TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Retro design is crippling innovation

67 pointsby PixelRobotover 13 years ago

23 comments

mechanical_fishover 13 years ago
Comparing the headline to the contents, I feel there's room for a follow-up article: "hyperbole is killing criticism".<p>I mean, it's OK to hate skeuomorphs, a valid critical position, but nobody is going to die.<p>And the whole thing feels like Louis CK's riff about airplanes. You are <i>riffling through entire bookstores and museums on an affordable 150dpi Star Trek pad in the bathroom</i> while complaining that innovation has stopped because the graphics look too familiar.<p>Two limited defenses of skeuomorphs. One: In a world where all of tech turns over on a timescale of months, orientation is important. It may be more important that people can glance at your calendar app and <i>tell that it's supposed to be a calendar</i> than that the calendar app perform optimally in the hands of a trained expert.<p>The other is: Skeuomorphs generally mimic designs that are at least decades old, sometimes centuries old. Be cautious about casually discarding the work of tens of generations of designers in the name of neophilia.<p>(Book page-flipping animations are less defensible with the latter argument, but the former still applies.)
评论 #3578190 未加载
评论 #3576880 未加载
camtarnover 13 years ago
There's a nice tip in the comments for that article:<p>"In Google Calendar, pick the "4 Weeks" option at the top, instead of "Month" and it functions exactly as you describe, with the current week at the top. -benjymous"<p>I didn't have a 4 Weeks view - turns out there's a setting which controls what the button between Month and Agenda does, in Settings -&#62; General -&#62; Custom View. There's also a setting above that for which view is your default when you reload the calendar.
评论 #3575946 未加载
jinushaunover 13 years ago
I don't understand his criticism of the calendar. I WANT to see past dates. It gives me a context to what day of the week it is in relation to dates before and after today. Nothing irks me more when a calendar does not show days from last month on this month's calendar.<p>Example: Wednesday is April 2... Was Monday March 30 or 31? It forces me to switch my entire calendar to get this info. I want to see days in March and May on my April calendar.<p>For me personally, the agenda view is hard to view because my brain works on a week/month scale, not day scale. In day view, I also like to see all my events in blocks throughout the day with gaps, instead of a linear list of events without gaps. It helps me visualise free time.
评论 #3575934 未加载
评论 #3576139 未加载
评论 #3575908 未加载
sambeauover 13 years ago
I don't get it.<p>He spends most of the article telling us that skeuomorphs are bad giving the example of calendar app that looks like a desk calendar and then finishes by praising an app with a screen that skeuomorphically flips up just like a wall-calendar.
评论 #3575465 未加载
评论 #3575898 未加载
dkarlover 13 years ago
I really hate criticism that doesn't suggest improvements. You can point out deficiencies all day, but until you have proposed or implied an improvement, you have not even proved that what you are criticizing is suboptimal, much less provided any helpful pointer towards improvement.<p>Unfortunately, the "old-fashioned, physical object" this design is based on is the human brain, or more precisely, the useful cultural artifacts that happen to be engrained in pretty much all the human brains on the planet. The monthly and weekly calendar reflects how we think about time. You think you can stop me from thinking in weeks and months by changing one calendar application? You'd have to work a little harder than that. Here's what you need to do:<p>1. Stop my company from scheduling my paychecks to coincide with the beginning and middle of each month. Stop them from organizing my work days into groups of five days in the middle of groups of seven, and stop people where I work from informally scheduling things with respect to month boundaries.<p>2. Do the same to the companies that employ all the people I occasionally synchronize my social schedule with.<p>3. Stop all the businesses I use from scheduling lessons and classes on a monthly basis and varying their hours on a weekly basis. Persuade the state government that it should be as easy to buy liquor on Sunday as on any other day. (That should be easy once you've abolished the days of the week; see 5.)<p>4. Detach holidays from dates. It would be so much nicer if Thanksgiving was the 329th day of the year instead of the fourth Thursday in November. That way I could forget about months and weeks, and my online calendar could make better use of screen space. (Again, this will follow easily once you've accomplished number 5.)<p>5. Abolish the days of the week and the months of the year. Prevent anyone from referring to Monday, Tuesday, January, etc., or to weeks and months at all, so I never have to think, "We're shipping on the first Monday of next month. How many days until then?"<p>After all that, I'll no longer want a calendar app that orients me with respect to weeks and months. You can get rid of your "skeuomorph," and I won't mind that my calendar app gives me no visual, non-verbal cues about what day of the week or week of the month it is.