TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Superior IQs associated with mental and physical disorders, research suggests

494 pointsby tabletover 5 years ago

78 comments

TurkishPoptartover 5 years ago
I went through a battery of IQ tests as a kid and got a _high_ score (139). But that was when I was seven years old. I&#x27;m 30 now, have a master&#x27;s degree (which was pretty pointless) and make 25 bucks an hour as a temp (more money than I&#x27;ve ever made in my life). I think my life and prospects have dimmed because I haven&#x27;t been able to get over the anxiety and the depression that impact me every day. Interviewed for jobs for 14 months and didn&#x27;t get a single offer. Haven&#x27;t had a girlfriend in 3 years, lazy as shit, can&#x27;t even look at myself in the mirror. Anyway, what I&#x27;m trying to say is IQ is bullshit, and discipline, social skills, and connections are priceless.<p>But we grew up in the world told we could do anything we wanted! I think it&#x27;s that sort of expectation that is screwing with us (at least those of us that didn&#x27;t become comfy SWEs).
评论 #21254149 未加载
评论 #21254190 未加载
评论 #21253985 未加载
评论 #21254334 未加载
评论 #21254147 未加载
评论 #21255601 未加载
评论 #21254058 未加载
评论 #21253933 未加载
评论 #21254690 未加载
评论 #21254623 未加载
评论 #21254411 未加载
评论 #21255448 未加载
评论 #21254414 未加载
评论 #21255684 未加载
评论 #21253981 未加载
评论 #21254648 未加载
评论 #21254551 未加载
评论 #21254407 未加载
评论 #21256149 未加载
评论 #21255270 未加载
评论 #21254629 未加载
评论 #21255645 未加载
评论 #21254600 未加载
评论 #21254212 未加载
评论 #21255641 未加载
评论 #21255962 未加载
评论 #21254677 未加载
评论 #21255291 未加载
评论 #21254493 未加载
评论 #21258090 未加载
评论 #21255821 未加载
评论 #21255921 未加载
评论 #21259239 未加载
评论 #21257524 未加载
评论 #21257828 未加载
评论 #21254598 未加载
评论 #21254473 未加载
评论 #21256545 未加载
评论 #21255639 未加载
评论 #21256712 未加载
评论 #21253994 未加载
评论 #21254083 未加载
评论 #21255171 未加载
评论 #21257557 未加载
评论 #21256906 未加载
评论 #21254247 未加载
评论 #21255930 未加载
评论 #21256625 未加载
评论 #21254587 未加载
评论 #21257112 未加载
评论 #21257173 未加载
评论 #21257236 未加载
评论 #21254601 未加载
评论 #21260523 未加载
invalidOrTakenover 5 years ago
Ugh, this study selected its &quot;superior iq&quot; group by surveying Mensa members. Study (<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.sciencedirect.com&#x2F;science&#x2F;article&#x2F;pii&#x2F;S0160289616303324#!" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.sciencedirect.com&#x2F;science&#x2F;article&#x2F;pii&#x2F;S016028961...</a>) makes no mention of this selection bias, though even the <i>article</i> does.
评论 #21254365 未加载
评论 #21254056 未加载
评论 #21254345 未加载
评论 #21254338 未加载
评论 #21253832 未加载
评论 #21258272 未加载
评论 #21253877 未加载
评论 #21254284 未加载
评论 #21253882 未加载
starpilotover 5 years ago
&gt; It turns out that the people who join Mensa and attend meetings are, on average, not successful titans of industry. They are instead – and I say this with great affection – huge losers. I was making $735 per month and I was like frickin’ Goldfinger in this crowd. We had a guy who was some sort of poet who hoped to one day start “writing some of them down.” We had people who were literally too smart to hold a job. The rest of the group dressed too much like street people to ever get past security for a job interview. And everyone was always available for meetings on weekend nights.<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;woodrow.typepad.com&#x2F;the_ponderings_of_woodrow&#x2F;2006&#x2F;11&#x2F;scott_adams_on_.html" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;woodrow.typepad.com&#x2F;the_ponderings_of_woodrow&#x2F;2006&#x2F;1...</a>
评论 #21254715 未加载
评论 #21255501 未加载
评论 #21257328 未加载
评论 #21255958 未加载
评论 #21254647 未加载
zxcmxover 5 years ago
Edit: Joining Mensa is associated with mental and physical disorders.
