TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

I Will Never Use the Metric System [video]

9 pointsby warrenmover 1 year ago

5 comments

Dig1tover 1 year ago
Pretty well done video, he sort of belabors the “imperial is so stupid and illogical” stuff. I think most people are aware of it already.<p>Growing up in the US I have had so many teachers at every single layer of schooling launch into a speech how dumb our units of measurement are and how much better the metric system is. Yet we all still use it and it makes no difference in our everyday lives.<p>I’ve never heard anyone say anything positive about the imperial system. I don’t care very much, but I don’t really mind it. A foot is a decently intuitive unit of measurement for everyday things, it’s helpful how “human” the units are. Like a tallish person is a nice round 6 feet, other body parts are 5, 6, 7 inches etc. Everyday objects are single digit roundish numbers in inches and pounds. I think that’s part of why it’s extra sticky here.
评论 #37312231 未加载
评论 #37312118 未加载
warrenmover 1 year ago
The Imperial System definitely feels far more <i>human-oriented</i> ... (and not just because some measurements have body parts associated (foot, handspan, etc))<p>Temperatures are a good example of this, and I saw a wonderful graphic&#x2F;meme a few years ago I can put here in print:<p>---------<p>F - 0º 100º - pretty cold, pretty hot<p>C - 0º 100º- cold, dead<p>K - 0º 100º - dead, still dead<p>---------<p>Imperial units are not <i>objectively</i> &quot;better&quot; than Metric units<p>Neither are Metric units <i>objectively</i> &quot;better&quot; than Imperial units<p>You can definitely tell Imperial is meant for &quot;human&quot; or &quot;comfort&quot; use vs Metric&#x27;s &quot;scientific&quot; or &quot;precision&quot; use, though
rhelzover 1 year ago
The problems with the metric system are largely the problems of using base-10 arithmetic. Say you are a carpenter; your boss hands you a meter stick and asks you to cut him a piece of wood 1&#x2F;3 meter long.<p>Well, there&#x27;s no line on the stick for that. You go back to the boss, and say this meter stick isn&#x27;t accurate enough; Its only marked to centimeters. So he grumbles, buys you one which is marked to millimeters, and you try again....still no line on the meter stick for 1&#x2F;3rd of a meter...<p>Wiki has a beautiful chart relating the olde-tymie english units like inches, barleycorns, and furlongs. These units were developed ad-hoc by people living in every kind of society from industrial stretching back to the paleolithic. And yet, they are remarkably coherent--once you notice it. What is striking is how often the factors of 2 and 3 are involved in converting one unit into another; e.g., three barleycorns is an inch, 6 picas is an inch, 3 feet is a yard, etc.<p>Metric <i>calculations</i> are ostensibly easier because we use base-10. If we used, say, base-6 or base-12, metric calculations would be as difficult to do in our heads as the English units are. But all those ancient English units would super-easy, because its super-easy to multiply or divide by 2 or 3 in base-6 or base-12.<p>You can see this most clearly, ironically, in nations like, say, Japan, who have adopted the metric system the most throughly. There, they never use decimeters, or even centimeters. Every measurement is given in millimeters, and you tend to find lengths like 24 and 48 millimeters to be especially previlent--because they both have lots of factors of 2 and 3, making it easy to divide lengths into the most common ratios which are actually used.<p>Its why eggs are sold by the dozen and beer comes in 6-packs.
评论 #37314455 未加载
评论 #37314903 未加载
评论 #37313971 未加载
resonatorover 1 year ago
I&#x27;ve been slowing learning the imperial measurement system and I would say that it&#x27;s now natural to me in a very limited sense.<p>I grew up in Australia using the metric system. As a child, it was (and probably still is) common to throw around estimates in inches or yards, but anything precise was expressed in in mm or meters. So I&#x27;ve always had a sense of how big and inch or two is but like the presenter, for anything bigger I&#x27;d need to perform a quick conversions back to my natural metric measurements to understand what was meant.<p>I&#x27;m also a woodworker and use many vintage tools, produced before the world adopted metric. I decided long ago that I would these tools as they were designed to be used and not try to mess with metric, too.<p>At the time, I had no intuition at all about fractions of an inch. I didn&#x27;t even know that 8ths and 16ths where how they were divided. I literally had no idea. I needed to pull out my maths brain to tell you whether 7&#x2F;8 or 5&#x2F;16 was bigger.<p>I used imperial measurements almost exclusively while woodworking in my shed. This was possible because I don&#x27;t need to communicate measures to anyone other than myself. I also don&#x27;t often need to take measurements of odd things that don&#x27;t fall nicely onto an imperial ruler.<p>I&#x27;m now comfortable using inches for measuring things up to maybe 100&quot; — I wonder if 100 is only an obvious stopping point because of my metric upbringing — I still have no concept of a mile or yard before converting to metric.<p>But I do still do use metric when I need a precise measure of something that can&#x27;t be expressed easily in inches. So I&#x27;d use 12&quot; rather than 304mm, but I&#x27;d use 300mm rather than 11 and whatever inches.<p>Also, it&#x27;s made easier due to a lot of hangover in stock wood dimensions. It still comes in thicknesses that are more naturally expressed in inches, for example 19mm (3&#x2F;4&quot;), 25mm (1&quot;).<p>I&#x27;ve been working this way for about 10 years and can now think in inches without any conversion. I doubt I could flip all units of measure to imperial without changing the world I live in and the people I work with.
评论 #37316396 未加载
N19PEDL2over 1 year ago
A fun fact about my ignorance of the imperial system: I moved to UK some years ago and I started using Tinder to meet girls there. I noticed that everyone wrote their height in feet in the description, so I did too. I&#x27;m 181 cm (5&#x27;11), but since everyone lies about their height on Tinder, I wrote 5&#x27;12. This until a girl I matched pointed out that 5&#x27;12 is actually 6 ft.