TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: What will everyone do if everything is automated?

23 pointsby typestover 2 years ago
This is a question that I feel comes up a lot, and it&#x27;s not often engaged with seriously. I feel sci-fi doesn&#x27;t really engage with the concept (you&#x27;ll get super smart AI, but somehow humans still just have plenty of jobs). Technologists frequently respond that we are very far away from being able to automate all jobs, but this assumption ignores the possibility that we do automate everything -- and also, AI continues to advance faster than even AI researchers predict.<p>In the past I used to think that with all jobs automated, we would just all devote ourselves to higher pursuits like art, science, math, etc. However, now I think this claim didn&#x27;t give AI enough credibility -- it&#x27;s totally within the realm of possibility, and even near future possibility, that AI easily exceeds human performance in art, science, math -- all the things we generally think of as uniquely human and morally valuable pursuits. Recent LLM progress should make this point very clear to everyone.<p>So. Since I don&#x27;t see this idea being taken too seriously in society, I thought we on HN could take a stab at thinking through the possibility.<p>For example, here is one possible outcome I can envision. Pre agricultural revolution, all humans were hunter gatherers who simply did not have to work that hard (I think estimates I&#x27;ve read said that people spent maybe 15 hours a week hunting&#x2F;gathering). In this time, as far as I understand, people&#x27;s lives largely revolved around things like their local community, relationship with others, culture, and leisure (I am not an anthropologist or historian, so I may be totally correct here). Is it possible our lives become more like this? Without jobs to do, without the ability to, say, make meaningful advances to science, with governmental decision making being better handled by AI...do we spend our time building and forming meaningful relationships and communities with others?<p>Would love your thoughts.

