TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Unconditional Love

44 pointsby memorableover 2 years ago

21 comments

RajT88over 2 years ago
As explained by therapists, unconditional love is not love which is eternal and unchanging. Mulling over the implications of a brain transplant is missing the point.<p>&quot;I love you as long as you are rich&quot; is an example of conditional love. It is abusive at worst or shallow at best.<p>Unconditional love does not mean a promise to love someone forever. That might be impossible: people change over time. It is a statement of &quot;I love you now, as you are, as a person and not anything you do or have or appear to be&quot;.
评论 #34565673 未加载
评论 #34565061 未加载
评论 #34565502 未加载
Nomentatusover 2 years ago
These days the topic falls under &quot;Secure attachment&quot; as part of &quot;Attachment theory.&quot; The phrase &quot;unconditional love&quot; proved thorny and IMHO ill-judged, misleading.<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.verywellmind.com&#x2F;what-is-attachment-theory-2795337" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.verywellmind.com&#x2F;what-is-attachment-theory-27953...</a><p>My experience raising children is that you&#x27;re golden if the child knows you&#x27;re on their side, putting their interests above your own. Helping them learn, not putting any moral puzzles in front of them that they can&#x27;t easily solve, together with lots of misbehavior play so they can learn boundaries without actually misbehaving.<p>&quot;Unconditional love&quot; was just bad philosophy.
评论 #34566124 未加载
kil0khanover 2 years ago
OP should read The Four Loves by CS Lewis. Unconditional love seems irrational if love is mainly a kind of feeling, but that&#x27;s not the highest kind of love.
评论 #34565296 未加载
评论 #34565206 未加载
niruiover 2 years ago
&gt; you can&#x27;t expect to feel the same about someone no matter what because if that person you once had is gone, what is left to love? it is merely your imagination, your memory. it simply turns to grief.<p>You can still love the good moments, the good memories and all the happiness comes with it.<p>One of the thing that I grown to accept very early in my life, is the fact people change, so as their promises. Love is not a contract, it&#x27;s more of an emotional statement, a statement which only applies to a specific context (sometime very narrow).<p>If love needs to be dissolved, make sure to do that in a fair manner so nobody gets hurt (at least not too badly), so the good moments in the past will always be good moments instead of painful memories.
supriyo-biswasover 2 years ago
The author misses the point - what people typically mean by &quot;unconditional love&quot; is that their love remains more or less the same even when some qualities about the person change, such as said person becoming handicapped due to an accident, losing their &quot;status&quot; due to unemployment or financial losses, and so on.
评论 #34565256 未加载
roxgibover 2 years ago
This seems to imply that &#x27;loving&#x27; someone means continuing to treat them in a particular way or taking everything they do in stride. A person might love their partner, but still decide that they need to break up with them for one reason or another. You might say that they didn&#x27;t really love them, but does love have to be overpowering?
评论 #34565204 未加载
m463over 2 years ago
People can have unconditional love and be healthy.<p>However you need to have a proper mindset to do it well.<p>You might want to look at codependence. This can happen in any relationship. It can happen with a partner, but it also frequently happens with a child.<p>Codependence is when people accept too much responsibility for someone and things can quickly go south. (really too much to get into here)<p>The way out of this is to understand that everyone is responsible for him or her self. Obviously not infants, but remember the airline &quot;oxygen mask over your face before you help someone else&quot;.<p>The answer is to have a healthy neutrality.
bugbuddyover 2 years ago
I think Wittgenstein would say that the question of whether unconditional love is possible is a semantic game.<p>The critics would see from the perspective of “absolutely unconditional love” where the absolute aspect of this idea will provide the source of all the counter examples.<p>For this next part of the discussion, love is defined as to give or the act of giving attention, care, protection, and other benefits for something deemed worthy of loving or love. Yes, this is a recursive&#x2F;self-referential definition. Deal with it. The proponents will be those who intuitively understand the need for a phrase to describe a feeling of depersonalization or a loss of one’s sense of strict individuality when one’s sense of self begins to merge with the subject of love. In a sense, it is like a self-love but where the self has now expanded to encapsulate another individual. It is self-evident that self-love is unconditional because we have to assume a non-pathological case. Self-preservation which is a form of self-love is in all living organism. The unconditional here is used as an emphasis for the strength of the love. An example of unconditional love is a parent being willing to give their life to save their child. Will all parents have unconditional love for their children? No and no one has ever claimed that. Only the Sith said parent-child love is unconditional because he is unable to equivocate and use a qualifier.<p>In this way both groups are using the same term to talk pass each other about different things. This is actually quite a boring discussion.
dcowover 2 years ago
What is this “aesthetic” where you don’t capitalize sentences but still follow every other grammar rule?
