TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Should I accept the free Windows 11 upgrade?

36 pointsby dzdtover 3 years ago
I have two machines at home on Windows 10: a gaming desktop on Windows 10 Pro and a laptop on Windows 10 home. Should I accept the offered windows 11 upgrade?<p>It sounds like there is no going back after a 10 day grace period.<p>What are the pros and cons? Are there any use cases where either the pros or cons are big?

34 comments

dudeinhawaiiover 3 years ago
The good, the interface is cleaner in many areas including the settings, snip, and other built-in apps. Start menu is fine, better support for features that have been around forever (multiple desktops). Better support for WSL2. Better looking Explorer with more sensible menu options. Appears to have 100% compatibility with previous Windows versions. Better tiled window support with numerous snapping options, no need for third party tools for that (great on very large screens).<p>The bad, power users thrown to the side in favor of reducing clutter in some areas. In particular, the Explorer right-click menu has been gutted. Now there&#x27;s an annoying &quot;show all options&quot; step to get to common actions you may have installed such as &quot;open in Notepad++&quot;. By default, the menu shows 5 options and a few context actions but is designed to avoid the massive (and perhaps confusing) menus users would have after installing 20+ apps. Perhaps this is &quot;mixed&quot; rather than bad but I find it annoying.<p>The ugly, there&#x27;s a small but noticeable latency in Explorer when navigating back and forth rapidly between drives&#x2F;directories. A search for &quot;windows 11 explorer slow&quot; shows a common theme. It&#x27;s not a constant, more like some sort of indexing hiccup that occurs from time to time when backing out of a folder or entering a new one.<p>That performance bug may be resolved in a bit, most bugs reported on the bug tracker have gotten surprisingly quick response rates. I reported a critical bug in the snip tool that was resolved in an emergency patch a week later.<p>There&#x27;s probably other &quot;good&quot; items but as a Windows 10 power user&#x2F;developer, this is what I noticed as part of the transition.
louskenover 3 years ago
No<p>- less customizability<p>- worse performance (animations with many windows) or boot times<p>- issues with SSDs, CPUs, network cards (already mostly ironed out but not fully)<p>- lots of random glitches and bugs (though january update for windows 10 and server isn&#x27;t much better)<p>- even worse interface, filled with ads and junk [0] [1]<p>- the top 10 requests are pretty much filled with bring X back from windows 10 [2]<p>[0] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;3D1deDXwWgQ" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;3D1deDXwWgQ</a> [1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;cRwdoo9kNTw" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;youtu.be&#x2F;cRwdoo9kNTw</a> [2] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.neowin.net&#x2F;news&#x2F;here-are-the-top-10-changes-that-windows-11-needs-according-to-the-public&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.neowin.net&#x2F;news&#x2F;here-are-the-top-10-changes-that...</a>
thomasdziedzicover 3 years ago
I don&#x27;t see any major pros or cons in upgrading to Windows 11 and I&#x27;m happy with Windows 10 Pro, so I&#x27;m going to hold off until I see something compelling or when October 14, 2025 is around the corner, when official support for Windows 10 is supposed to end.
评论 #29956855 未加载
sbarreover 3 years ago
I also have 2 Win 10 machines at home, and my current plan is to wait until at least the fall of 2022 before updating to Win 11, if not longer.<p>Maybe something will come along and change my mind, but at the moment I&#x27;ve seen no compelling reason to update, and I value stability over shiny latest.<p>The last major super annoying bug of Windows 10 (windows moving around on a multi-monitor setup when coming back from sleep or monitors off) was fixed with the 21H2 update, so I&#x27;m good.<p>Other than &quot;free offer&quot;, do you have a specific reason to want Windows 11?
评论 #29956584 未加载
cdriniover 3 years ago
I&#x27;m holding off for now mainly cause I keep my taskbar on the left side of the screen instead of the bottom, and that&#x27;s no longer possible in Windows 11. Not in the mood to change, and not in the mood to find a workaround. But I probably will eventually update.