评论 #21257413 未加载
评论 #21254268 未加载
underwaterover 5 years ago
Using Mensa members as the study group seems fatally flawed.<p>Mensa seems to attract people who define themselves by their intelligence, instead of by their success. It wouldn&#x27;t surprise me that they would be more anxious and depressed than average.<p>Higher rates of allergies could be explained by socioeconomic, racial and cultural biases in those who gravitate towards Mensa.
评论 #21253989 未加载
评论 #21256992 未加载
uberduberover 5 years ago
I have managed many people in industries that attract low IQ (70-90) workers. I also know a lot of high IQ people since I went to a gifted high school.<p>I&#x27;m not a psychiatrist, but I believe the low IQ have WAY higher rates of anxiety, depression, and other mental disorders, but almost none of them are diagnosed. Their lives run without much thought or planning so they often end up in very stressful situations. Sometimes they don&#x27;t even realize that something is wrong or not normal. Or even if they do manage to figure that out, they cannot describe what they are feeling or communicate effectively which can be stressful in itself.<p>I still think high IQ people have mild to moderately higher rates of mental disorders than normal IQ people, but with low IQ I think it&#x27;s massively higher.
评论 #21257262 未加载
DanielleMolloyover 5 years ago
I’ve had this little pet theory about high achievers and depression for some time. It boils down to:<p>They apply the same thinking patterns that make them excel at work (= very controlled environments with binary answers, requiring perfectionism and attention to detail - e.g. programming, maths, fact-checking, engineering, arts) to every area in their far less binary lives.<p>If you have very high standards at work you likely apply very high standards to yourself. How you view yourself is frequently how you view others, which can be destructive for relationships.<p>If your job is searching for bugs 8h a day you likely develop the thinking pattern to take even the smallest issue very seriously.
评论 #21254697 未加载
评论 #21254900 未加载
评论 #21254522 未加载
RandomTiskover 5 years ago
I have a theory about high IQ and anxiety:<p>The more intelligent and creative a person, the more sensitive to negative emotion they&#x27;re going to be, simply because their subconscious mind will see more connections between their negative emotions and the things, people and places the person has, sees or frequents. In other words, they&#x27;ll naturally realize the world is more inhospitable than the average intellect, so their subconscious will have more negative data points to track. When something bad happens, they&#x27;ll need to work harder to convince their subconscious that it won&#x27;t happen again.<p>Anxiety itself is therefore because the subconscious currently sees familiar patterns it saw before, during painful experiences, and it throws out feelings of anxiety to slow down the conscious mind to force caution, as if the person is looking at a minefield and may not know it.<p>Edit: And the key to living anxiety-free, at least for my own personal experience, is understanding every negative emotion in my past, why it happened (whether my fault or not), how I reacted, and how I would react today In a way that would avoid the same terrible outcome. Usually it requires forgiveness, either for something someone did to me or to forgive myself because I was ignorant but no longer am and most importantly I&#x2F;my subconscious knows if my forgiveness is genuine, namely when I&#x27;m ready to sympathize with someone else in the same situation. It&#x27;s incredibly liberating.
评论 #21254670 未加载
评论 #21255697 未加载
DoreenMicheleover 5 years ago
When I was involved with The TAG Project, this was common knowledge in gifted circles online. This is not limited to Mensa at all. Some fairly well-known names in the gifted community referred to issues like OCD and ADHD as &quot;co-morbidities&quot; for lack of a better word.<p>The higher the IQ, the more likely there are to be other issues and the more likely they are to be severe.<p>Similarly, Ashkenazi Jews win some inordinately high number of Nobel Prizes and happen to be a population with a high risk for genetic disorders, some of which have been proven to have impact on cognition.<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.quora.com&#x2F;Why-do-Jews-constitute-20-of-all-Nobel-laureates-despite-being-0-19-of-the-worlds-population-What-specific-sociocultural-elements-are-the-root-cause-of-this-phenomenon" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.quora.com&#x2F;Why-do-Jews-constitute-20-of-all-Nobel...</a><p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.m.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Ashkenazi_Jewish_intelligence" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.m.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Ashkenazi_Jewish_intelligenc...</a>
评论 #21254384 未加载
评论 #21254122 未加载
freshhawkover 5 years ago
This study shows that being in Mensa is associated with mental and physical disorders - based on self-reporting.<p>I appreciate the irony of this study having been done by people who were being very very dumb.