<p>So, sarcasm aside, you DO need to show month boundaries. It is not helpful to propose doing away with the one convention for that without proposing any replacement for it.<p>Also, it is not helpful to propose doing away with the past entirely. People are oriented by the past as well as by the future. Oh, dear, it's been a week since I told Doug that information would be available soon. I had better drop him a line and explain that it's delayed. My tooth has been hurting ever since I went to the dentist; how long has that been? When's the last time I worked out?<p>Showing the past is a valuable function! If you don't recognize that showing the past is part of the function of the calendar, then criticizing a calendar for showing too much of the past rings a little hollow, because you aren't balancing the valuable functions of the interface. You're just picking one and throwing out another.<p>A better statement of the problem is that the visual clues for month boundaries are the top and bottom of the displayed grid of days on the screen, and therefore the past to present ratio varies dramatically through the month. During some parts of the month, you see very little of the past, and during other parts of the month, you see very little of the future.<p>A useful suggestion would be to detach month boundaries from the edges of the displayed grid and show them in some other way, perhaps by using color or shading. That way you can keep the balance of past to present close to an optimum value. Perhaps the current week can be the second or third from the top. I'm not a UI designer, but I think that is a more useful analysis of the problem, even if I didn't show off a new word I learned a few weeks ago from a magazine article.
评论 #3576331 未加载
dwyerover 13 years ago
Finally! Somebody who understands me!<p>Now I certainly don't think retro design is "crippling" the basic OS experience. I personally find the whole desktop metaphor to be silly and outdated and not so useful for a generation that has grown up with computers and don't need a clock to look like a wall clock in order to understand that it's telling us the time. OSX widgets may be immature and tasteless, but they're not a hindrance.<p>If retro design is crippling anything, IMO, it digital audio workstations (DAW). Whenever I launch Cubase I have to deal with virtual mixer boards and virtual synthesizers that mimic the interfaces of 40 year old hardware to the point that you have to turn virtual knobs with my mouse. It's ridiculous and more often than not it's frustrating. Now I understand how this choice of design eases the learning curve, but I'd much rather jump over a few hurdles than run straightaway into a wall.<p>This is why programs like vim and emacs are still relevant decades after their invention. They don't insult the users intelligence, they don't pretend to be something they're not, and they take full advantage of the platform they're designed for.<p>If somebody could create a DAW that adhere's to this kind of philosophy, I don't care if it uses ncurses as an interface, I'd adopt it in a heartbeat.
keithpeterover 13 years ago
"Let paper work like paper and screens like screens."<p>I liked that quote. Having said that, I take the point that skeuomorphs are not exactly destroying people's minds.<p>Another quote I found extremely intresting was this one, from a professional designer's blog<p>"It shows the care and attention paid to the printing of a photographic image, but also <i>shows how the analogue process of printing a photograph shares a lot with the the digital process of adjusting an image in Photoshop.</i>" [ my italics ]<p>See the quote in context at the link below<p><a href="http://www.wemadethis.co.uk/blog/2012/01/shaped-by-war/" rel="nofollow">http://www.wemadethis.co.uk/blog/2012/01/shaped-by-war/</a><p>Basically, are we reaching the point where metaphors that originally made software more accessible (Photoshop like a wet darkroom) actually lose their meaning. My colleagues who teach photography often illustrate aspects of the photographic printing process using Photoshop (reverse metaphor).<p>Does anyone have any academic references on the anthropology of interfaces?
bornon5over 13 years ago
If his argument is valid, there's no logical reason to stop where he does. You see a continuous progression of weeks instead of discrete months; fine. But what about days? What's so special about the end of one day and the beginning of the next? Nothing - it's just an artifact of paper calendars, daily planners, and so on.<p>What a calendar should be, if we're going to truly abolish the tragedy of skeuomorphism, is a smoothly flowing timeline, with you at the front, diminishing logarithmically into the future. This way, you can clearly see your appointments. Should make the author happy.<p>The point is, sometimes we need to artificially break things up into manageable pieces. We think in milestones - the beginning of a season, midnight as a landmark showing how late you're staying up. Some skeuomorphic designs are only "incidentally" skeuomorphic, in that they solve a problem the right way, and just happen to resemble how people used to solve that problem.
nextparadigmsover 13 years ago
Isn't iOS filled with skeumorphism, too? I know Matias Duarte said he wanted to make Android 4.0's design completely digital and without any skeumorphism.
