TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Did you turn off Google activity tracking?

58 pointsby nittanymountabout 1 year ago

27 comments

donatjabout 1 year ago
I actually really like it, particularly location history. For instance I find it fun to go back and look at past trips in detail and reminisce.<p>I can definitely see where someone wouldn&#x27;t want that though
评论 #39660411 未加载
评论 #39660550 未加载
评论 #39660946 未加载
评论 #39660240 未加载
评论 #39660756 未加载
评论 #39660706 未加载
neilvabout 1 year ago
Yes, I turned it off a long time ago.<p>But I&#x27;m also not normally signed into a Google account, I don&#x27;t use anything that automatically signs me into Google (not a browser nor any other program or device), I run aggressive Web tracker blocking, I try to use Tor Browser for sites that don&#x27;t require logins, and my phone is GrapheneOS without any Google Play apps.<p>That&#x27;s little more than the minimal, IMHO. Google and many other tech companies are still able to violate me, but the next tier of defense against them is too difficult.
tr33houseabout 1 year ago
Surprisingly enough, I actually _want_ mine turned on. I normally look through when I found a particular site and just can&#x27;t remember what it was but vaguely remember the dates or some other information about them. I&#x27;m happy Google is even sharing these controls but I would assume anything that&#x27;s <i>deleted</i> here is a soft delete on their system
评论 #39661888 未加载
jimmywetnipsabout 1 year ago
No, sometimes it accidentally turns off and I have to turn it on again.<p>I like having it on just like I like having Internet search history to look back and find something.<p>My memory kinda sucks and I travel a lot so sometimes I use it to place myself where I was 2 months ago. Whether it&#x27;s to find a restaurant I walked by but forgot to save in maps, or to try to remember where I lost something yesterday etc etc<p>I also found out my last month of Google photos had location disabled from my phone. Again by accident. It really sucks because I liked being able to search via location to find photos. Or sometimes find a photo and share a venue or restaurant to friends.
rkagererabout 1 year ago
Yes. I don&#x27;t trust Google.<p>(Is the setting meaningfully respected? Who knows.)<p>I might like this feature if there were a way I could have true sovereignty over the data (ie. stored locally in a manner they cannot hoover back up with an app update, and which is captured by my own backup infrastructure).
gray_-_wolfabout 1 year ago
Yes, except youtube history. Not sure the turning off actually does anything.
评论 #39660316 未加载
评论 #39660248 未加载
solardevabout 1 year ago
I turn everything on and sign in everywhere. It&#x27;s super useful to remember both what I searched for and where I&#x27;ve been.<p>I use Google stuff <i>because</i> of the tracking&#x2F;personalization, like Calendar is integrated with Gmail, or Maps can show my contacts, or Search knows where I am, and YouTube makes OK (not great) recommendations based on my history.<p>I&#x27;d gladly pay them to handle all this for me (instead of ads), especially for search and maps.
BrandoElFollitoabout 1 year ago
I switched ON everything Google I can because it saved my bottom several times already.<p>Well, maybe not really saved my bottom but helped enormously to get some information about a place I was in, a payment or a web page.<p>When people tell me about my data being resold and whatnot I put my hands on my ears and I am not hearing you, la la la la! Truly a responsible behaviour but Google is making my life soooooo much easier.
dwrobertsabout 1 year ago
Thanks for the reminder. I really strongly dislike how it tracks when I &#x27;visit&#x27; my television, that kind of creeps me out a bit
nittanymountabout 1 year ago
this might not be a big deal, but it saves your internal server urls to their database too, this is not expected in some way...?<p>seems it was turned on by default for everyone on March 29th, 2022<p><a href="https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.adzapier.com&#x2F;google-activity-tracking-now-on-by-default" rel="nofollow">https:&#x2F;&#x2F;www.adzapier.com&#x2F;google-activity-tracking-now-on-by-...</a>
recursivedoubtsabout 1 year ago
Yes, i have.<p>No, i don&#x27;t expect the to actually not track me.
est31about 1 year ago
A friend of mine had his phone stolen at a party. He had turned off all remote location services before, a choice he regretted after the theft. I don&#x27;t know precisely which features he turned off, maybe there is separate controls. What can you turn off without losing the ability to locate your stolen phone?
评论 #39661384 未加载
dalfabout 1 year ago
I&#x27;ve turned off web&#x2F;app activities and don&#x27;t use Google web search (directly). However, I keep YouTube and maps tracking (from time to time).<p>YouTube because this is one of the algorithms that provide good suggestions with minor work on my side.<p>Position because I can go back in time when I travel (I try to turn it off otherwise).
eternityforestabout 1 year ago
Nope, I like having a record of where I&#x27;ve been synced in the cloud. Very occasionally I&#x27;ll use it to reconstruct some past events.<p>One time I forgot to clock in, and didn&#x27;t know about the history yet, and when my boss asked my hoe long I thought I had worked I used by bus payment card logs to figure it out.
blakesterzabout 1 year ago
Apparently I keep YoutTube on? Though when they started blocking adblockers I stopped going to YT, but the past few times someone&#x27;s sent me a YT link, it just worked, so maybe they backed off? I wish I could step away from Google like I did from Twitter, but I&#x27;m stuck with it. At least for now.
ufmaceabout 1 year ago
Nah. It&#x27;s mildly useful to me to have all that recorded and accessible. Plus I think there&#x27;s like a 60% chance that turning it off only turns off it being displayed to me and it&#x27;s all still being recorded and stored anyways. &quot;Don&#x27;t be evil&quot; is long gone.
评论 #39660419 未加载
sanitycheckabout 1 year ago
Yes, all off and several google domains blocked with noscript too.<p>I don&#x27;t want anything to be automatically personalised, and Firefox already does a good job of keeping my browsing history &amp; bookmarks.
ricketteabout 1 year ago
Yes many years ago. The only annoyance I have is GMaps not remembering recent places. So you have to type in an address every time. Still outweighs being tracked all the time.
AH4oFVbPT4f8about 1 year ago
Yes but I have to check every so often to make sure its still off. I try to use Kagi for all things search and Fastmail for email&#x2F;calendar.
M95Dabout 1 year ago
Need to have an account to turn it off.
nittanymountabout 1 year ago
reading the comments, kind of interesting to see how people changing the way of thinking privacy over years....<p>remember years ago, when gmail started put on ad based on &#x27;reading&#x27; the email content, it was a big thing, big discussion, haha, now, people accept these things... not exact the same thing tho.
评论 #39660734 未加载
frizlababout 1 year ago
I do not have a gougle account at all.
评论 #39661089 未加载
tmoravecabout 1 year ago
Yes, years ago. Why?
michidkabout 1 year ago
I turned it on.
aminabout 1 year ago
I know I will get downvoted here but I like to keep everything enabled. The more Google knows about me, the more relevant the ads they can serve. I hope Google’s ads will one day be as relevant as the ads I see on Facebook and Instagram.<p>And if I ever get falsely accused of a crime, my Google location history, combined with my Google Photos’ metadata, could serve as my alibi.
评论 #39660759 未加载
评论 #39660400 未加载
评论 #39660462 未加载
pieratabout 1 year ago
Lets be honest here...<p>These settings are whether Google *shows* them to you. Google already collects all this data. And knowing what we know about Google, it&#x27;s laughable that they&#x27;d delete all the data they captured.<p>So, yeah, these settings just toggle whether YOU see it.<p>And I value having my data shown to me when I ask, so they&#x27;re on.
评论 #39660618 未加载
评论 #39662428 未加载
realprimohabout 1 year ago
Nope. I like having it on. Seeing the yearly review in Google Maps is amazing.