blablablergover 5 years ago
Saw an interesting talk on youtube about high IQ and underachievement, shame it is in Belgian dutch (<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=oFCLdJVoHVg" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=oFCLdJVoHVg</a>).<p>She states that an high IQ is most likely going to be an impediment to a succesful career rather than an advantage if unmanaged, because education is set up for the average kid. She makes an interesting car analogy: it doesn&#x27;t matter whether you are too long or too short, if you deviate too much from the average length your seating is going to suck. Likewise, high IQ kids placed in the average education environment are going to get bored quickly, which if not overcome compounds over the years resulting in unsatisfying academic achievement.<p>Another interesting analogy she makes is regarding athletes. When a recruiter finds a kid with high athletic potential, they get special training to transform that talent into superior skill. But children with a high IQ people are stuck in the school system designed for the average IQ kid, because in education they tend to think that &quot;everything is so easy for them&quot; instead of &quot;they require special attention to let that talent bloom&quot;.<p>So she claims that a high IQ warrants special attention to turn it into an advantage, otherwise there is an considarable risk of an unsuccesful life, which i personally can attest to.<p>I was tested with an IQ of 140, almost dropped out of college, still managed to finish it at the age of 30, way too late. And while I have a decent job, chances of promotion are low because employers tend prefer the candidates who did finish their education in the avarage timespan. So now I am stuck in a dead-end and that is very frustrating because I know I can do better than most, and have gained the required displicine but get passed over because in my professional area they prefer the kids who did everything the way society set it up for them. My parents where even told that I needed special attention, but they couldn&#x27;t afford it, so now I have to deal with it. Sucks but thats life for me I guess.
评论 #21256988 未加载
评论 #21256909 未加载
keiferskiover 5 years ago
Isn&#x27;t it a likely explanation that society is generally structured (consciously and unconsciously) for the average person and therefore the further you get away from the average, the less ability to have to connect with the broad group&#x2F;culture identity, ergo leading to isolation and thus more social and psychological issues?<p>For example - imagine that you have an IQ of 150 in a society where the average is 100. If suddenly everyone else&#x27;s IQ jumped 50 points, the society would then change to reflect this new increase in intelligence - jobs, social roles, and other aspects of culture would be different than those from the 100 IQ culture.
评论 #21257380 未加载
Hittonover 5 years ago
I always thought that high IQ is correlated with high anxiety, because the smarter a person is, the better he can imagine all possible things to go wrong. On the other end of spectrum are people with IQ comparable to children, who presumably don&#x27;t worry about too many things - ignorance is bliss.
评论 #21254348 未加载
zabzonkover 5 years ago
Anecdote:<p>My Dad was a MENSA member for a couple of years, but he was mostly taking the piss - he put down his &quot;special interest&quot; as &quot;carved Dravidian lapis lazuli&quot;, which is not as far as I know a thing. He was an RAF V-bomber captain and never as far as I could see suffered from depression or other mental health issues (which would have affected his security clearance) - much the reverse.<p>Edit: The lapis lazuli thing is (per Google) actually a thing, but in the early 1960s I don&#x27;t see how my Dad could have come across it, but obviously he did.<p>I could have joined MENSA (had the IQ) but thought it was all too silly and didn&#x27;t. I&#x27;ve suffered a lot from depression.<p>Go figure.
yummypaintover 5 years ago
Advice to parents: Don&#x27;t tell your kids their IQ. There are good reasons not to whether it is low or high, plus it doesnt mean that much. My parents offered to tell me my first year of high school after a big science fair win, but I didn&#x27;t want to know. At the time I think I needed to believe I had the hardware needed to keep chewing what I had bitten off. A few years later, I had the luxury of still feeling like my achievements were born out of patience and passion rather than talent. I didn&#x27;t finally ask until I was in grad school and knew myself well. Im grateful to have been given that choice.