评论 #3575911 未加载
rurounijonesover 13 years ago
First thing I saw "Retro design is crippling innovation" followed by the left hand column "Subscribe to Wired Magazine for..."<p>Magazine, how retro
评论 #3575966 未加载
ctdonathover 13 years ago
I keep wondering when we'll move away from the "pages" paradigm in e-books. We should be returning to the scroll paradigm (which is already a familiar motif in software), not forcing content to fit a physical format which the e-reader is precisely an attempt to get away from.<p>Worst case is when trying to highlight, as a single mark (with note attached), a section of text which spans more than 2 pages (esp. when a "page" is a large-font phone-screen size): I can't tap-and-drag from one end of the section to then next because the "page" paradigm intervenes. Web page? word processing? no problem, we're used to highlighting via scrolling. E-book? <i>scroll</i>? nope, gotta match that page-flipping animation.
评论 #3576329 未加载
评论 #3576333 未加载
petercooperover 13 years ago
I thought this was going to be about gaming before I read it. Retro designs have become de rigeur in gaming over the last couple of years and it's <i>boosting</i> innovation by making it possible for indie developers to compete on a more level playing field against the big studios (e.g. MineCraft).<p>This article demonstrates how it's almost the opposite for non-game interfaces. Instead, it's the plucky upstarts that can take the risk on novel interfaces since they don't have large numbers of users to annoy (and I bet if Google tried to get radical with Calendar now, there'd be a real storm of hate over it).
yabaiover 13 years ago
If nothing else, this article made me consider all of the 'retro' ideas I live with everyday. It is amazing how much things advance while staying the same.<p>What other 'retro' tech hasn't changed much? The automobile?
jmilloyover 13 years ago
Often, I'm just as frustrated about the opposite problem... technology that is <i>less</i> functional than what it is replacing because it <i>doesn't</i> replicate important features in a natural way. For example, I feel like I can organize my physical music collection on shelves in my house more quickly, naturally, and helpfully than I can my digital music collection in any media player/music manager I've tried. Shouldn't our technology be <i>at least as good as</i> its counterpart?
评论 #3576147 未加载
aridiculousover 13 years ago
The author is off-target.<p>Apple went over the top with the new iCal GUI, but it wasn't an interaction problem. Users have mental models from cultural experience that dictate how they want to use things. In other words, "that software feels intuitive."<p>The issue I suspect the author actually has with the new iCal is that it goes over the top visually. Software doesn't have to mimic the gaudy ornamentation of a real world object to resemble it.
bradtover 13 years ago
Can't agree more that skeuomorphs are awful. Probably my fav example of this is "sticky notes" apps. So f'in useless! What are your favs?
评论 #3575765 未加载
zmonkeyzover 13 years ago
One nice thing that came about with the KIN (yes as in Microsoft) was the KIN studio. It had sort of a timeline thing going with all of the pictures and video you uploaded grouped by days. A lot of people complained it had no calendar but I thought it would have been kind of cool to put the calendar functionality with the studio.
Ryguover 13 years ago
Regarding Google Calendar, there's a "7 days" view that shows today+6 days.<p>Personally I prefer the regular week view.
jasonjeiover 13 years ago
Speaking of a good calendar UI widget, I really like how ITA Software OnTheFly iOS app does it... Instead of showing you one month at a time it shows you the current week - 2 weeks, current week + 2 weeks. Makes it really utilitarian. I wish more apps would adopt that format making scheduling much easier.
Tooover 13 years ago
HEAVILY inspired by <a href="http://www.marco.org/2010/03/28/more-ideas-than-time-logarithmic-calendar-view" rel="nofollow">http://www.marco.org/2010/03/28/more-ideas-than-time-logarit...</a>
yockover 13 years ago
So...this article about how a design philosophy is wrong contains exactly how many direct comparasons between flawed designs and their alternatives?
mbestoover 13 years ago
This is article's premise is weird on so many accounts..<p>It's "crippling innovation"...what!? Retro design isn't an institution, or a person, or even a "thing". It's a concept that designers take in order to progress towards a more usable interface.<p>You know what "cripples" innovation - massive design changes that happen in extended batch schedules. Technically this doesn't cripple innovation, it simply decreases innovative adoption and user acceptance.
pnathanover 13 years ago
What's wrong with skeuomorphs?<p>That needs to be answered first before assuming crippling of innovation.