TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Am I being too ambitious?

11 pointsby samh748about 3 years ago
Hey HN!<p>Before I get into it, I just want to thank you all for the overwhelming responses I&#x27;ve received on my recent Ask HN (the one about my interest in many disciplines [0], I bring this up because it&#x27;s all kinda related).<p>Sorry that this post is going to be long, because it&#x27;s, well, ambitious. More ambitious than anything I&#x27;ve done with my life.<p>In short, I&#x27;m working on something that involves writing a series of long-form critical essays to be published on a website of my own. It&#x27;s going to be a long process, so I&#x27;m hoping to get some feedback on the feasibility of it all.<p>I&#x27;ve been trying to keep this a secret for fear of judgement and of &quot;leaking my ideas&quot;, but I&#x27;m starting to think that keeping it so private may be doing more harm than good.<p>I&#x27;m sharing all this here now because I trust HN to give a diverse set of honest and critical feedback, which I really need. I also feel that HN is going to be the audience that will understand my overarching theses the most. I know there will be some people here that will disagree with my points, but that&#x27;s part of the process and I&#x27;m prepared for that.<p>Anyway, there&#x27;s a lot to unpack. I&#x27;ll start with my backstory, as for me there really was a interesting narrative that led up to all this.<p>... (due to character limits, I&#x27;ll have to continue in the comments: https:&#x2F;&#x2F;news.ycombinator.com&#x2F;item?id=30976499 ) ...