Knufenover 5 years ago
When I was 18 I tested 135 on a FRT based on Raven Matrices. I briefly joined Mensa and what I saw was quite depressing. Dysfunction upon dysfunction and wasted potential. Except for the dysfunction it reminded me too much of myself and I had to quit. This is of course a limited data set so take it with a grain of salt.<p>I would recommend <a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;prometheussociety.org&#x2F;wp&#x2F;articles&#x2F;the-outsiders&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;prometheussociety.org&#x2F;wp&#x2F;articles&#x2F;the-outsiders&#x2F;</a>
manjanaover 5 years ago
Even for those with a normal IQ range and properly more so for those with better ability to recognize patterns - the world is a scary place sometimes.<p>Being able to predict mind games, deception, passive aggressiveness without those at fault will admit to it can make you question your own sanity easily - now what if you had sharpened senses that picked up on these things.<p>How I see it, the bottom line is this. If you are surrounded by a good and suppprting tribe it can be a gift, but at the other end it can seem like a mean curse.
a-dubover 5 years ago
when i was in grade school, i was tested and put into the &quot;gifted and talented&quot; program which was mostly just a one hour session once a week with about eight kids. it was mostly just brain teasers but then they literally spent an entire year explaining and stressing the importance of charisma. they also told us that &quot;this is easy for you now, and you may not have to work hard, but you need to learn how to work hard because one day you&#x27;ll be taking classes that you can&#x27;t just breeze through and if you don&#x27;t know how to study you will fail.&quot;<p>they were right on both counts. many times later in college and in working life i&#x27;ve thought back to these moments.<p>also, &quot;overexcitability&quot;, yup.
评论 #21254644 未加载
评论 #21254929 未加载
losvedirover 5 years ago
I hate when IQ comes up on Hacker News because it&#x27;s a topic that everyone feels like they have something to contribute on, and there&#x27;s so many misconceptions floating around it&#x27;s hard to know what&#x27;s &quot;orthodox&quot; so to speak.<p>Does anyone have a good reference about what the current, academic general understanding with regard to intelligence is? Are there any surveys of practicing psychologists, etc?<p>The best I&#x27;ve found is the &quot;Intelligence Knowns and Unknowns&quot;[0] task force report published by the American Psychological Association in 1995, but I&#x27;m not aware of any such report since then.<p>My takeaways from that report, are that IQ does capture the concept of &quot;intelligence&quot; that most people understand exists, that the tests aren&#x27;t biased or flawed anymore, that IQ can&#x27;t really be changed with any known interventions, and that it correlates well with success in school, jobs, and life.<p>I&#x27;d love to know if that&#x27;s still the academic consensus. You&#x27;d never know from these threads where people chime in with their own anecdotes <i>what&#x27;s</i> real.<p>[0] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Intelligence:_Knowns_and_Unknowns" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Intelligence:_Knowns_and_Unkno...</a>
评论 #21257809 未加载
zw123456over 5 years ago
The old trope is that there is a &quot;fine line between genius and insanity&quot;. I was testing with above average IQ at a young age (6th grade, 11yrs old) of 160 or in that range many times since. But I have noticed that many of my family members, friends, associates and coworkers seem to look at my behavior with skew towards that bias. In my view, I think this idea that genius and insanity or abnormal behavior has been so ingrained in peoples minds that when they meet someone with elevated IQ they look for indicators to support their bias (bias confirmation). I think I am no weirder than other people, I know several people who clearly do not have elevated IQ&#x27;s and they seem to &quot;get away with&quot; various strange behaviors but because they are &quot;normal&quot; it goes without notice. In my experience, once you are labeled with the big brain you come under more scrutiny than norms. Also, I don&#x27;t think Mensa is a good sample, my experience is that people who seek the big brain recognition through things like Mensa may also have personality traits that trend towards those types of disorders. A true double blind study would need to be peer reviewed before I would lend any credence to this hypothesis.
icedchaiover 5 years ago
As a &quot;gifted child&quot; of the 80&#x27;s, this is obvious to anyone who was identified as one or had friends who were. Depression, OCD, anxiety, etc. are all very common in that crowd.
lucas_membraneover 5 years ago
I scored 166 when they gave us an IQ test in the 8th grade. Two years later I gave myself an IQ test from a book in the local library, and I scored 149. Following that trend line, my IQ is now approximately minus 300, but the headline gives me some hope that my various disorders have slowed my rate of IQ decline.
Madmallardover 5 years ago
The kind of people that join a club to prove they are high IQ are likely insecure and feel the need to peacock. No wonder there&#x27;s a higher incidence.<p>Most high IQ people I know think Mensa is stupid and just want to have normal lives and hate talking about intelligence and think it&#x27;s irrelevant and a cringe-worthy topic.
