On the other side of the spectrum -- as an attractive young man who first bought into this philosophy that "looks don't matter" -- I realized only in the relatively old age of 26 that I could control other people's first reaction upon meeting me by controlling my appearance. Then it came to me that control of one's appearance is a far more sophisticated and deep skill than most people realize -- almost akin to programming. Caring about looks is just as much advertising your complexion as it is advertising the fact that you possess enough intelligence to have mastered the relatively complex skill of controlling one's appearance.<p>There is much more to knowing how to present oneself than the shallow mindset most people ascribe to those who are good at it. For as long as humans existed, people have been equally idolizing and denigrating that which they don't possess.<p>I do not mean to encourage talking to young girls in terms of their appearance -- as a matter of fact I support gender-ambivalent parenting. It's just that the author's attitude strikes me as hateful.
"and twenty-five percent of young American women would rather win America's Next Top Model than the Nobel Peace Prize."<p>I'd rather win the Boston Marathon than the ACM Turing Award. I'm no danger of winning either, so the priority could switch next week. Or maybe they look at the 2009 winner and figure they'd rather aim for something that requires work.<p>"Even bright, successful college women say they'd rather be hot than smart."<p>OK, but I've heard this before this author was born.(I suspect.)<p>I don't tell little girls they're pretty, and I don't tell children they're smart. I talk to them, when I do, without condescension, and we seem to get along fine.
If you're dating someone then I think it's ok to tell them or otherwise let them know that you think they're smart or attractive every six months or so. Less often than that and they get insecure, more often than that and either it becomes part of their identity (bad) or else it influences the power balance and relationship dynamic in other negative ways.