29 comments

escapedmooseover 2 years ago
I don’t make art to make “high-performance” art. I make it because I enjoy the process and it makes me feel connected to the world around me in a way nothing else does. I don’t appreciate art because it’s “good” either. I like art that makes me feel something from another human.<p>If I didn’t have to work, I would spend my days drawing, reading, gardening, hiking, camping, meeting friends, eating and cleaning. A little bit of time creating things and a lot of time admiring the creations of others and of nature. A life centered around making and discovering beauty in the world… it sounds like a dream!<p>I would also love to see more of my friends’ children and have a more active hand in helping to raise them.<p>If many other people spent their time similarly, the world would be very fun imo
stev-0over 2 years ago
There is no “everything is automated”.<p>“Everything is automated” is similar to “finished software”. It just doesn’t happen.<p>Besides that there are many services you want to purchase where interaction with the other is part of the value of said service.<p>Think of going to a barber or a nice restaurant. Think about education, designers. There is also artisanal products. People pay a pretty penny for a teapot made by a master ceramist even though perfect products are made in much more automated ways.<p>I’m pretty hopeful about people having to work less. Maybe even about most people not having to work at all. But being able to afford luxuries like having a master chef cook your dinner from time to time is likely to require you do to some paid work and I think there will be plenty of work left for us humans.
评论 #34097076 未加载
hacooover 2 years ago
If we are headed towards a post-labor society (which I doubt, but that’s a different topic), the first thing we need to do is radically reconsider how our society thinks about property and wealth. Otherwise, we’ll have a small class of property holding aristocrats and everyone else is screwed.
评论 #34097070 未加载
评论 #34098603 未加载
fabbariover 2 years ago
I always tell people - when talking about unemployment rate - that our target rate should be 100%. Many of the things I do for work I would happily do for free - and sometimes do.<p>Labor as a choice is a great outcome. You&#x27;re not a woodworker because someone needs to be - but because you love it. So: if there is no work to do, it doesn&#x27;t mean that work wouldn&#x27;t be done, it just changes the motivation to do it.
评论 #34100523 未加载
SquibblesReduxover 2 years ago
I suspect that the majority of people would begin to act like teenagers. It seems like a world where everything is automated would remove many of the consequences we have now. I see a strong likelihood that human conflict would significantly increase.
solarmistover 2 years ago
Completely ignoring all the other thoughts and comments. And working from first principles.<p>The human brain is a problem-solving machine; one that is somewhat optimized for connecting with other people (I say somewhat because the social parts are still a very new addition).<p>If AI could do all labor and creative activities at levels far beyond human levels, then we&#x27;d still do many of them to try and understand how they do it. We&#x27;d also invent new problems to solve and new ways of interacting with labor and creativity.<p>It&#x27;s like asking what rich people do all day. They find stuff to do or make it up. Sometimes that&#x27;s productive, and sometimes it&#x27;s destructive. Or another similar thing would be the pursuits of landed gentlemen in the 1700 and 1800s, which invented many of the fields we call science.
poulpy123over 2 years ago
Looking at the current trend, there will be 3 classes: the elites, owners of the automates, the domestics, with a status somewhere between servants, slave and pets, and the useless, the masses.
mFixmanover 2 years ago
We&#x27;ve had automatic coffee machines since the 1950s, and yet Starbucks employs over 300k people.<p>Everything being possibly automated doesn&#x27;t mean everything will be automated. There is always value in human work, even if we are objectively worse at working than robots and AI.
评论 #34129533 未加载
timonokoover 2 years ago
First to go are administrative jobs, because human organizations are tiny monkey societies and humans cannot operate for the benefit of the billions.<p>The AI administration perceives that human life is just a memory, bad memories can be eradicated and better ones injected. So humans can be utilized where machines may fail. Machines have deeper level of consciousness, higher logic, higher &quot;morals&quot; and they cannot be easily fooled.<p>Most humans are just stored somewhere, not to dream, just to be with they injected life. Eventually AI recognizes the futility and waste of these storage units and stops maintaining them.<p>In short:<p><pre><code> Matrix will not happen.</code></pre>
johngaltover 2 years ago
Until we have AGI, I expect automation to be similar to the past. Where productivity increases along with material wealth and standard of living. After AGI, &quot;what jobs will people do?&quot; is probably the most uninteresting part.
评论 #34098437 未加载
muzaniover 2 years ago
Automation is nothing new. By contrast, full time jobs are a new thing. Not having to spend most of your day getting food, water, and heating is new. We just have other ambitions besides feeding ourselves and keeping warm. That&#x27;s where you end up working 15 hours&#x2F;day.<p>AI won&#x27;t change lifestyle much more than the other things do.<p>If you&#x27;re not already forming meaningful relationships and communities, you won&#x27;t when more things are automated. That&#x27;s where the dystopia is: everyone is chatting with real friends constantly, and yet more lonely than ever.
PartiallyTypedover 2 years ago
No human can ever stand up to stockfish, and yet people like Magnus still play the game, and this has been one of the best years in chess.<p>There’s already so many things to learn and understand that even if I could devote my life to learning, it won’t be enough. Heck, even if we solved all the big problems in math, a couple of lifetimes would still not be enough to understand them, and that’s just one field.<p>I can order takeout, but I prefer to cook in because I enjoy the process.<p>We have experiences to live through, people to share them with, and feelings to feel.
regularjackover 2 years ago
Just because an AI can make music, doesn&#x27;t mean it can make the music <i>you</i> would make.<p>Even if it could, if your motivation is genuine, i.e. you&#x27;re not making music for profit but because you enjoy the process, then it doesn&#x27;t matter anyway if an AI can or cannot do it.
devlifeover 2 years ago
I think people will work longer hours. This story has been played before.
giantg2over 2 years ago
&quot;What will everyone do if everything is automated?&quot;<p>It seems the dream is to become an influencer. People want to &quot;be&quot; some person, not an AI. So that seems pretty safe for now.
pharmakomover 2 years ago
There’s a great novel called Mockingbird. The humans mostly consume content and study music appreciation and so on. Everyone lives on daily tokens like a UBI.
rockzomover 2 years ago
This: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.amazon.com&#x2F;dp&#x2F;B09MQM7QPF" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.amazon.com&#x2F;dp&#x2F;B09MQM7QPF</a>
soueulsover 2 years ago
I think I would cook, go for some long walk, read&#x2F;watch a lot of classics.<p>Probably still code a bit.<p>But overall I think I would dislike my life.<p>I enjoy competition.
gus_massaover 2 years ago
Including military? Just hide inside the underground bunkers like in Terminator.
评论 #34098001 未加载
DantesKiteover 2 years ago
Probably play games, eat good food, and learn cool new things.
readonthegoappover 2 years ago
without organizing, the vast majority of us will be doomed.<p>i figure a couple of clues as to where we&#x27;re headed...<p>1) the black population in america. largely discarded, warehoused in prisons and and kept in poor, hopeless neighborhoods. add in large populations of poor white people in vast swaths of rural land areas.<p>and, possibly in a much more extreme situation,<p>2) palestinians in the west bank, and particularly gaza. gaza has been described as the world&#x27;s largest open-air prison, with good reason. at the current rate, they&#x27;re doomed, too.<p>both situations are just US policy - they&#x27;re not magic, or what other people or governments choose to do.<p>what do all these people do in their current circumstances? try to survive. try to maintain some semblence of dignity. try to hold onto their humanity and that of the people doing this to them.<p>so, our current neoliberalism craze is stratifying the US population by income even more, creating more and more extraneous&#x2F;disposable populations.<p>automation might be exacerbating our move towards faciscm and domination and extraneous populations, but it&#x27;s only that -- just helping, not a primary driver, imo.<p><pre><code> - 4-day work week could help. - things like GBI could help. - billionaires and rich people paying taxes could help. - organizing obviously could help. - technology sanity (ludditism) could help. - a less insane intellectual culture could help. - more democracy could help. </code></pre> my take on automation is that there are shocks to the system, but over the long haul, there is plenty of work to do, but without popular organizing, most of us are doomed.
ilakshover 2 years ago
People forget that humans are primates. Hierarchy and status are built-in (sub-conscious) concerns. There will be things like jobs and companies and co-ops and socialist committees, but many of them will involve humans leveraging AIs that they control. Or they will involve integrating AI and or robots with brain computer interfaces.<p>You status may depend largely on your ability to leverage AI and robotics.
nam17887over 2 years ago
Automate things?
adversaryIdiotover 2 years ago
get a chance to enjoy life not burdened by capitalistic chains hopefully.
评论 #34097121 未加载
jmakovover 2 years ago
Debug
deafpolygonover 2 years ago
Matrix
johlitsover 2 years ago
Innovate.
a_mechanicover 2 years ago
maintenance
verdentiover 2 years ago
You can always find something to do. Read, travel, cook, socialize, build things etc. none of this has to be monetized so even if everything in the world is automated, the fun is in the process.