TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Robot Priests Will Change Human Spirituality

2 pointsby mmonihanover 5 years ago

1 comment

AnimalMuppetover 5 years ago
What? No.<p>A real priest&#x2F;minister&#x2F;pastor&#x2F;rabbi&#x2F;imam is someone who... well, let&#x27;s split this into two possibilities.<p>Possibility 1: God is actually there, and has told us real things about himself and how we are to relate to him. A real priest&#x2F;minister&#x2F;pastor&#x2F;rabbi&#x2F;imam has <i>lived</i> some of that, and can relate to you as you try to live it, and hopefully help you. In contrast, a robot can give you answers programmed into it by some Silicon Valley engineer.<p>Possibility 2: God is not actually there. All that spirituality is junk. The only thing religion has is, maybe, some wisdom in how to live well. As I&#x27;m trying to live life and run into challenges, a real priest&#x2F;minister&#x2F;pastor&#x2F;rabbi&#x2F;imam has still lived some of those challenges, and has some idea of how to live as a human being, and can maybe help me as I try to do so. A robot, on the other hand, give me answers programmed into it by some Silicon Valley engineer.<p>In both cases, the robot is less helpful, because it doesn&#x27;t actually know what it&#x27;s like to <i>live</i>. But it&#x27;s worse if case 1 is true. It&#x27;s still worse if I, the seeker (or whatever term) <i>think</i> that case 1 is true, because I&#x27;m just about dead certain that the robot <i>hasn&#x27;t</i> lived the spirituality that it&#x27;s trying to help guide me to.