评论 #29957137 未加载
评论 #29957119 未加载
评论 #29961228 未加载
评论 #29957893 未加载
评论 #29969842 未加载
mwattsunover 3 years ago
I&#x27;ve been on 11 now for a few months as part of the preview program. I&#x27;m happy with it. I like the Windows 11 interface because it&#x27;s cleaner and nicer looking. I built Serenity OS in WSL2 with Ubuntu installed yesterday and it launched in QEMU without problem. I have Windows 10 running in a VMWare VM if I need it for some reason.<p>That said, I can&#x27;t really think of a reason a 10 user would upgrade. It&#x27;s my impression that it&#x27;s primarily for new machines. On the other hand, Microsoft may starting building improvements to 11 that won&#x27;t make it to 10, which is why I upgraded.
Andrexover 3 years ago
I opted to upgrade to Fedora instead. Honestly.<p>I&#x27;ve been pretty happy. Whatever remaining faith I had in MS&#x27;s stewardship of Windows was lost with 11. Which is a shame, because over the years I generally preferred them to Apple - I still have my first-gen Zune.<p>But Windows 11, no thanks. I&#x27;m out.
satysinover 3 years ago
Unless you <i>need</i> something that is new in Windows 11 I don&#x27;t really see any point in upgrading while Windows 10 is still supported and so getting the same security updates.<p>There are too many downgrades in terms of UX in Windows 11 to upgrade just because it is new.
gandalfianover 3 years ago
I&#x27;d give it year and let the dust settle first.
dzdtover 3 years ago
Possible points I know of: the desktop has a little-used Bluray drive. There is discussion of Bluray functionality being removed.<p>Also I&#x27;ve tried etherium mining on the desktpp gpu, which uses memory parameter overrides and overclocking. I worry that support could change?<p>I do some development, CUDA, python, mingw64 C++ stack. Possible WSL. Does WSL change&#x2F;improve in Windows 11?
评论 #29958196 未加载
fuzzy2over 3 years ago
I personally do not like the new shell for a multitude of reasons. Taskbar feature restrictions (I use labels and no grouping), I don’t like the new start menu, I don’t like the new menu look, …. I’m sure there were other things I forgot again. I grew up using Windows 3.1+. Only these days it’s looking less and less like Windows. I dread the day I’ll have to upgrade my parents’ devices. They will not be able to adapt.<p>Still, there are reasons to upgrade: Stronger security (maybe), much-improved Settings app. Better WSL 2. Most new development will be for 11.<p>I’m working at a Microsoft dev shop, so I’ll be forced to use it sooner or later anyway.
评论 #29960810 未加载
snarfyover 3 years ago
It&#x27;s like going from Win7 to Win8. If you thought that was a good upgrade then you like Win11.
评论 #29959355 未加载
ru552over 3 years ago
The thing holding me back from the win11 upgrade is turning on my TPM. Not a fan.
评论 #29957139 未加载
评论 #29956749 未加载
Zachsa999over 3 years ago
I upgraded 3 days ago, no regrets.<p>Actually, I did a fresh install, and saved the iso on a bootable USB stick just in case it sucked and I had to downgrade.
评论 #29956581 未加载
Grismarover 3 years ago
On an individual level I just don&#x27;t see the point right now. It&#x27;s not that it&#x27;s particularly bad, it&#x27;s just that it doesn&#x27;t fix anything important about 10, and there is nothing I could do on 11 that 10 won&#x27;t let me. From a point of view of risk, changing is almost certainly worse, between fixing no major issues and introducing a lot of change all the same. From a group perspective, I imagine that slow adoption will put more pressure on Microsoft to fix what people are disliking about it, so politically I think not upgrading right now is better.<p>So that is a very mild &quot;probably not&quot; from me.
sdoeringover 3 years ago
I didn&#x27;t yet make the update and what I hear about it doesn&#x27;t inspire confidence. We have 5 machines at home running win10 smoothly. Three max. 2 year old midline laptops, one desktop upgraded three years ago in quite good hardware and my work horse as well. Two of the machines tell me they are not equipped with hardware that supports win11.<p>If MS believes I will replace totally fine hardware functioning and still really up to all I throw at it, because it wants me to update a OS they must be delusional. Why should I buy new stuff when all is good?<p>I am way past tbe &#x27;I need new shiny stuff each year&#x27;-phase of my life.<p>So as long as my employer doesn&#x27;t force me to switch I really would need to see good reasons to jump.
rPlayer6554over 3 years ago
The reason I won&#x27;t upgrade is there doesn&#x27;t seem to be much benefit. I don&#x27;t use the gaming stuff and while the UI seems nice, Windows 10 works fine as well. I&#x27;d also be forced into logging in with an MS account which I&#x27;m not hot on.
