TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Engineering Manager to IC Role

3 pointsby Gigacoreover 3 years ago
I am an engineering manager, but a new assignment requires me to wear the IC hat. I do code pretty much every day. Nowadays I spend about 20% of my time writing code. I have begun to enjoy the high-level aspects more as I have spent quite some time in this role.<p>I wanted to understand from other engineering managers on this. So here are a few questions:<p>Have you ever worked as an IC being an engineering manager, especially after spending a few years in the managerial role? If yes, how hard was it to transition?<p>Did you enjoy going back to writing code on daily basis?<p>Or did you feel IC is not your forte anymore?<p>Did it concern you about the growth?

2 comments

stocktechover 3 years ago
I&#x27;ll add here, even if it&#x27;s not really what you&#x27;re looking for. I&#x27;m a director, not at faang, fwiw.<p>My first 2 years of managing was hands on, probably 50% coding. I had a small scope and the energy to do people things while also doing coding things. What I found was that this doesn&#x27;t scale and that if I ever wanted to lead larger initiatives and have a bigger impact, I&#x27;d need to give up coding. During this period, I burnt out trying to grow both technically and managerially. The context switching required of me was too much.<p>When I got to a position where I could do people management 100% of the time, it was transformative. In the same way we think about coding - what skills do I need to develop, how can I optimize XYZ, is there a better pattern for this, etc - I now started to think about management. Part of this is that I joined an org that truly valued management and was able to be mentored and allowed to develop my skills.<p>Now as a director, I insist that my new managers don&#x27;t code. There is a period of time where you need to focus on management and nothing else. Later on, I don&#x27;t care if you want to get into the code, but at that point, no one chooses to.<p>It does seem like the industry is split on where a manager title exists and if you&#x27;re hands on. Regardless of which way you go, you&#x27;ll find career growth imo. I would consider if you feel like you&#x27;re being the best manager you can be though.
eatonphilover 3 years ago
I have seen a number of managers go back to being an IC at an equivalent title.<p>I think it&#x27;s pretty common. And not particularly penalized.<p>I was a manager for 5 years and am now building my own company. I do way more coding than as a manager but I also do everything else.<p>If I were to go back to full time employment I think it would be easy to go back as an IC or as a manager depending on what I wanted and how I spin my time.<p>Basically, you always have a story and always have control of how you tell it. So as long as you&#x27;re average or above average as an employee you&#x27;ll always have options.