评论 #21254129 未加载
lallysinghover 5 years ago
&quot; example, people preoccupied with intellectual pursuits may spend less time than the average person on physical exercise and social interaction&quot;<p>...or Mensa members are more interested in analyzing themselves as a whole, and will seek diagnosis more often than the general population.
acscottover 5 years ago
Sampling the set of Mensa members is not the same as sampling &quot;superior IQs&quot;.<p>digression: My personal preference is to call IQ a testing quotient and not intelligence quotient--it&#x27;s more specific and less qualitative, for &quot;intelligence&quot; is overloaded.
raincomover 5 years ago
Late Dr. Oliver Sacks, a famous neurologist, became a neurologist because his brother had schizophrenia. Many of his books contains cases of people with extraordinary abilities, but with mental disorders.
zamfiover 5 years ago
&quot;Mensa membership associated with mental and physical disorders, research suggests&quot; would be both a more accurate description of the results, as well as perhaps a more believable correlation.
kumarvvrover 5 years ago
Perhaps people with superior IQs think and stress a lot.<p>I recently came across the work of Dr. Robert Sapolsky and his research highlights the long term effects of chronic stress.<p>It is possible that higher IQs lead to a lot of thinking and stressing out.<p>I can safely consider myself in the above average IQ bracket and I tend to stress a lot about things as obscure as the world&#x27;s oceans, climate, politics, science, the Arctic ice, etc.<p>My brother is less inclined academically, is of a very easy going nature and always seems to be happy, with the exception being during difficult times in his business.
jowdayover 5 years ago
Is it possible that the study shows that high IQ people who bother to join a &quot;high IQ society&quot; tend towards higher mental and physical disorders, rather than high IQ people in general?
nopinsightover 5 years ago
This paper made some news before and was also debunked back then. Note that (2017) should be added.<p>Here is a quote from Neuroskeptic:<p>“The ‘national average’ data in the mood disorders category, for instance, are taken from the NCS-R survey (data collected 2001-2003.) The NCS-R survey did not ask people whether they’d been diagnosed with a mood disorder. Instead, trained interviewers asked participants a series of questions about their mood, emotions, sleep, and other symptoms, and made diagnoses based on strict criteria.<p>Doctors in the real world don’t diagnose depression the NCS-R way, so we can’t compare the NCS-R estimate of mood disorder prevalence to the estimate of diagnosed prevalence from Karpinski et al.’s survey. It’s comparing Malus and Citrus.<p>Secondly, I have concerns about the sample. This wasn’t a study of high-IQ people. It was a study of Mensans, a self-selected subgroup of high-IQ people. 6.5 million Americans fall in the top 2% of IQ, and only 55,000 of them are members of American Mensa.<p>In other words, Mensans make up about 0.8% of high-IQs, and Karpinski et al. have data from less than 10% of Mensans, so the sample is seriously unrepresentative.“<p><a href="http:&#x2F;&#x2F;blogs.discovermagazine.com&#x2F;neuroskeptic&#x2F;2017&#x2F;10&#x2F;22&#x2F;intelligence-risk-illness&#x2F;#.XaU5MowxVvI" rel="nofollow">http:&#x2F;&#x2F;blogs.discovermagazine.com&#x2F;neuroskeptic&#x2F;2017&#x2F;10&#x2F;22&#x2F;in...</a>
geoelectricover 5 years ago
It&#x27;s unclear to me that they&#x27;ve controlled for &quot;people who join Mensa.&quot;<p>To be clear, I&#x27;m not throwing shade, and I was a member for awhile before I got sick of paying dues, getting spammed, and not going to meetings. They&#x27;re a fine organization, spam aside.<p>But in general, people who join clubs based on personal qualities do so because they put some level of value and identity in that quality. <i>Some</i> people who tend that way do so because they have an emotional hole to fill, and <i>some</i> people who tend that way do so because it&#x27;s their dominant positive quality (in their own perception).<p>So, neither of those speak to Mensa&#x27;s core message of joining so you have people as smart as you to converse with. But both of those suggest a higher potential for Mensa members in general to have life issues they&#x27;re compensating for by joining intelligence clubs.<p>I do believe the basic trend that very smart people have more mental disorders, at least. I think our knowledge of twice-exceptional people has grown a lot over time, and I think there&#x27;s plenty of anecdotal evidence that quirks come with the intelligence territory. Get quirky enough and a quirk is a diagnosis. But I&#x27;m not convinced that particular skew starts at the 95% percentile.
