TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Should I ask for user demographics on the registration form of our app?

5 pointsby gerasiniabout 13 years ago
I am in the process of designing the registration page for our application. And I am in the middle of the dilemma on whether we should ask for user demographics.<p>From my experience as a consumer of cloud application, most apps do not ask for such demographics. And this is a trend emerged in the past few year. I can understand the "Why": more fields -> increased abandonment of the form and thus fewer customers.<p>But if you do not ask, how could you possibly get such information. Information that can help you ad-target specific demographics or build a new feature/product for a user group (eg lawyers) that seem to have adopted your app.<p>What is your view? Do you have any break-through solutions?

3 comments

Sander_Marechalabout 13 years ago
Have a look at StackOverflow or pretty much any "social" site, like Facebook or LinkedIn. The registration process is as short as possible. Then, after they are registered and signed in, prompt them to flesh out their profile with more information. Remember that you need to entice them by doing so. SO gives out badges to users who filled out all fields. LI keeps a percentage score of "profile completed". Those things nudge users to want to fill out their profile.
评论 #3624873 未加载
loraxabout 13 years ago
If you ask for demographics you will not only get increased abandonment, you will also get a lot of incorrect information, would it surprise you to know that I'm a 95 year old sumo wrestler? Your users don't care that you will get higher advertising rates due to "ad-target specific demographics". Don't ask for demographic information unless the user can see how it will benefit them directly. Facebook gets peoples correct birthdays (most of the time) because if you put in the right one, you get birthday wishes from your friends.
gerasiniabout 13 years ago
Sander, lorax thank you for your input.<p>We discussed the concept internally and decided that we won't ask for any user demographics on the registration form.<p>Later, when we have a clear way to use user demographic, we will create a value proposition for them to enter it. Eg tell us your profession so that it will be visible to other users and get new leads.