TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Why is calculus considered such a difficult subject to learn?

1 pointsby ggr2342almost 2 years ago
I see this primarily from students in US universities. They dread their freshman calculus classes? Why? Are the teachers bad or the curriculum or books?<p>Calculus is such a beautiful field with geometrical explanations for almost every theorem. It is the least abstract or dry subject in math.<p>What is your favourite textbook that made you understand and love calculus (single and multivariable)?

2 comments

nramanandalmost 2 years ago
Even as a math graduate, I still think calculus is a bit weird.<p>The idea of successive approximations for a slope culminating in a dy&#x2F;dx term -- where we say dx (really the denominator of the limit definition) is obviously not zero, but is also smaller than any given real number. It&#x27;s not clear that numbers should work like that.<p>Pile on that calculus courses (at least in the US) tend to care more about deriving interesting trigonometric&#x2F;exponential&#x2F;polynomial&#x2F;whatever derivatives once using the limit definition and proceed to have students essentially memorize the derivation tricks for the remaining 90% of the course, and it can easily end up being overwhelming.
评论 #36768852 未加载
raverbashingalmost 2 years ago
Honestly? It sounds to me like a meme. A bit like &quot;Math is hard&quot; for freshmen<p>There&#x27;s nothing specifically hard about it. Maybe harder-ish than other subjects, but nothing specifically hard (I mean, specifically about Calculus 101 - later ones are of course harder)<p>&gt; Are the teachers bad or the curriculum or books?<p>But yes, yes and yes. All of that. And wasting too much time with crap like &quot;theorems about limits&quot; which literally nobody cares unless you&#x27;re on a pure math track.