评论 #34566204 未加载
评论 #34565739 未加载
评论 #34565008 未加载
评论 #34565024 未加载
thomover 2 years ago
As the incomparable Elizabeth Fraser once told us:<p><pre><code> Love… love is a verb Love is a doing word </code></pre> Unconditional love isn’t a promise to love someone forever (although that’s somewhat baked into the deal when you have kids). It’s a promise to show love without demanding anything back from someone. It’s not a feeling it’s an act.
dheeraover 2 years ago
Esther Perel has spoken and written about unconditional love.<p>I think the gist of it is being wanted is romantic, being needed is not romantic at all. Being wanted is actually very much conditional.<p>Unconditional love is more like parent-child love, you didn&#x27;t choose the person, it&#x27;s not a romantic process.
评论 #34565885 未加载
xivzgrevover 2 years ago
To me there’s 3 kinds of love -conditional love: give only what you get -masochist love: give no matter what, even if you are abused -unconditional love: give freely, trust in the relationship. But maintain your boundaries - separate when you need to, temporarily or permanently.<p>The author mixes up the latter two. Unconditional means no conditions before you try to love the person. It means focusing on how things are going overall vs any individual day or moment. It doesn’t mean to keep loving them if they don’t return it.
评论 #34566091 未加载
ccrushover 2 years ago
I have uncoditional love for the woman that bore my son, and it&#x27;s not by choice, and it hurts so much you wouldn&#x27;t believe. My life is a mess. She lied about my son and said he wasnt mine for years and she knew he was. She became a heroin addict with one of my friends. She got back together with me and i got addicted trying to get her clean.
评论 #34566299 未加载
Out_of_Characteover 2 years ago
I think unconditional love is a misnomer. You can love someone but its in your and their best interest to leave if your relationship is destructive. What most people truly desire is to be loved unconditionally while taking on the challenge of life whatever that might be for you.
zombiephysicistover 2 years ago
This is unthinking and uses fallacy of edge cases. Brain transplants. Reality is generally a core of you remains. Yes some people completely change. But that is an edge case. This tries to be profound, but ain’t.
评论 #34565997 未加载
jelliclesfarmover 2 years ago
I thought..I love my cats unconditionally.<p>Mostly because 1. I am grateful for them. 2. It is not an equal relationship 3. I am the caretaker.<p>And then I realized that those were the conditions.
评论 #34566300 未加载
chfritzover 2 years ago
Anyone who is a parent knows what unconditional love is.
评论 #34565010 未加载
revskillover 2 years ago
Dog &quot;love&quot; for human is the only true unconditional love.
评论 #34566248 未加载
jimkleiberover 2 years ago
For me, I think about &quot;unconditional love&quot; for someone else as trying to always believe that they are a good person, no matter what happens.<p>In other words, I see it as unconditionally loving their essence (or soul, core, or some deep immovable part of them) and at the same time, conditionally liking their behaviors or other extensions of their essence.<p>In this way, I can commit to trying my hardest to believe in your good intentions, no matter what happens, while at the same time, letting myself dislike your actions. E.g., a woman I had dated I believe lied to me about being pregnant with a child of mine after we had broken up. While I was furious at the time, after reflection, I thought that if she were to lie about something as deep as that, she may have been hurting so deeply and that I may have contributed to her pain. So by reflecting, I got myself back to thinking that she may have been trying her best and may not have really known what she was doing. At the same time, I didn&#x27;t like that she lied about that and didn&#x27;t trust her word or want to get back into a romantic relationship with her.<p>So this is the approach I like to take: dig deep to try to get back to loving one&#x27;s essence, while allowing myself to like or dislike what someone does, says, has, etc.<p>I really appreciate MLK&#x27;s perspective on this that he delivers in his Loving Your Enemies speech [0]:<p>&gt; And this is what Jesus means, I think, in this very passage when he says, “Love your enemy.” And it’s significant that he does not say, “Like your enemy.” Like is a sentimental something, an affectionate something. There are a lot of people that I find it difficult to like. I don’t like what they do to me. I don’t like what they say about me and other people. I don’t like their attitudes. I don’t like some of the things they’re doing. I don’t like them. But Jesus says love them. And love is greater than like. Love is understanding, redemptive goodwill for all men, so that you love everybody, because God loves them. You refuse to do anything that will defeat an individual, because you have agape in your soul. And here you come to the point that you love the individual who does the evil deed, while hating the deed that the person does. This is what Jesus means when he says, &quot;Love your enemy.&quot; This is the way to do it. When the opportunity presents itself when you can defeat your enemy, you must not do it.<p>And I highly recommend you listen to MLK deliver the full speech via audio[1]—it frequently shakes me to my core.<p>[0]: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;kinginstitute.stanford.edu&#x2F;king-papers&#x2F;documents&#x2F;loving-your-enemies-sermon-delivered-dexter-avenue-baptist-church" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;kinginstitute.stanford.edu&#x2F;king-papers&#x2F;documents&#x2F;lov...</a><p>[1]: <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=522wcqUlS0Y&amp;pp=ygUTbG92aW5nIHlvdXIgZW5lbWllcw%3D%3D">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.youtube.com&#x2F;watch?v=522wcqUlS0Y&amp;pp=ygUTbG92aW5nI...</a>
