TE
TechEcho
Home24h TopNewestBestAskShowJobs
GitHubTwitter
Home

TechEcho

A tech news platform built with Next.js, providing global tech news and discussions.

GitHubTwitter

Home

HomeNewestBestAskShowJobs

Resources

HackerNews APIOriginal HackerNewsNext.js

© 2025 TechEcho. All rights reserved.

Ask HN: Why are Closed Captions so neglected by Netflix et al.?

2 pointsby SamineDylah8 months ago
Errors abound - Spelling mistakes, grammatical errors, weird punctuation artifacts (e.g. double quotes and single quotes redundantly used together), ascii symbol accidentally inserted, etc.<p>I know why closed captions on Amazon Prime, are <i>technically</i> poor (auto generated. under-funded, etc.).<p>But why are they so neglected by the media streaming giants in a <i>business</i> sense?<p>It is an offense to the hearing impaired.<p>It is transparent that they care little about accessibility.<p>It looks unprofessional.<p>Many people have subtitles on even if not hard of hearing. We see this terrible quality. It undermines the aesthetic beauty of the media.<p>So much time is spent on the shoot, the cinematography, staging, lighting, colors, angles, acting, editing. Hundreds of millions of dollars on a film, then failure to spend $1k on final proofreading&#x2F;testing. Why undermine it with a stupid mistake (&#x27;ins&#x27; instead of &#x27;in&#x27;).<p>The answer can&#x27;t simply be &#x27;cross platform compatibility issues&#x27; because it doesn&#x27;t explain the spelling mistakes, or the fact that these issues occur across multiple browsers&#x2F;platforms that each have billions of users.

2 comments

jfengel8 months ago
Remember that Netflix only needs to keep you subscribing. They don&#x27;t want to spend more than they have to. If you were canceling your subscription, they&#x27;d change something. If not, they&#x27;re perfectly happy with your money.<p>They do a <i>lot</i> of subtitles -- as many as a dozen, for each property. And they have a lot of content. They&#x27;ve clearly optimized the process for producing a lot of good-enough subtitles.<p>Adding $1k to each of those would be a lot of money. It&#x27;s a little surprising that there&#x27;s nobody pushing harder to get it done right on their prestige content, but the subtitling department is probably quite swamped with work as it is.
WheelsAtLarge8 months ago
It&#x27;s an expense they rather not have and not enough people complain about the quality. It&#x27;s also an after thought, not a part of the original production. If you think those are bad, take a look at the real time ones that are transcribed during live events. They are almost impossible to follow. I can hear but I like to keep them on because I sometime mishear but I feel for those that can&#x27;t hear. It&#x27;s a mess.
评论 #41502889 未加载