评论 #29957200 未加载
II2IIover 3 years ago
I tried Windows 11 on my Home based laptop about a month after release, bumped into a bunch of user interface glitches, and immediately reverted to Windows 10. The glitches were not show-stopping, but not confidence inspiring either. Given that I only boot into Windows for work, I have put the upgrade on indefinite hold.<p>My advice: if you aren&#x27;t doing anything critical, it&#x27;s probably fine to upgrade sooner rather than later. It sounds like there are a few benefits to Windows 11. If you are doing anything critical, give it a year for the bugs to be ironed out.
me_me_mu_muover 3 years ago
This is just my opinion on how I have my setup. I have a gaming windows machine that’s used for just gaming. I don’t do any personal work on it. It has a 2tb drive that has just games on it.<p>Microsoft can go ahead and ruin the OS for all I care, all I’m using it for is my entertainment. The moment it gets annoying I have no problem not gaming anymore if that’s what it comes to (already is considering I barely game anymore)
MattPalmer1086over 3 years ago
I used to upgrade to the latest versions of things as soon as possible. I was excited by new shiny things. I also got regularly burned by the new shiny things.<p>These days I stick with what works, and only upgrade when I know I have a need for it. Much more boring, but I don&#x27;t look to my OS for excitement.<p>So to me, the fact you&#x27;re asking the question tells me that you don&#x27;t really have a need.
Shadonototraover 3 years ago
No, stick to windows 10, windows11 doesn&#x27;t add anything new, doesn&#x27;t improve performance, adds more bloat to your base install<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.techspot.com&#x2F;article&#x2F;2349-windows-11-performance&#x2F;" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.techspot.com&#x2F;article&#x2F;2349-windows-11-performance...</a><p>Seriously, need random people to make choice for you?
senectus1over 3 years ago
It seems fine on my home desktop&#x2F;gaming machine.<p>its a fking nightmare on my work laptop. So buggy, needs to be rebooted daily. It really doesn&#x27;t like Sleep or having to change between multiple screen setups.<p>Patches for Win11 seem to be fairly slow in coming compared to Win10. but then it is early day I guess.
aero-glide2over 3 years ago
Seems snappier, no downsides so far.
thrower123over 3 years ago
I wouldn&#x27;t try it until there is an LTSC build.<p>That&#x27;s when you know a Windows release is actually done.
评论 #29963993 未加载
executiveover 3 years ago
had to downgrade, still many bugs with WSL.
评论 #29956821 未加载
评论 #29956634 未加载
dzdtover 3 years ago
Of I forgot my middle-schooler&#x27;s cheepo Win10 laptop. There there may also be questions of minimum specs. Does anything change with Microsoft family account features?
tinus_hnover 3 years ago
If you can spare the time it might be worth it to upgrade and then immediately downgrade, so there more of a chance you get the free upgrade when you want it.
alloaiover 3 years ago
Until now, I want to stuck with windows 1809 After trying 1903, 2004, and windows 11<p>Wanted to swtich to Ubuntu, but because I need to use VBA, so not an option
supportlocal4hover 3 years ago
I&#x27;ve never understood the mentality of staying on an old release of Windows. If you use Windows, you should stay current. If you are not willing to stay current, you should move to something else that is responsibly maintained. To stay still is to accept ever increasing vulnerability. That is bad for you and bad for everyone you touch (which probably means everyone, period).
