TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Would you pay for a beautiful and stable Linux-distro for high-end PCs?

3 pointsby abhikandoi2000about 4 years ago
By high-end I mean at least 16GB RAM, 512GB M.2 PCIe NVMe Solid State Drive (or better), min. base frequency of 2.50 GHz, quadcore Processors and above (no Ultrabook support). Think Dell XPS 15 Laptop (here: https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.dell.com&#x2F;en-us&#x2F;shop&#x2F;dell-laptops&#x2F;xps-15-laptop&#x2F;spd&#x2F;xps-15-7590-laptop&#x2F;xn7590edldh).<p>Distro would have the following focus:<p>1. battery life; above 9hrs [CRITICAL]<p>2. beautiful and fast UI [CRITICAL]<p>3. intuitive and pleasing UX [CRITICAL]<p>4. developer focus: stack exchange integration, git&#x2F;Mercurial plus GitHub, GitLab integration in explorer. tons of programmable interfaces for booting, screen etc. [CRITICAL]<p>4. only support for resolution 1080p and above (1920x1080)<p>5. only support for high-end pcs and laptops<p>6. limited drivers support to a small set of Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and other common devices (based on who&#x27;s willing to pay)<p>7. Linux based and open source<p>8. no support for legacy drivers and devices<p>Expected audience is a small set of maybe around 10,000 people &#x2F; developers who are willing to use it as their primary operating system and have an eye for battery life, design and speed.<p>Given these focus areas how much would you be willing to pay? If not for the OS itself, but for its development over a period of 2 years?

7 comments

ubermanabout 4 years ago
I guess my first reaction is what would be the value proposition over alternatives like System76 or potentially Boxx?<p>I&#x27;m also a little confused by the description, specs, and timetable. We are starting with two years for development where one might expect delivery some time after that, but I consider many of the specs to be minimums and not representative of a &quot;high end pc&quot; today.<p>While I would certainly not want a &quot;slow UI&quot;, your first 3 items seem unimportant as far as I am personally concerned. My main workstations are desktops and I almost never use my laptop when it is not plugged in. Even my laptop has about twice a guts of your spec and it is several years old now. For me battery life is completely irrelevant and I would gladly trade beautiful and pleasing for ubiquitous driver support.
评论 #26559324 未加载
kristooabout 4 years ago
I use PopOS as my OS on a high end PC and it is pretty good. There are some things which I find annoying, such as Bluetooth headphones going to a headset mode at the start of calls. Just tiny things. Would I pay to have a smoother experience? Probably, - I would like the OS to be as smooth as possible.<p>Although, I don&#x27;t think that&#x27;s the main problem with a Linux distro. Most of the friction still comes from third party apps, such as Teams (which I use for calls multiple times a week and it absolutely sucks).
评论 #26559264 未加载
solarkraftabout 4 years ago
&gt; only support for high-end pcs and laptops<p>Why? This sounds like it&#x27;s supposed to be inefficient.<p>&gt; limited drivers support to a small set of Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and other common devices (based on who&#x27;s willing to pay)<p>Also why? The Linux kernel has all the support for free.<p>That it&#x27;s open source would be a precondition for me. The closest to what you&#x27;re proposing is Elementary OS, which I would likely pay for if I was still using it.
评论 #26559224 未加载
verdvermabout 4 years ago
As a reference point, I switched from linux to a Pixelbook Go for your critical reasons. I&#x27;d have a hard time justifying a higher price. The slightly lower specs have not hindered development, tho sometimes laggy when video call + screen share + heavy website like Jira
评论 #26559245 未加载
7174n6about 4 years ago
Buy a Thinkpad X1 Carbon and install Pop_OS on it. Done. And System76 won&#x27;t charge you a cent!
评论 #26559601 未加载
yuppie_scumabout 4 years ago
You’re kinda describing MacOS
评论 #26559236 未加载
phendrenad2about 4 years ago
$300, or $600&#x2F;year
评论 #26559374 未加载