Decent article, but I guess I'll weigh in on the counter-points:<p>1. Uninformed consumers returning devices isn't unique to Android Tablets. It happens in basically every corner of the market. People buy Macs and wonder why their Windows apps don't work on them. There's really not much you can change about that, aside from trying to educate them slightly in whatever form of advertisement you have. I do think all the commercials for Android Tablets are terrible though. The iPad's wins by a landslide.<p>2. 16:9 vs 4:3 is really just personal preference. There are some apps that I really enjoy the 16:9 ratio for (like movies, books, and general internet browsing). For others, yes it does feel a bit wide or tall at times. This becomes a non-issue if you decide to go for a 7-inch tablet though, which I believe 3.2 just introduced support for.<p>3. There's a "Featured Tablet" application section on the market blatantly visible the first time you start the application. Unfortunately that's about where it ends, as there's no way to tell if an application is tablet-ready from its details page, and no way to filter for tablet-ready apps when doing a search. It's been said before, but the Market really needs an overhaul. I have noticed apps start to name themselves "HD" if they're tablet-ready, but that's not really consistent or a standard at this point.<p>4. Honeycomb's 3.2 version that released this past month now has the "app zooming" feature the author described missing.<p>5. It's been said before, but I'll repeat it here: the lack of tablet-ready apps is really just a matter of time. People tend to forget that it took iPad several months to get a decent selection of apps optimized for that screen size. This summer a good number started cropping up on the Market for Android, and now that more tablets are landing in the hands of developers (like the Transformer and Galaxy Tab), we'll no doubt see a ton of apps begin to flood us come Winter.
> However, for the amount of marketing and push that these tablets are getting, there should absolutely be not only a wide range of options, but a clearly delineated path with which to reach them. Android Market has neither. You can search for "tablet", and you hit quite a few things, and you can search for "Honeycomb", and reach some others, but you have things like themes and wallpapers for phones in the Honeycomb style that make their way into your search. Apple has two sides of the App Store - iPhone and iPad - and it's completely obvious where the tablet apps are. I'm an experienced user, so I'm figuring things out, but I can't imagine someone who isn't comfortable with this stuff having much fun doing the same<p>Yet another example of how Google's Market app is slowly catching up to iTunes. The new market app is a big improvement.<p>It seems like writing tablet apps for Honeycomb are more an exercise for developers and their teams (I see distinct rivalries between iOS and Android dev teams at the same company) at companies that have Android apps to pad their resume and "feel cool" (look at me, we have a tablet app) than a practical economic market. I know four people who own Honeycombs, all of them were purchased by their employers so their company could get the "Tablet" achievement. As for iPads, I was shocked the other day to see not just one but two iPads being used (the glow is mega massive from the screen) from my nosebleed level cheap seat before an orchestral concert started.
I set up some new PC laptops recently for a few non-technical friends. It's been a while since I've touched a new PC laptop so it was a bit of shock to be reminded of how much clunky, ugly, slow, proprietary junkware was larded on top of Windows. It's a bad soup cooked by too many chefs.<p>From what I've seen of recent Android UI's, vendors seem to be following the same MO, with the same poor, inconsistent results. If Google doesn't start pushing hard for stock Android on tablets they're going to lose this race.
Google need to take a page out of the video-game emulation world and introduce filters and anti-aliasing at higher magnifications.<p>For example you can play a Gameboy Advance game at native resolution (ie tiny!) on the emulator Visualboy Advance or scale the video output 2 or 3 times and after enabling all the above settings, the output is <i>much</i> nicer than the originals.<p>It doesn't take all that much processing power to do either (the difference in power between phones and tablets more than makes up for it - many times over I suspect)<p>Anyone care to chime in? (and possibly destroy my argument)
I have played with my friends iPad 2's and just got the Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1. I think it's fine and now I prefer it over the iPad.<p>It's so much lighter which means I can be "that guy" who takes movies and pictures with it. It uploads to Google+ automatically and then I can choose to share or not. One of the big barriers to me sharing meda with friends is my laziness in taking the time to upload each file. This takes one step out of that process: I just leave a note and choose to share it or not.<p>The 16:9 form factor can be awkward for reading eBooks. I actually prefer that form factor overall because when I type in portrait mode I don't have to move my thumbs as far to type letters.<p>As for the apps one thing that I found is that due to the way Android apps manage layout instead of doing a simple pixel multiplication the applications scale fairly well. While there aren't a lot of pretty tablet-specific apps in the Android Marketplace at leas the apps are usable on the full-screen. I really appreciate the information density as opposed to running in an a small emulator.
I'm not sure why everyone keeps saying that Honeycomb tablets aren't there yet. Where are they supposed to be? I've owned a Xoom WiFi for a while now and it has quickly replaced my laptop as my "just surfing the net" tool. I still switch to type out e-mails, but my Xoom is always what I reach for when I'm sitting on the sofa and want to google something real quick.
Are apps really that important? I figure main use would be web browsing. I hardly ever use apps on my Android phone, except for the built in ones (maps, contacts).<p>I even consider to go web only on my future tablet to avoid privacy issues with apps.