TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Is 5% a reasonable cut for a middle-man when selling shares privately?

6 pointsby renegadusalmost 4 years ago
I have fully-vested options in a private company which expire in Dec 2023. A company has reached out to me saying they have a buyer for the shares. The shares are worth &gt; $300k.<p>I&#x27;d like to sell because they expire in Dec 2023 and I don&#x27;t know if there will be a liquidity event before then, however they want to take a 5% cut.<p>Is this a normal cut for a middleman in this type of transaction? Is there a way I can connect with a buyer directly to avoid giving a % to a middleman like this?

9 comments

giantg2almost 4 years ago
5% sounds ok. If <i>they</i> reached out to <i>you</i>. Then maybe you can negotiate it down some.<p>There are private equity markets. You might be able to talk to a broker at a company that handles private equity (JPM?) and explain what you want to do. I would think their cut would be lower than 5%, but I have no idea.
评论 #28134602 未加载
codeduckalmost 4 years ago
95% of &gt; 300k is worth infinitely more than 100% of nothing.
评论 #28134591 未加载
97-109-107almost 4 years ago
Just to add another perspecitve here - you might find out that middleman that you can easily access might find 5% of the deal not worth their effort.<p>The logic here is that prospective providers you will find are already busy with larger deals, as they are easy to find by all other market players.<p>(This is under the assumption that you don&#x27;t have relationships with such middleman and would need to look for them)
drstewartalmost 4 years ago
&gt; Is there a way I can connect with a buyer directly to avoid giving a % to a middleman like this?<p>Sure. Find the buyer yourself. If you can&#x27;t or don&#x27;t know how, then surely it&#x27;s worth 5% to you. If you don&#x27;t think it&#x27;s worth it, then let the options expire.
babaganoosh89almost 4 years ago
5% is common for private stock market place like forge global. Often they charge the buyer 5% too.
评论 #28134619 未加载
airbreatheralmost 4 years ago
Sounds like 5% might be a total bargain in the context, what will you lose if you miss the date?
cm2012almost 4 years ago
I had shares pre-ipo worth $300k, then we ipoed and our stock price tanked while in lockup. Ended up selling at 30kish. If I could have taken liquidity pre-ipo I would have.
altdataselleralmost 4 years ago
It depends on the company, if it’s a Databricks or highly coveted unicorn, then 1% is more than enough. It ids a struggling startup or no-name, then 5% might be fair
评论 #28134611 未加载
sumanthvepaalmost 4 years ago
I would push for 2% of net sale value. But my experience is limited to India where costs are lower.