TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Help needed for medical assistance in dying

4 pointsby throw_away98321about 4 years ago
I hope you&#x27;re all managing through the pandemic. Any help would be sincerely appreciated with the following.<p>My situation isn&#x27;t pleasant. I&#x27;m having a difficult time ending my life. I live in Montreal, Quebec. Here in Canada, it&#x27;s legal to end one&#x27;s life by suicide and by a physician when the patient satisfies legal criteria for medical assistance in dying.<p>Last year I was diagnosed with cancer. I also have another illness but incurable that makes my life intolerable. I&#x27;m refusing treatment for the cancer &quot;besides pain medication&quot; because of my preexisting medical condition. I&#x27;m doing well emotionally with coping and I&#x27;ve been starting to end contacts with friends in preparation for dying.<p>From the very start of the cancer diagnosis, I&#x27;ve been requesting medical assistance in dying by speaking with my Oncologist and the request to him isn&#x27;t being processed. The hospital&#x27;s complaint commissioner isn&#x27;t helping as well. I&#x27;m spoken to a few lawyers &quot;that I cannot afford&quot; and they&#x27;ve confirmed I do qualify for medical assistance in dying but the problem is a doctor can refuse for personal reasons. So, when I go to other Hospitals, ERs, walk-ins, I&#x27;m told &quot;speak with your oncologist&quot; while they&#x27;re ignoring my explanation of why that&#x27;s not helpful. They also refuse to let me request on a form for medical assistance in dying. I&#x27;m told they don&#x27;t do that here.<p>I&#x27;m starting to get to my wits end and planning a suicide instead in the near future. I really wish I could have my death done by a physician but it seems like my age with how the cancer is currently considered treatable by surgery is making nobody want to help me until the cancer has spread everywhere. I&#x27;ve been told by my Oncologist that without treatment I&#x27;m looking at less than a year for life expectancy. Again, any help&#x2F;advice&#x2F;opinions I&#x27;m grateful to read.

2 comments

throw_away98322about 4 years ago
I&#x27;m sorry to hear about your situation. My advice would be to stop being so explicit or official. You&#x27;re probably too used to being an engineer or techie of some sort and we can get trapped in very black and white, explicit ways of thinking and speaking, forgetting that a lot of people work on implication and in a much fuzzier way. &quot;speak with your oncologist&quot; probably means <i>speak to them in the right way</i> and they can probably help. As I understand it the code is &quot;I&#x27;m in too much pain&quot; and they&#x27;ll give you a bit too much pain medication. That&#x27;s how doctors used to get around the law, the patient&#x27;s care is their highest priority and that includes trying to treat unnecessary suffering as best they can. Only egregious misuse of this power would be prosecuted.<p>That being said, you should respect your doctor&#x27;s wishes too, right? They&#x27;ll have to live with what they&#x27;ve done after you&#x27;re gone.<p>All that being said, get some counselling, seek mental help <i>of any and every kind</i>. I&#x27;m not trying to talk you out of things - your decisions are for you - I&#x27;m telling you to do <i>what you should be doing anyway</i>. Even if you get your wish to end things you should still be getting help for your mind, not just your body.<p>All the best.
s5300about 4 years ago
Google &quot;exit bag&quot;<p>There is also Dignitas in Sweden<p>Sorry if this advice is inappropriate for HN dang, death with dignity is something very important to me.<p>Also, to the OP - I am sorry your life had to be this way. Life is completely unfair and has been quite cruel and cold for pretty much all of humanity. I only wish this was taught a bit more to those who never experience it.<p>Anyways, with some severe physical ailments myself, I may be down your path soon enough