TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Going Critical (2019)

63 pointsby rankoalmost 3 years ago

4 comments

creakingstairsalmost 3 years ago
This is a great interactive essay. I found the part about diffusion in cities particularly interesting.<p>I’ve been discussing with a friend on what makes big cities worth living in and one of the point raised was that just by putting a lot of people in a small space, you get much more innovation than spreading out the same amount of people in a wider area.<p>This is one of the reasons why Edward Glaeser dubs city as “the man&#x27;s greatest invention“ in his book. He brings up the rate of new patents to back up the above claim but the blog post offers another mathematical reason.
评论 #31891815 未加载
评论 #31892711 未加载
评论 #31892029 未加载
photochemsynalmost 3 years ago
Great article and the interactive graphs work well to explain concepts.<p>I can think of a few extensions: make it more realistic with a global map of fiber-optic cable networks and local extensions, and then compare how information spreads through things like peer-to-peer sharing vs. information posted to &#x27;central authorities&#x27; like Twitter. (Notably there was also that study that showed false information spread faster across Twitter than accurate information, attributed to the &#x27;surprise factor&#x27;). This could also be modified to include the authoritarian filter effect (i.e. how does China&#x27;s &#x27;Great Firewall&#x27; affect the spread of information, for example).<p>With respect to this simple nearest-neighbor model, I suppose a complicating factor would be long-distant transport from a given node to a distant node by some out-of-plane connection method (i.e. Covid spread rapidly by airplane, for example).<p>The article really shows that graph-based network thinking is a great way of approaching these problems, nice work.
DriftRegionalmost 3 years ago
<i>when careerists take up space in a Real Science research community, they gum up the works. They angle to promote themselves while the rest of the community is trying to learn and share what&#x27;s true. Instead of striving for clarity, they complicate and obfuscate in order to sound more impressive.</i><p>Great essay. The simulations sure make this point hit hard. I feel the author&#x27;s jadedness coming out here.<p>Should one feel like a small colored dot encircled by immune grey, it is essential to maintain a belief in agency: believing oneself capable of networking, relocating, and modifying the surroundings.
thereinalmost 3 years ago
I have been looking for this with my friend for the last 6 months. I saw it on HN about two years ago and have shown it to him. Neither of us were able to find it again, especially since we thought the title was `Going Viral`, which made it especially hard to find given the COVID&#x27;s pollution of the search keyword space.