评论 #29956729 未加载
评论 #29956746 未加载
评论 #29956766 未加载
评论 #29956830 未加载
评论 #29956757 未加载
评论 #29956731 未加载
评论 #29956676 未加载
评论 #29956877 未加载
评论 #29956705 未加载
评论 #30051037 未加载
评论 #29957637 未加载
Syonykover 3 years ago
I don&#x27;t intend to ever run Win11 on personal hardware, based on several of the changes they made - though I barely run Windows 10. I don&#x27;t believe any of my stuff &quot;fully supports&quot; Win11 anyway, despite being some reasonably recent CPUs (8000 series Intel and a little AMD NUC). Yes, I know about the USB install trick, no, I just don&#x27;t care.<p>The first major point of concern is the issue during late beta where the chunk of advertising JSON that was malformed took out Explorer entirely, rendering the system unusable. That speaks to how tightly Microsoft has integrated &quot;things I consider worthless crap&quot; (advertising) with the core OS. In my preferred model of computers, the OS is core, and nothing from the internet can render the core OS inoperative (short of actual OS updates being defective). Advertising updates <i>definitely</i> can&#x27;t render the OS entirely non-usable. They got it fixed before too long, but that tight integration between &quot;core OS&quot; and &quot;advertising delivery&quot; is exceedingly concerning.<p>Microsoft has also been steadily making &quot;offline accounts&quot; harder, and with Win11, has made offline accounts no longer an option for Win11 Home. You are now <i>required</i> to have an online Microsoft account in order to use your local computer (or pay up for the Pro version, because you&#x27;re not being as profitable on the backend). My read of this, given the advertising tie-in, is that Microsoft has decided that the &quot;behavioral surplus collection&quot; benefits from having what&#x27;s likely to be your common email tied to your account (and at least your IP address) exceed the small costs of annoying a few technical users - and are therefore almost certainly hoovering up more information about use than they were with Win10. Again, my model of computers is that the local login information, at least for personal computing, has no business being tied to whatever online accounts I care to use or not use, and my OS definitely shouldn&#x27;t be actively reporting up what I use or not (yes, I <i>know</i> Win10 and MacOS are both doing this in some form or another, and I&#x27;m moving away from both of them).<p>These two, combined, tell me that Win11 has diverged so far from what I consider an OS should be (serving me, not using my behavior as a raw material source for the OS company) that I&#x27;m just not willing to use it for personal use. I&#x27;ve been heading more completely down the Linux road lately, and will likely continue that, just because of how I think computers should function in relation to my goals.<p>This does mean there are probably certain things I won&#x27;t be able to do eventually in the context of gaming, though the Steam&#x2F;Linux&#x2F;Windows compatibility layers (Proton?) are getting better, from what I hear. But I&#x27;ve accepted that there will be things I can&#x27;t do with computers if I use computers in the way I think they should behave, and I&#x27;m OK with that.
DiabloD3over 3 years ago
A few notes:<p>Windows 11 is Windows 10 with exactly two changes; Windows 10 is not Windows 8 with several changes, but still in the same branch&#x2F;evolution in the same NT family.<p>The first change is: the Sun Valley theme update, which finally gives all the WinForms&#x2F;WPF&#x2F;UWP&#x2F;WinUI apps (&quot;Metro&quot; or &quot;Modern&quot; style) apps a real theme instead of bad full-white and full-black themes that destroy any sense of visual ergonomics Windows had. Microsoft was afraid people would be confused and need to be retrained in corporate environments (fun fact: this happened when Vista became 7), so they increased the major version.<p>The second change is: VBS (Virtualization Based Security) is now enabled by default and the installer won&#x27;t let you install without it working. This means UEFI must be enabled, legacy boot must be disabled, secureboot via TPM must be enabled, and due to the previous one, your TPM must be enabled and new enough, else you cannot use Windows 11 (unless you do an underdocumented hack to the installer; I did this on my Ivy Bridge laptop, I know what I&#x27;m doing and I accept the risk). All Skylake family CPUs and all Zen family CPUs have a firwmare TPM that meets requirements; first generation Skylake and Zen 1 have security vulnerabilities that blacklist them from default Windows 11 installations (or, roughly, to run Windows 11, you need a CPU made in the past ~5 years). Again, because hardware requirements changed (even though &quot;sold with Windows 10&quot; required such features exist in the first place), major version changed.<p>The second change is not a huge issue either, as all sold-with&#x2F;for-Windows-10 machines are required to have these features; the flaw is, many mobos default to being broke out of the box, as in, TPM is not enabled, secureboot isn&#x27;t turned on, and hypervisor CPU features are not enabled: these are technically defective mobos whose fix is to just turn the features on. Some mobos have gotten Windows 11 BIOS updates that just change their defaults and turn it on; 99.9% of users have no clue what I just wrote or what any of it means... and a BIOS update won&#x27;t fix this because they, again, have no clue what any of this means.<p>Now, one last thing, the semi-kicker: with the first change, they finally jettisoned the old taskbar: it predates the original Metro UI, and is very finnicky to work with as it has a lot of custom behavior. The new one is written entirely in normal XAML as a completely normal and conventional app.<p>Why is this a semi-kicker? If you use small taskbar and&#x2F;or task grouping disabled, as you&#x27;re a competent and knowledgeable Windows user, you need to use Explorer Patcher to re-enable both of those features. Microsoft is currently denying the lack of those features are a bug, and do not understand that their decision has already been vetoed by the community and some of their largest enterprise customers.<p>Their reasoning is that both Apple and Google poison kids in education environments by putting Macs and Chromebooks in school and making that their first exposure to computing, so instead of fighting this, they default to an identically functioning dock-esque giant centered task-grouping taskbar instead of, you know, the one you expect from a product named Windows.<p>So yeah, go accept the upgrade, then install Explorer Patcher to fix the backwards taskbar issues.
