TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Would the internet be better if domain squatting was made illegal?

2 pointsby iosystemover 2 years ago
Seems like all domains that are either short or catchy are taken and nothing exists if I go to them. I'm curious what you all think. Should a policy be made to stop the bad behaviour? Would it make the internet better or would things stay the same? Sure, someone can always make a long domain name or use .whatever but it seems like the popular websites rarely ever follow that example.

4 comments

aurizonover 2 years ago
Think like a herder, you have 10,000 cows = feed&#x2F;milk&#x2F;clean = time and $$, now you have a game with 10,000 virtual cows and each cow costs $2-3&#x2F;year to pasture. So you want to sell one a year = sale price of $30K to break even. Ask the cowherd about the next cow = also $30K. To change this you have to change the basis of the game. What if it cost $500 for each virtual cow&#x2F;year for virtual vet fees. So hos 10,000 cows now cost $500 each. I know we speak of cows, but we have now tossed a cat among his chickens = a huge ruckus will occur. His former model is broken, with annual vet bills for his 10,000 coes of $500 each = $5 million a year in vet fees. So this is the squatter game, it has been made dirt cheap to lock up domains for small annual fees. The way to change it is to make domains &#x27;eat&#x27; Same thing in houses as rates went up, people who bought for 5% down with 1.5% corporate $$ and now stuck with 5-6% money = their morgtages are eating them alive.<p>Will changes occure? I hope so. The current squatterverse rewards the worst of people.
评论 #34407430 未加载
akerl_over 2 years ago
How do you identify who is squatting and who isn&#x27;t?
评论 #34407390 未加载
评论 #34407410 未加载
logicalmonsterover 2 years ago
IMO, this opens up a real bad can of worms regarding property rights where rich&#x2F;powerful organizations are going to be able to bully individuals much easier to seize domains they want.<p>Imagine you have some snazzy domain for a project, but all of a sudden Coca-Cola or McDonald&#x27;s marketing team wants to use it for some Super Bowl promotion next year. If they apply their full weight and pressure on both the &quot;independent governing board&quot; that determines disputes, as well as on you (&quot;Better accept this one-time offer of $500 for your domain now or who knows what the board will decide?&quot;), essentially you&#x27;ve really disadvantaged individuals.
navjack27over 2 years ago
No that won&#x27;t do anything for the Internet at large