TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Did Google's AI run amok?

8 pointsby Ireneover 4 years ago
4 years ago I uploaded an unlisted video on youtube - video of a medical procedure, esophagogastroduodenoscopy. It did not have any views, I was keeping it just in case I need to show it to a doctor. Today I got an e-mail labeling it with adult content and warning about my channel (my other videos were of a Christmas tree and such, all unlisted). I changed video settings from unlisted to private and made it age-restricted - I understand that medicine is not for kids. I appealed since I wanted to help their AI (Remember Facebook's AI labeling a photo of onions for 'sexually suggestive' content?). I've just got another e-mail where they said that I lost my appeal, my videos are not safe and Youtube deleted them all. They said they'll forever label my content as age-restricted. Are we already in an Orwellian Dystopia?

4 comments

st1x7over 4 years ago
&gt; Did Google&#x27;s AI run amok?<p>No, there&#x27;s no AI in what you&#x27;re talking about and it certainly isn&#x27;t running amok. A classification algorithm flagged a video showing the inside of someone&#x27;s body as not suitable for children. You could argue either that the algorithm made a mistake, or that the algorithm worked as expected and you disagree with youtube&#x27;s policy on what is adult content.<p>&gt; Are we already in an Orwellian Dystopia?<p>No, youtube aren&#x27;t a government and they aren&#x27;t forcing you to do anything, it would be weird if they were obliged to show any video that you upload regardless of the content. At worst, they&#x27;re possibly giving you a bad user experience and poor customer service.
ignorancepriorover 4 years ago
YouTube&#x27;s customer support is notoriously terrible, even for large channels. Good luck.<p>I&#x27;d recommend keeping a local copy of everything you upload just in case it gets deleted for some random reason.
Rzorover 4 years ago
Whatever you do, don&#x27;t do it with your personal account. You will never get anything back once Google lock you out.
评论 #25476889 未加载
timmytwoshotover 4 years ago
I think we are.