TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Wacky Jabber (2022)

11 pointsby andy_herbertover 1 year ago

1 comment

AndrewSwiftover 1 year ago
As someone who learned a foreign language as an adult, I really enjoyed this.<p>And, I think it represents two important issues with the technology industry:<p>1. the status of information provided by computers is usually missing<p>2. there is a complete unwillingness to return negative results<p>By #1 I mean that you ask a computer a question, whether it be Google, an AI or probably any other service, and you get an answer.<p>What you don&#x27;t get:<p>• feedback on whether the question was clear or nonsense<p>• whether the answer is know to be true, is a best guess, or is probably nonsense<p>• whether the answer is copyrighted or protected in some other way<p>By #2 I mean that where in many cases a human would say:<p>• I didn&#x27;t understand<p>• I understood but don&#x27;t know the answer<p>• I have some ideas but am not sure how useful they are<p>• I tried to get an answer but the library was closed<p>Computers just supply an answer in a vacuum, even if any observer could instantly tell that the answer is garbage<p>Example #1: I ask Alexa to play &quot;playlist late Beatles&quot; and it plays something completely different, instead of saying &quot;could you come closer and repeat the question&quot; or &quot;there&#x27;s a lot of background noise, I couldn&#x27;t understand&quot;<p>I presume that Amazon is afraid that if they gave these kinds of answers it would become blindingly obvious how unreliable their service is. Providing cheerful-but-wrong responses pushes the blame onto the user: &quot;your question wasn&#x27;t clear enough&quot;.<p>Example #2: Apple products have an increasing tendency to refuse to display any kind of error message. It&#x27;s as if want to inspire confidence, and saying &quot;iCloud Synchronization failed&quot; would break that. Better to just have random delays and forums filled with complaining users.<p>Example #3: AI has proven to be extremely useful, but since the status of the results is completely missing one is handicapped from using them in the real world:<p>• is this answer copyrighted<p>• is it completely wrong<p>• was your question incomprehensible?
评论 #38871812 未加载