breadandcrumbelover 5 years ago
Could this be caused by people with higher IQ being more honest and knowledgeable about things?<p>The average person has undiagnosed issues. They may have a mood disorder, but either deny that they have something wrong with them or have never bothered to have it checked out?<p>Compared to people who care enough to officially test their IQ. I argue that more people in a group like Mensa are more aware of their diagnosis&#x27; than the average person.
johngrefeover 5 years ago
While this is a neat surface level study, there&#x27;s a few issues I see with it.<p>&gt;No separation of Full Intellectual Assessment or another re-test, simply self reporting the averaged figure. We lack resolution in results.(ex: were people with high verbal IQ more prone to schizophrenia?)<p>&gt;Subjects were those concerned with their own mental status. All respondents were MENSA members. While I could test into MENSA, I simply don&#x27;t care. I have a friend who is in MENSA, they are quite proud of this over dinner conversation, but they are also quite neurotic. This observation is anecdotal, but I&#x27;d think you&#x27;re going to get more people who live a lot of time &quot;in their heads&quot; in MENSA. I would love to have another control group to compare results over.<p>&gt;They understand that self reporting is ripe for error. An online survey is difficult to accurately administer, people will misrepresent things about them, especially if they think it is a reflection of their own personal value.<p>It&#x27;s neat, but I don&#x27;t think it&#x27;s reliable enough to make any declarative statements about a linear progression of IQ and health disorders.
NicoJuicyover 5 years ago
There&#x27;s a quote I have and that is that smart people have a harder time being happy, because they worry too much.<p>I&#x27;ve never put it to test with others though.<p>The reasoning is that you see some sort of pattern always and you believe it&#x27;s the end of the world.<p>Eg. China, climate change, ...<p>So you believe you need to earn as much as possible, so your odds for survival are better ( as an example).<p>Narcissists don&#x27;t have this problem, as they are focused on themselves.
_bxg1over 5 years ago
Anecdotally, I know a lot of very smart people and many of them have combinations of anxiety&#x2F;depression&#x2F;chronic pain&#x2F;etc.
dcanelhasover 5 years ago
I think a flaw in this study is looking at people who joined a club for smart people rather than just smart people.
tim333over 5 years ago
There&#x27;s an interesting if not politically correct theory that<p>&gt;Jews as a group inherit significantly higher verbal and mathematical intelligence and somewhat lower spatial intelligence than other ethnic groups, on the basis of inherited diseases and the peculiar economic situation of Ashkenazi Jews in the Middle Ages.<p>as<p>&gt;During the [...] period, laws barred Ashkenazi Jews from most jobs, including farming and crafts, and forced them into finance, management, and international trade. Wealthy Jews had several more children per family than poor Jews.<p>I&#x27;m half jewish genetically myself and there do seem to be differences between the jewish and non jewish relatives kind of along those lines. (<a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Ashkenazi_Jewish_intelligence" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Ashkenazi_Jewish_intelligence</a>)
c3534lover 5 years ago
So to be clear, this wasn&#x27;t a study of people with high IQs, it was a study of people who signed up for a high IQ club that wasn&#x27;t, say, academic research. Sounds like you&#x27;re looking at people where the biggest thing going for them is not their accomplishments, but their IQ score.
mongeeseover 5 years ago
Reading the study, it&#x27;s more like, people whose identity is tied up with being smart, (members of Mensa) spend a lot of time thinking about their mental health and are likely to think that they are not normal and are also like to respond to questionnaires about their mental health.
phkahlerover 5 years ago
&gt;&gt; This theory holds that, for all of its advantages, being highly intelligent is associated with psychological and physiological “overexcitabilities,” or OEs.<p>On a speculative note, maybe those OEs are a result of maltreatment of some sort (there are many).
misevover 5 years ago
The study was only done on members of American Mensa, I wonder if there would be any difference across countries.<p>I&#x27;m from a poor European country; in high school (~15 years ago) I measured 156 in a Mensa IQ test, a friend had 168, and a third friend 172. We were top students in the generation, going to programming and math competitions. Definitely not in the popular kids club, but otherwise perfectly normal as far as I can tell. In the couple of Mensa meetings I&#x27;ve been to back then I have not really seen any of the mental or physical disorders considered in the study either.