combatentropyover 2 years ago
&gt; what you&#x27;re saying is you love someone for who they are as opposed to for what they are doing at any particular moment? but then what if they change? what if they become someone other than who they were when you decided to offer them &quot;unconditional love&quot;? (does no one question this?)<p>No, loving someone for what kind of person they are, would still be conditional.<p>&gt; you can&#x27;t expect to feel the same about someone no matter what [...]<p>Love is not a feeling.<p>Well, okay, &quot;love&quot; is perhaps an overloaded word. It means many different things in many different contexts. &quot;I love pizza&quot; means something a little different than &quot;I love you&quot;.<p>Many will say that love is really an action. I love you, by feeding you or taking you to the hospital when you need to, and so on. Of course, that doesn&#x27;t quite capture it either, because if your mother told you &quot;I love you and will do anything for you, but I don&#x27;t really feel anything towards you,&quot; well, that would feel cold indeed.<p>Many will say that love is an act of the will, but falling in love is independent of the will and sometimes even contrary to it, like when someone falls in love with someone who is already married --- even married to a friend. And so you don&#x27;t act on that feeling, because the loving thing to do is to sacrifice yourself in that case.<p>In fact all love will eventually entail some kind of sacrifice. Else it has never been tested, and that is no sure love at all.<p>&gt; what if the person you grew up with becomes a monster, with little left of their former self? how can you love someone who no longer gives you reason to love them?<p>You can love someone who has gone wrong. It is the hardest kind of love, because loving them in action is always doing the opposite of what they want, of what they ask you to do for them. Imagine your child becomes addicted to crack. To love them would be to not give them crack.<p>In sum, love is something that can start on its own through no act of the will but at times, even in happy relationships, you have to downshift into doing it out of sheer will, to keep it alive throughout the years. It more than a feeling, but also more than a cold action. Sometimes the feeling motivates the action, and sometimes the action motivates the feeling. It&#x27;s weird.<p>How can you love someone you don&#x27;t even like? I just remembered that C. S. Lewis addressed this in one of his books (was it Mere Christianity or The Four Loves?). He said, there is one person you have been loving your whole life even when you don&#x27;t like them, and that is yourself. Often we do things that we detest, and we berate ourselves over how terrible a person we are or were. Yet we keep on loving ourselves, by feeding ourselves, tending our bodies, etc.
kerkeslagerover 2 years ago
I believe in unconditional love, but I feel like there&#x27;s a lot of context to that which has to be explained to even respond to what this author is saying.<p>First, if love is extended to someone based on who they are, that&#x27;s a condition, it&#x27;s not unconditional. Unconditional love doesn&#x27;t make sense if it&#x27;s only extended to one or a few people--it has to be extended to everyone, universally. So talk of switching brains or bodies makes little sense: if you love unconditionally, you love both people, and switching their brain&#x2F;body configurations is irrelevant to that.<p>In that context, I think what actions you take based on unconditional love are more nuanced. I do think love necessarily affects your actions, but unconditional love for one person needs to be balanced with unconditional love for other people. Typically you don&#x27;t kill someone if you love them, but I think it would be possible to both love Hitler and kill Hitler, because your love of Hitler has to be balanced with love for the victims of the holocaust. People who do horrible things are the hardest to love I think--but loving those people is important, because without love people only become worse. It seems plausible to me that if Hitler had experienced more love, the Holocaust might have been prevented. Daryl Davis talking over 200 KKK members into giving up their robes[1] comes to mind as an example of how loving people who do terrible things can be extremely powerful.<p>And critically, &quot;everyone&quot; includes yourself, so unconditional love means loving yourself. So the &quot;to what i am able to do with or to this person&quot; thing isn&#x27;t true: loving someone unconditionally doesn&#x27;t mean you let them walk all over you, because your unconditional love for that person is balanced with unconditional love for yourself.<p>I&#x27;ll also add that unconditional love for yourself also means having reasonable expectations for yourself and prioritizing what love you take action upon. Talking KKK members into leaving the KKK is admirable, but it&#x27;s beyond what can reasonable be expected of people. And if love of Hitler is something that comes up for you often, you might be better served exerting that loving energy toward someone who isn&#x27;t a dead genocidal dictator.<p>[1] <a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.npr.org&#x2F;2017&#x2F;08&#x2F;20&#x2F;544861933&#x2F;how-one-man-convinced-200-ku-klux-klan-members-to-give-up-their-robes" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.npr.org&#x2F;2017&#x2F;08&#x2F;20&#x2F;544861933&#x2F;how-one-man-convinc...</a>