TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Could Google Bard Disrupt Universities?

5 pointsby dalyover 1 year ago
Step 1 Google collects a bunch of playlists. Bard classifies them as &quot;networking&quot;, split by sub-topic (queueing theory, congestion handling, DNS, TCP&#x2F;UDP, hardware types, wireless vs wired vs quantum, etc.)<p>Step 2 is for Bard to summarize each lecture and create a 1-page summary of the important points as well as a syllabus of each course.<p>Step 3 is a use the lectures as reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF) so Bard is able to interactively answer questions about networking before, during, and&#x2F;or after the lectures.<p>Step 4 is for Bard to create (or find) github repositories related to the course as well as the whole subject of networking.<p>So now Bard IS the teacher.<p>Iterate by topic.<p>Step 5 is to have Bard create a &quot;canonical version&quot; of network lectures that it has self-generated, curated by experts in the field.<p>Now you&#x27;ve disrupted all the Universities.<p>I suspect that a small team could have most of this working within the next year or two using Bard doing voice recognition in lectures as well as Bard generated voice, video-from-text to illustrate the lectures, and even generate and correct homework problems unique to a particular user&#x27;s weak areas of understanding based on interactions.<p>Bard could be adaptive enough so that when I don&#x27;t remember Little&#x27;s Law it can dynamically insert a quick tutorial at the point in question.<p>Companies could use such courses instead of resumes or interviews. You need to show a passing grade for a course in their problem area. People could easily transition from their current job to another job by taking Bard courses that target the employer. Everybody wins.<p>Having deep control of youtube puts Google ahead of OpenAI.<p>Skate where the puck is going, not where it has been. -- Wayne Gretzky

5 comments

solardevover 1 year ago
There&#x27;s already nothing stopping from someone from learning great material online already, between YouTube and Wikipedia and OpenCourseWare and all that. And Google already offers a bunch of certifications that employers could use. I&#x27;ve never known a single developer who has one, or a company that&#x27;s asked for one.<p>IMO the main purpose of universities isn&#x27;t really even education anymore, but gatekeeping. The commercial sector often uses them as a first-pass filter to get candidates who have shown they can abide by the rules for 4-ish years and put in the grunt work. If it were actually a matter of skill and knowledge, you would be able to placement test your way straight to a diploma... that&#x27;s not the case. They want you to go through the rigamarole of showing up every day for attendance, turning in all the repetitive homework, etc. It&#x27;s also training for the industrialized model of work that we have.<p>Sure, some specialist degrees and post-grad programs have actually relevant training for specific fields, but a lot of people don&#x27;t really work in the field of their undergrads. The diploma is proof that you can check boxes and be a good cog in the machine, not that you&#x27;re exceptionally skilled or brilliant or anything.<p>What you&#x27;re suggesting sounds like an AI-powered University of Phoenix, which is already considered kinda worthless. I suspect such a certification from Google would be worth even less.
mnky9800nover 1 year ago
The printing press didn&#x27;t do it, the telephone didn&#x27;t do it, television didn&#x27;t do it, the internet didn&#x27;t do it, moocs didn&#x27;t do it, why would we think ai would do it?
al2o3crover 1 year ago
<p><pre><code> I suspect that a small team could have most of this working within the next year or two </code></pre> Each of steps 2-5 would be an impressive achievement advancing the state-of-the-art. Big &quot;draw the rest of the fucking owl&quot; energy here.
gtirloniover 1 year ago
You can just try using ChatGPT&#x2F;Bard as a college professor yourself today and report results here. My guess is you&#x27;ll have to adjust your enthusiasm.
nullindividualover 1 year ago
Thankfully there is an easy answer to your question:<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Betteridge&#x27;s_law_of_headlines" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;en.wikipedia.org&#x2F;wiki&#x2F;Betteridge&#x27;s_law_of_headlines</a>
评论 #38776357 未加载