TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: How much does open source play a role when choosing a software?

3 pointsby nirgaover 1 year ago
In recent years, I&#x27;ve seen a surge of open source alternatives to traditionally closed source solutions. From Posthog (replacing Mixpanel), Infisical (Doppler &#x2F; Vault), and others.<p>This might be a question that was asked here before but - how much does it play a role when choosing a product to use? Will you prefer product A over identical product B just because A is OSS? If A is slightly worse, do you still prefer to work with A? Or is it completely the other way around?

4 comments

jqpabc123over 1 year ago
As always --- it depends.<p>Developer tools are supported well enough by open source.<p>Business software is less so.<p>How important is support and continuity and longevity? Source code is the only support Open Source really offers. If you get something more --- good for you but typically there is no obligation or commitment made in this regard. Even if you get one, it&#x27;s longevity is suspect. It&#x27;s really easy to walk away from a software product when it&#x27;s not paying it&#x27;s own way.<p>Most people looking to invest and build a business expect somewhat more than Open Source offers for &quot;business critical&quot; software. And many of these people are not in the software business and don&#x27;t want to be.
t312227over 1 year ago
imho. (!) FOSS <i>every</i> time ...<p>even if its <i>far worse</i> than a comparable proprietary solution ... as long as it fits my use-case :))<p>but don&#x27;t get me wrong: there are a lot of use-cases out there which are best solved with proprietary products - and that&#x27;s absolutely ok ;))<p>and especially as a company i should pay in one form or another for either solution!!<p>as a private person this is optional for me: but no FOSS-project will reject a donation or an order of some of its merchandise - if available ;)<p>just my 0.02€
评论 #38686342 未加载
themanmaranover 1 year ago
For me it&#x27;s just knowing the option to self host exists.<p>Of course as long as there&#x27;s a $X&#x2F;mo cloud version available I&#x27;ll almost always go with the hosted. But knowing that in case xyz startup goes bankrupt I could maintain the service myself is a great safety net.
vmatsiiakoover 1 year ago
For some teams it&#x27;s just a philosophical decision, but many larger enterprises have mandatory requirements which makes OSS software much easier to adopt (this is in relation to infrastructure products of course).
评论 #38686325 未加载