TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

How to solve the British maths problem?

9 pointsby reazalunalmost 17 years ago

5 comments

neilkalmost 17 years ago
Is anyone else ever disturbed by the attempts to "make X fun!" by inclusion of cartoon characters and other inanity? I think it's a distraction; the kids just pay attention to the cartoon.<p>I know that some teachers would disagree, but in my experience, most teachers at the primary level don't really love math. Not the way I do, anyway. At the very best, you get people who liked doing rote problems, and those sorts of people just suck. The rest struggle through the lessons as much as their charges do, and they'd be lost without the teacher's guide.<p>In my opinion, the way to make math fun is to make the exercise of the skill itself more fun. Make it part of a game. For bonus points, make the game complex enough that multiple strategies can work, estimation or direct calculation or induction. And I'd like some recognition of the fact that some people are insanely good at this and others will always struggle, so create teams where different skills are useful (calculation, problem solving, record keeping, data gathering) but everyone learns the basic lessons.<p>Sooner or later you're going to be alone with the pencil and paper and Mr. 4 and Ms. 5 are not going to be there to help.
评论 #238258 未加载
DougBTXalmost 17 years ago
The problem is demonstrated by the video in the article. Maths? Here, try some Long Division. You could get yourself a <i>maths degree</i> without even touching long division, but it's the example they use to get people to do maths??
评论 #238132 未加载
评论 #238342 未加载
vitaminjalmost 17 years ago
A lot of the guys I knew that were good at maths were labelled nerds, so to admit to being good at maths is to risk being labelled a nerd by association. On the other hand, to say that you suck at maths implicity says things about you that avoid this association eg. "I dispensed with my maths education to hang out with the cool kids". I think most people know this intuitively.<p>The pride of a self-confessed maths half-wit is anchored in implied social standing rather than genuine pride in a lack of ability. I doubt anybody is saying "I can't add or subtract, how awesome am I?"
Tichyalmost 17 years ago
I think it has to be more obvious how to apply maths to everyday life. Not sure if it is very easy to do, though.<p>One problem that comes to mind is understanding mobile telephony costs. I am amazed how many people really seem to believe that their phone only cost 1€...<p>Finances (interest rates, economics) would be another area, which could at the same time help prepare people for life after school.<p>What about games? I just bought "The Theory Of Poker", perhaps stuff like that could arouse more interest about maths in kids? They could even play games at school, imagine that.<p>Thinking about it, maybe it would be worthwhile to start a web site (wiki) about applied maths problems. Applied as in REALLY applied, everyday problems everybody could relate to.<p>I have a server and would set it up, could anybody recommend a good wiki package (debian)?
mynameisherealmost 17 years ago
I looked at the division problem and guessed 472, and got it right. I think guessing accurately is important. You almost never have time to work things out. The 4 was obvious, and the 2 was probable--they wouldn't likely require a remainder from people. And so that left the 7 to guess.<p>I mean, given a set of problems requiring such division, most could be acceptably answered by nearly-correct answers. This isn't true in finance, but for most other things it is.