usually 15 days a year now. The entire stat of Virginia has an &quot;At Will&quot; employment policy. No wonder why really productive projects suffer from attrition and buron out. You only get out of that trap if you have the power to negotiate, but companies need to create better policies and stick to them for all employees.<p>9. Recruiters need to educate themselves on technology. Stop lying to candidates about positions, you should know the difference between Angular and Python. You should also always be up front about where the work location is, and stop sending me text messages you vultures... Email works just fine.
quaquaqua1over 5 years ago
I would argue that two major factors are really affecting the market on both sides-- one is that cost of living in many places is extremely high, and the other is that businesses are demanding people with deep understanding of complex technology from day 1.<p>Decades ago, cost of living was lower, and apprenticeships or &quot;learning on the job&quot; was tolerated.<p>These days the landlord wants 30k a year, and the employer wants to pay bargain basement for &quot;10+ years of reactjs experience&quot; :)
tmm84over 5 years ago
My comment is going to cover some of the answers given by others but here is my view of the situation.<p>Management&#x2F;HR: 1. They don&#x27;t know programming (to them it&#x27;s magic). 2. They are afraid of paying for people who are less than rockstar. If they can&#x27;t keep up with the Googles and Facebooks then they can&#x27;t succeed they hear. 3. Technology&#x2F;market has been moving faster than developers can develop. Need it yesterday is the theme management dances to and they don&#x27;t care about paying you 30 hours of overtime if they can get something to market this week instead 2 weeks later under a relaxed deadline. 4. All computers work like Star Trek because Siri can tell them the weather according to their logic.<p>Programmers: 1. Starting your own framework or library just to advertise&#x2F;divide the mindshare of other programmers instead of collaborating. 2. Not knowing how to interview candidates correctly (talk about programming? nah, just come up with a programming whiteboard then nickpick them to death to find one good enough to play sidekick.). 3. Working for less&#x2F;putting in too many hours. Working for less brings the profession down and putting in too many hours reinforces the idea that only good programmers put in loads of overtime.<p>Of course this isn&#x27;t 100% spot on for every company, market and country but it is what I see most of the time.
crohover 5 years ago
This is just one of the many side-effects of money-oriented society. People work to earn money. Not because they love work.<p>1. Business owner just want paying customers, they don&#x27;t care about product.<p>2. Your tech-lead&#x2F;manager&#x2F;solution-architect has stop coding for last 15 years (or never did it). So s&#x2F;he choose the most hyped stack (or js-framework-of-week). Now to justify his decision, he needs team with that skill or he put blame on HR<p>3. HR doesn&#x27;t understand damn thing neither they care for HUMANS. Their job is finding RESOURCE. So they just look for keywords in resume and contact each and every single candidate having keywords in resume.<p>4. Candidate deeply hate computer science fundamentals. And believe that being hacker is cool and can learn lot of money&#x2F;girl&#x2F;boys&#x2F;fame. So he tries to show off himself by somehow adding hyped keywords in resume ( or most of time copy-pasting resume).<p>Now after all this, if product succeeds believe me amigo, you&#x27;re very lucky or someone just robbed by your product.
评论 #20809059 未加载
qualsiasiover 5 years ago
(Europe &#x2F; Tech)<p>1. HR is not tech-savy and most of the time does look for distinguished engineers at the price of an intern<p>2. Salary is always on the low side, and salary range is almost never included in the job posting<p>3. Companies are not considering their employees an asset, but a liability
JSeymourATLover 5 years ago
&gt; for both job-posters and job-seekers...<p>Chiefly, that Hiring Managers &amp; Executives are almost completely divorced from the actual process of identifying, assessing, and attracting people.<p>They leave this grunt work to Human Resource Flunkies and Recruiter Bozos (wrongly believing that&#x27;s HR job).<p>Yet, executives who get this right-- take an intensely methodical, personal, hands-on approach.<p>THE ELUSIVE FORMULA FOR GREAT HIRING &gt; <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;mastersofscale.com&#x2F;#&#x2F;aneel-bhusri-the-elusive-formula-for-great-hiring" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;mastersofscale.com&#x2F;#&#x2F;aneel-bhusri-the-elusive-formul...</a>
theriddlrover 5 years ago
Non-technical people doing the hiring. Keyword bingo and thinking Java and JavaScript are the same thing. The endless search for a unicorn or Goldilocks hiring (not unqualified, but not too good either). HR lacking EQ when they reject with weak white lies – this reflects badly on the company when the candidate is more qualified in the future.
lkiernanover 5 years ago
Job-posters lie, job-seekers lie.
tempsdlfkjsover 5 years ago
1. Wanting to hire people that can scale to millions of users when you only have less than 10,000 users<p>2. Agism
isaaafcover 5 years ago
For software engineering, whiteboard tests&#x2F;leetcode questions.