"I want AI to do my laundry and dishes so that I can do art and writing, not for AI to do my art and writing so that I can do my laundry and dishes." (C)
authorjmac
Udio's instrumentals seem to be better than Suno's, but the reverse is certainly true for vocals. God these tools are fun. Here's one I made a little earlier: <a href="https://suno.com/song/a6a53f5a-0c4f-4602-9654-404de0008719" rel="nofollow">https://suno.com/song/a6a53f5a-0c4f-4602-9654-404de0008719</a><p>Udio has some truly hilarious songs on the platform, I'm in tears listening to them with my buddy: <a href="https://www.udio.com/songs/sThXmpDS5Jt8e9cJgE6VQf" rel="nofollow">https://www.udio.com/songs/sThXmpDS5Jt8e9cJgE6VQf</a>
Less than three months after laughing in disbelief that it was now possible for an especially clever orchestration of AI models to instantly produce a pop song about my refrigerator, I’m almost nearly as amazed that there are now multiple entrants in this market. Feels singularity-ish.
It would be so much more useful for music producers if these audio gen services would create individual samples instead of trying to generate the entire composition.
Udio and Suno are both really bad at generating classical instrumental music that makes any melodic sense — the equivalent of drawing six-fingered people everywhere.
Funny to see how people getting ignored when they post their AI song. Personally against the movement because it’s basically killing the music culture.
People use it to generate huge number of neuro covers on different genres for some memetic song which gets funnier with each new one. Obviously not possible without AI because who would care to record a Rockabilly or Cossack choir for a meme?<p>I would like an AI which can just take an existing song and make it better quality (several knobs), or put new lyrics.
I very much enjoy udio, stable audio, suno and others.<p>- it seems like lately most human musicians write music when they are angry or depressed, not when they are in a good mood. These tools are able to come up with a neutral or positive sounding music much better than, say, youtube music search.<p>- it probably marks end to cookie-cutter music production (can you really tell the difference between modern edm tracks?). letting musicians play live music to smaller audiences. because of these tools, suddenly live perfomance is special again.<p>- unlike people, these tools are not afraid to be silly. creating ridiculous cat music is a lot of fun<p>- this is a great way to get ideas for your own music. no need to sprinkle ink on note sheets, like they used to.
Funny this was posted today. I spent some time this weekend playing around with Facebook’s MusicGen and had a ton of fun. I’m planning to use it to have a personal 24/7 radio station. Wonder what Udio is using under the hood.
Listening to some of these, it is so extraordinary to think an algo created and performed the music, all I find myself wondering is how much these songs resemble a particular song it was trained on.
Are there any models that I could run locally that would let me do this? I'm afraid I will go bankrupt buying credits for this if I'm not careful because I enjoy it so much!
Good project. Personally though, I have made a resolve to not listen to and support AI artists/musicians.(Provided I recognize the artist is using AI of course).
Is there people who really enjoy music generated by AI ?
I guess there always is an audience for poorly made things or poor quality things like industrial food with low quality ingredients.<p>Or maybe it’ll become so good it replaces artists altogether but what’s the point of it all ?
In a way, future generations might only know this new world where music is generated by machines and won’t be shocked ?<p>My take is that, music is so deeply rooted within us that even if AI can generate it, it’ll never replace the human experience and it might even push music made by humans to be a luxury and be more expensive. In a way it’s a good thing for artists if money goes in their pockets, on the other hand it might severed a part of the population who will not have access to culture anymore.
Or there might be more piracy but it might kill the artist way of living and their music in the process.<p>I though about more concerts and all, but as of today, I find it difficult and expensive to assist concerts from where I live. I requires many hours of travel, even taking hotels which makes the experience out of reach if required a few times a month.<p>My brother in law is a musician but he’s never been able to make a living out of it. They performed in places but in order to live and support his family he need a job which made it harder to live of his craft.<p>I’m curious to see which positive change this will bring
Whoever made this doesn't understand why people create and listen to music.<p>It's an interesting tech demo, but as an actual product that lives in the world, it's dystopian af.
Lmao I love this song. Cool site!<p><a href="https://www.udio.com/songs/tCghV579RUboW8BGyxnUNk" rel="nofollow">https://www.udio.com/songs/tCghV579RUboW8BGyxnUNk</a>