6 comments

adg001about 3 years ago
Sam,<p>1&#x2F; &#x27;All happy families are alike; each unhappy family is unhappy in its own way.&#x27; - Which is to say that we all have faced, at some point in time, significant challenges... (I will refrain to tell you about my own ones). Having read your three part Ask HN, the first thing I want to tell you is &#x27;please go straight to the point when posting here, or only a few folks will give proper consideration to what you write;<p>2&#x2F; Secondly, think strategically. You have the ambition to write a long form essay about self-help, psychology, sociology, and semiotics. This is excellent! At the same time though be sure to first position yourself as somebody that is not only knowledgeable – I am sure you are – but also recognised as being as such, and, therefore, authoritative and well known enough to publish in that field. Or, getting published will turn to be very hard, and, in the event you get your work out there, only a limited a few will pay attention, again;<p>3&#x2F; I am not knowledgeable enough to tell you if the proposed structuring makes sense. If it does for you, fine! However dozen of books get published in the more general self-help section every year. Be sure to contrast your proposed structure to what already exists, and to make it digestible by your target audience. Not many people are well versed in multiple discipline, be sure to guide your target audience gently in your interdisciplinary analyses.<p>Much love, alfonso
评论 #30981785 未加载
crowdyriverabout 3 years ago
Hello Sam,<p>I don&#x27;t know if you&#x27;ve heard about this youtube channel, actualized. I&#x27;m not sure if I should recommend it to you, because, well, it takes extreme an extreme openmind to see his videos, but I&#x27;m sure you could confirm plenty of ideas you&#x27;ve contemplated in your life from him.<p>Following actualized advice changed my mind and my whole worldview, I&#x27;m sure it could help you as well. I strongly recommend his series on ego development:<p>part 1: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=J3hNosyyXRA" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=J3hNosyyXRA</a><p>part 2: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=G8fIhLDV3L4" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=G8fIhLDV3L4</a><p>part 3: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=pGItuEai8vo" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=pGItuEai8vo</a><p>From what you&#x27;ve wrote you seem to be in an advanced stage, but again, I&#x27;m no expert to judge.<p>Maybe you already know Leo Gura&#x27;s work! In that sense, I have nothing to share with you, but if you don&#x27;t, god I cannot recommend you his channel enough. Just these 3 videos I linked to can reinforce or even expand your worldview so much.
评论 #30989193 未加载
评论 #31055221 未加载
TigeriusKirkabout 3 years ago
I think you should pursue this. Primarily because it will force you to structure your ideas and that will benefit you personally.<p>I don&#x27;t think you should pay much attention to any feedback you get here as this isn&#x27;t really the right forum for meaningful discussion of such topics.<p>Yes, this is an incredibly ambitious path to set off on. Yes, the likely outcome is that your book will simply be ignored. That&#x27;s the most likely outcome for any book, and moreso for books on deep, serious topics.<p>So be sure you&#x27;re ready for that, and do it anyway.
评论 #30981815 未加载
yuppie_scumabout 3 years ago
This feels like a clickbait post (exploit the “curiosity gap” to make people click and read quasi-related content)
评论 #30981731 未加载
ksajabout 3 years ago
I&#x27;m sure you&#x27;ve come across the word &#x27;hypergraphia&#x27; at some point in your life. This Ask HN was a long essay in and of itself.<p>It feels like this wasn&#x27;t really asking anything, but instead was all about telling HN about your life story, disguised as a question.
评论 #30977043 未加载
samh748about 3 years ago
Several years ago I dreamt of becoming a university professor. I was young and naive and got a lot of ego-boost from my peers and professors who really praised me for how smart I was. I did some research projects during my undergrad (I studied Ecology &amp; Evolutionary Biology), then went immediately into a PhD following graduation. At that point, my own idealistic expectations of myself (and of academia), combined with conflict with my parents and other personal life chaos, all slammed in my face as I tried to navigate grad school. I got depressed (though I didn&#x27;t recognize it at the time), got nothing achieved, and eventually dropped out.<p>My life and my dreams all crashed before me, I became very distant from my parents, and I spent the next several years numbed out, trying to figure out what the hell to do with my life now.<p>Fortunately, it was during this next phase of my life, after the fire had burnt through everything, that I went through some incredible personal growth and transformation, alongside with my partner. I learned how to navigate relationships, I learned about differences and about universals. I learned how to love. I learned how to accept and embrace change. I revisited my past traumas and started to heal. Life became less chaotic and I could finally breathe a little and at least live a low-lying life.<p>Then roughly two years ago, due to some pretty big changes in lifestyle (moving, went back to do some school) and all the expectations that came with it, I went into my second depressive episode. This time around, even though the experience itself was darker and more tormenting, I was more aware of what&#x27;s happening in my mind. I could hear all the voices in my head, I could describe my pain, and so I wrote about them and shared it with my few friends on social media. There wasn&#x27;t much response, but something inside me started to change. By writing down my most vulnerable thoughts and feelings and trying to communicate them to others, it helped me to make sense of these experiences. The more I wrote, the more clarity I found. I started to really see and feel my traumas and pains, and after some gut-wrenching catharsis, my depression lifted.<p>What was even more incredible though, was how these experiences would then drastically transform my view of the world. As the fog in my mind cleared, I started to pay more attention to the world around me, more so than I ever have. I&#x27;ve always <i>known</i> about social issues, but nothing ever really clicked, and so I never really <i>cared</i>.<p>As I paid more attention, I started to see the problems of our world more clearly. After nearly 30 years of life, I finally looked outside my own little bubble. Everything started to matter now, and I felt <i>so alive</i>. I started thinking seriously about various topics, started asking questions, and started writing privately about all of them. I became genuinely interested in one discipline after another, slowly expanding my realm and my worldview, trying to make sense of the more fundamental questions and ideas that stretched across disciplines.<p>Slowly, as I learned more about the world and looked back on my life, I began to realize that everything that had happened in my life, from my idealistic career fantasies, to the conflicts in my relationships, to the trauma and the depression and all the growth that followed, can be explained and understood in one way or another. But as I looked out at the world, I began to notice, literally <i>everywhere</i>, that people are stuck in problems and debates because of some very fundamental misunderstandings about how things work. I started to realize that, nearly all of us have been binded to and blinded by our cultural assumptions of everything, from careers to relationships, to society, to science itself. And if the problems of our world and in our personal lives can be better understood, they can also be prevented or improved upon, if only we weren&#x27;t so complacent about it all.
评论 #30976504 未加载