gojomoover 5 years ago
I suspect a form of survivorship bias is contributing to these results.<p>Less-high-IQ people with the same disorders may never be diagnosed with these sorts of (often subtle &amp; subjective) mood&#x2F;anxiety&#x2F;learning&#x2F;chronic-immune disorders.<p>Perhaps, even, less-high-IQ people are more likely to literally perish before such diagnoses show up in national averages.<p>(And that&#x27;s before considering the filter that many others have already mentioned: that only some, potentially-unrepresentative high-IQ people find the idea of joining MENSA appealing.)
harry8over 5 years ago
IQ is bullshit. Children surrounded by adults who believe that bullshit correlate highly with adults who maybe aren&#x27;t doing the best job caring - and possibly nobody is at fault there. IQ is literally another example of the abject failure of psychology as an intellectual discipline. May it one day be rectified because the subject matter is fascinating and obviously deeply important.<p>Choosing to not let children in your care do IQ tests is correlated with sensible, caring, intelligent adulting. No really. Really.
lawlorinoover 5 years ago
Unsurprised that most of the comments on this post are just people number dropping their IQ and anecdotes about their mental health problems and minimal discussion of the article itself.
评论 #21257006 未加载
评论 #21257024 未加载
Tomminnover 5 years ago
Mensa members are an extremely biased sample of high IQ individuals.
todaysAIover 5 years ago
This article sort-of falls in line with my theories on non-local consciousness. Intelligence could be just a particular manner in which that person&#x27;s brain is accessing the consciousness dimension, and these mental disorders are just side-effects of this access. For example, I feel that the autistic can be more &#x27;in-tune&#x27; with the non-local consciousness, which is why they have (generally) a different thought process. (I have ASD)
NohatCoderover 5 years ago
Look at it like this: If high intelligence didn&#x27;t come with some pretty serious drawbacks, evolution would have made short work of dumb people long ago.
评论 #21256991 未加载
KhanMahGretschover 5 years ago
&gt;From a practical standpoint, this research may ultimately lead to insights about how to improve people’s psychological and physical well-being. If overexcitabilities turn out to be the mechanism underlying the IQ-health relationship, then interventions aimed at curbing these sometimes maladaptive responses may help people lead happier, healthier lives.<p>Reading between the lines, in these cooling months, sent a chill up my spine.
didibusover 5 years ago
Reading some of the other comments got me wondering, it seems most people had their IQ test when young, and were told their scores by their parents. I wonder two things, what would happen if they took that test again, would they score similarly now? And what if their parents told them a higher score then they actually did, I can imagine most parents don&#x27;t want to have the you scored low conversation...
ilakshover 5 years ago
They compared it to the national average but they didn&#x27;t actually give the same survey to people who weren&#x27;t in Mensa at the same time.
elifover 5 years ago
Since disorders were self-reported, I wonder if capacity or willingness to understand complex disorders was controlled.<p>For instance, a low intelligence person might consider autism to be &quot;bad&quot; and avoid considering it, or unable to afford doctors to tell him.<p>While a high intelligence person would recognize that the autistic spectrum has advantages and disadvantages, and would be more likely to accept it.
sajidover 5 years ago
This article should be more accurately titled &quot;Mensa membership associated with mental and physical disorders, research suggests&quot;
rf15over 5 years ago
I think Mensa is not a good frame of reference for intelligent people: You have to actively work towards getting into Mensa, which limits the target group to people who are willing to do that work, pay membership and possibly desire the prestige associated with it. Therefore it is very possible that some people with mental issues use it as a gateway to self-validation.
czbondover 5 years ago
Startups and continually &quot;trying to improve the world&quot; are where my mental health was severely impacted. That can be toxic ...
hoffrocketover 5 years ago
All this study says is that there&#x27;s a correlation of Mensa membership to a higher likelihood of certain disorders. It does _NOT_ establish any causal links, or even that Mensa membership is representative of the much much larger population of people who can get a 98th percentile score on an IQ test. Perhaps disorders cause people to join Mensa? Who knows.
评论 #21255616 未加载
iamgopalover 5 years ago
We are living in a more and more defined, secure, safe world ( and part of the world where this is not the case, they are getting there sooner or later ). In defined world, characteristics other than intelligence play a much heavier role and since intelligence doesn&#x27;t rewarded enough becomes secondary. I hope it&#x27;s cycle that comes and goes.
euskeover 5 years ago
What&#x27;s more interesting to me is the fact that people are still sticking to this idea of expressing one&#x27;s intelligence with one number. Just one. Using IQ as the degree of intelligence is like using one&#x27;s weight or blood pressure as the degree of healthiness. It may be an important metrics, but only one of million variables.