评论 #29956894 未加载
keskadaleover 3 years ago
switch to linux
评论 #29957238 未加载
analog31over 3 years ago
Out of curiosity, is it a new OS or a new shell?
fuzzfactorover 3 years ago
Most people are not using anywhere near the entire amount of drive space on their Windows 10 C: volume.<p>And it&#x27;s so easy to shrink the C: volume while you are booted to W10, leaving over 64GB of unallocated space to format so you can do an additional clean install of W11 to the previously unused drive space, after booting to the W11 USB install media, without disturbing W10 in any way.<p>The built-in Windows multi-boot menu accepts an additional entry for W11 alongside your present W10 boot entry, then the resulting dual boot menu will pop up every time you reboot so you have a choice of which partition to boot to, either W10 or W11. The most recently installed version of Windows will automatically become the default OS appearing on the bootmenu if you do not change which one you want to be default afterward.<p>Whichever partition you choose to boot to will be autoenumerated as your C: volume at the time, with remaining &quot;unhidden&quot; volumes occupying other alphabetical designations. i.e. when you boot to W11 it will be your C: volume and your W10 partition will not be C: again until you reboot to W10.<p>The built-in multiboot menu simply remains unseen when there is only a single boot entry, such as on a factory W10 PC.<p>cons: -you basically update each OS separately -you back up each system separately -unless you make the desired adjustment to the OS&#x27;s in a multiboot system, more than one correction for Daylight Savings Time may occur after that date arrives. Only the most frequently used OS should be the one to autoupdate the mainboard timeclock for DST<p>Alternatively, without using the conventional Setup.exe to install W11 from the USB install media, you can place the W11 virgin fileset onto a formatted partition from an administrative command prompt using DISM.exe.<p>i.e. in W10 after shrinking C: and formatting the unused space as new NTFS volume &quot;T:&quot;, you plug in the W11 setup USB stick, cancel the setup&#x2F;upgrade option then use W10 CMD line to access the files on the USB volume and bring in the W11 fileset to your target partition.<p>Assuming your W11 USB drive is &quot;U:&quot; and your target NTFS volume is &quot;T:&quot;, first use DISM to find out which versions of Windows 11 are available within the install.wim file:<p>DISM.exe &#x2F;get-imageinfo u:\sources\install.wim<p>Most of the time the &quot;pro&quot; version of Windows will be the sixth choice, which is identified as Index 6.<p>Apply W11 pro fileset to target volume &quot;T:&quot;:<p>DISM.exe &#x2F;apply-image u:\sources\install.wim index:6 &#x2F;applydir:t:\<p>-w11 can actually be applied to volumes smaller than 64GB this way also<p>Without employing the consumer W11 Setup.exe routine, you would then need to manually add a W11 bootentry (pointing to your new Windows 11 fileset) into the existing (hidden) EFI folder that you have been using for W10 booting all along:<p>bcdboot t:\windows<p>This manual deployment approach can also be accomplished similarly from the CMD prompt when booted to the W11 install media itself, which can be helpful when your target partition is not empty, as <i>Trusted Installer</i> you will have fewer permission problems than a W10 Administrator.