评论 #21257518 未加载
KurtMuellerover 5 years ago
As I&#x27;ve gotten older, my desire to be more intelligent has gone down while my desire to be more charismatic has gone up. It seems to me the ability to create and grow the social connections I desire is the key to happiness. With that ability comes to the necessary intelligence(s) to navigate through other parts of life as well.
_the_inflatorover 5 years ago
Have a look at this IQ critic: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;medium.com&#x2F;incerto&#x2F;iq-is-largely-a-pseudoscientific-swindle-f131c101ba39" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;medium.com&#x2F;incerto&#x2F;iq-is-largely-a-pseudoscientific-...</a><p>Nassim Taleb has got some very valid points. Forget about IQ, it is not worth the time you focus on it.
bitLover 5 years ago
Highly intelligent people should be pushed to physical exercise and forced to avoid sugary&#x2F;processed food. I knew one girl with BPD and PhD and those two things helped her tremendously; every time she slipped her state rapidly deteriorated and it was hell for everyone around.
评论 #21262266 未加载
meow_mixover 5 years ago
Be careful gleaning anything with email surveys like one. There could be confounders. E.g.<p>High IQ -&gt; More $ -&gt; More likely to see Dr for diagnosis<p>I didn&#x27;t read the whole thing though--did anyone w&#x2F; the time decide to do a deep dive on the study and see how they controlled?
hardlianotionover 5 years ago
If the study is based on a comparisons between mensans and the general population, I can think of confounding factors that should make it impossible to draw these conclusions.
cwmmaover 5 years ago
the thing about an IQ is that all it measures is the ability to take an IQ test, and ability to take an IQ test is thought to correlate with some sort of thing called intelligence, but nobody is quite sure how it relates to intelligence, what intelligence even is, or if intelligence is a single thing.<p>Which is why the vast majority of the people who talk about IQ tests and IQ scores are people that scored highly on it and very much want it to mean something important.
kordlessagainover 5 years ago
Maybe people who feel the need to be in an exclusive group based on arbitrary test data are associated with mental and physical disorders, logic suggests.
FillardMillmoreover 5 years ago
I have often wondered if there&#x27;s any correlation between higher IQs and addiction rates, whether a positive correlation or a negative one.
FabHKover 5 years ago
(2017)<p>Previous discussion:<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=15886128" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=15886128</a>
scott00over 5 years ago
The result here is from a survey of Mensa members. I&#x27;m skeptical Mensa members are representative of the high IQ population as a whole.
alestainerover 5 years ago
The study did not add income as a control variable, so the article is basically about how rich people go to the therapist more often.
fortran77over 5 years ago
I&#x27;m as dumb as a rock, but perfectly happy, healthy, athletic, and gainfully employed as a PHP programmer.
GarrisonPrimeover 5 years ago
Recommended book: The Curse of the High IQ<p>Its points are debatable, but at the very least it offers some comfortable thoughts.
bashwizardover 5 years ago
I&#x27;m clearly retarded since I&#x27;m happy all the time and I have no physical disorder!
nkingsyover 5 years ago
What if mensa members seek more healthcare than an average person?
buboardover 5 years ago
Give it ~ nine months before it &#x27;s refuted.
AtlasLionover 5 years ago
Sounds true to me (though based on a sample of one), My daughter of 16 with an IQ of 152 was diagnosed with autism and social anxiety.
solidsnack9000over 5 years ago
Mutation-selection balance.
评论 #21254391 未加载
foobar_over 5 years ago
And low IQ is consistent with right-wing barbarians.
评论 #21263640 未加载
gafferongamesover 5 years ago
Can confirm.
评论 #21255835 未加载
KorematsuFredover 5 years ago
I request everyone to read Nissim Nicholas Taleb&#x27;s criticism of this IQ BS. Now, I do not buy all his arguments but I do think his broader point is pretty much valid. At their core IQ tests measure how to answer exams designed by people like them.<p>I was born dirt poor in a remote godforesaken village in India. Today I work for one of the FANG in bay area.<p>The most depressing thing about working for this employer is howe dimwitted majority of their tech employees are beyond the core tech skills. Many of them can write complex code with ease and yet they do not understand simple sarcasm or hyperbole.
评论 #21254131 未加载
评论 #21254233 未加载
评论 #21253982 未加载